Beta 11 bug: Cannot search by BHSApparatusCriticus datatype

If I right-click on a BHSApparatusCriticus datatype (e.g. in BHS 2.0 SESB), and select the BHS Apparatus Criticus option and then choose "Search this resource", I get 0 hits. I should, of course, get one hit. This also makes it impossible to create visual filters based on this datatype.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Mark Barnes

Update: this search works if you switch it to a basic search, but there still seems no way of searching ranges (so there are now two bugs):

The right-click would perform a basic search, not a bible search.
There seems to be no way of searching for ranges (e.g. all BHSApparatusCriticus in Gen 16)

Melissa Snyder

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96281#Comment_96281

We'll look into these. I found that if you choose 'Search all open resources' from the context menu (even thought the BHS is only open resource), a Basic search is generated with one result.

Update: This data type reference is not in the 'bible' field, as it's not part of the Bible text, and so can't be found by a Bible search. A visual filter can be created for it by choosing 'Basic', not 'Bible', in the filter.

Mark Barnes

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96472#Comment_96472

Thanks Melissa,

My points were:

If I choose "Search this resource" from the context menu, Logos itself should determine whether to do a Bible Search or a basic search. I shouldn't have to correct it.
Regarding visual filters: For filters to work, you need to search by a range. It doesn't seem possible to search for a range with this datatype. If it is, can you confirm the syntax (e.g. to search for all apparatus in Genesis ch 16).

Melissa Snyder

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96640#Comment_96640

I'll go back to development with these questions.

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96640#Comment_96640

Regarding visual filters: For filters to work, you need to search by a range. It doesn't seem possible to search for a range with this datatype. If it is, can you confirm the syntax (e.g. to search for all apparatus in Genesis ch 16).

The BHS Critical Apparatus data type does not currently support specifying a range (e.g., "[Apparatus] Genesis" to find all apparatus marks in the book of Genesis).

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96640#Comment_96640

If I choose "Search this resource" from the context menu, Logos itself should determine whether to do a Bible Search or a basic search. I shouldn't have to correct it.

I've reported this bug. (It also affects pericope titles, preface text, etc. in English Bibles.)

Mark Barnes

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96684#Comment_96684

The BHS Critical Apparatus data type does not currently support specifying a range (e.g., "[Apparatus] Genesis" to find all apparatus marks in the book of Genesis).

Thanks, Bradley. Could we add it as a suggestion?

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/96809#Comment_96809

The BHS Critical Apparatus data type does not currently support specifying a range (e.g., "[Apparatus] Genesis" to find all apparatus marks in the book of Genesis).

Thanks, Bradley. Could we add it as a suggestion?

Yes, I already added that to the bug database, too. (Sorry to not be clear in my first post.)