Bug: Vine's Indexes give wrong information
First: A crash
Opened Vine's to G5467 and got a Parallel Resource set (PRS) that included DBL Aramaic, DBL Greek & DBL Hebrew. I clicked on DBL Aramaic and crash!
Tried this with G2367 and again G5467 but DBL Aram opened to the title page. Next time it crashed on G2367:
Why is PRS picking up an Aramaic index from Greek Strong's? H5288 is in the drop-down with G5467/G2367 (?) and when DBL Hebrew is selected in the PRS that's where it goes!
Second: Wrong Index Info
After using PRS in DBL Greek to get to Vine's I noticed the following in RHS pane & compared to a copy of Vine's in the LHS.
The Index info on RHS comes from DBL Greek!
This Index Information mix up also occurs in using a PRS to go from Vine's to DBL Greek.
Dave
===
Windows 11 & Android 13
Comments
-
I'm not able to reproduce any of these on my system; not the crash, the unexpected resources on the PRS list, or the variant resource information.
Regarding the second issue, to help me try to reproduce, do you have a user-defined Collection that includes these books with PRS enabled? Are there any advanced prioritization limits configured for Vine's or the DBL resources in Library?
0 -
Dave, I was also able to reproduce the index info and found several other lexicons keyed to DBL Greek included the Theological Dictionary of the New Testament and the Complete Word Study Dictionary New Testament.
0 -
It seems like DBL Greek uses the Goodrick/Kohlenberger numbering system. A system that came into use after 1990 and is an improvement upon Strong's numbering system. The only difference between DBL Greek and Greek GK is when you have multiple definations under a Greek Word. As far as I know when you use Parallel Resources the other resources do not jump to the 2nd defination. So it seems like several lexicons were tagged with both numbering systems.
The 3 systems are:
1. DBL Greek
2. GK Greek- Goodrick/Kohlenberger numbering system
3. Strong's Greek
0 -
Melissa Snyder said:
Regarding the second issue, to help me try to reproduce, do you have a user-defined Collection that includes these books with PRS enabled?
Sorry ... I was using my Lexicons collection :-
The crashes came from selecting DBL Aram in Lexicons.
Melissa Snyder said:Are there any advanced prioritization limits configured for Vine's or the DBL resources in Library?
Concise Heb & Aram Lexicon of the OT
Vine's (not restricted)
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
JohnBrumett said:
It seems like DBL Greek uses the Goodrick/Kohlenberger numbering system. A system that came into use after 1990 and is an improvement upon Strong's numbering system. The only difference between DBL Greek and Greek GK is when you have multiple definations under a Greek Word.
I hadn't been aware of the DBL #1, #2 indexing for meaning! But it doesn't seem to be used when keylinking from a resource eg. ESV reverse interlinear
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Dave Hooton said:
Sorry ... I was using my Lexicons collection
Thanks, I'm able to reproduce the crash after creating that collection and will submit a bug report. I don't have any advanced prioritization limits.
Update: This crash will be fixed in 4.0d (beta 3).
0 -
Melissa Snyder said:
Update: This crash will be fixed in 4.0d (beta 3).
Melissa
The crash is fixed but the aspect of displaying those resources still exists. Can you confirm that the two bug numbers in the wiki problem report cover both aspects?
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Dave Hooton said:
The crash is fixed but the aspect of displaying those resources still exists. Can you confirm that the two bug numbers in the wiki problem report cover both aspects?
The first bug case was for the crash, which was fixed. The second bug case was for the wrong indexes in Vine's About resource info, and that was also fixed in 4.0d B3.
The display of the invalid parallel resources won't be fixed at this time. In order to only show resources that definitely contain the reference, we would have to open all of the resources before showing them, which is unnecessarily slow.
I will edit the wiki report to reflect that both of those cases were fixed in 4.0d B3.
0 -
Thank you!
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Melissa Snyder said:
The display of the invalid parallel resources won't be fixed at this time. In order to only show resources that definitely contain the reference, we would have to open all of the resources before showing them, which is unnecessarily slow.
Opening all of the resources seems unnecessary to solve this problem. Mark Barnes has a good suggestion in this other thread which would fix it. Create a single headword index, and then you'd be able to look up whether a given headword was in a given resource without having to open that resource.
0 -
I appreciate all the work you all put into Logos as staff and users so my experience is just about effortless. I get so many blessings from my time in The Word.
May the Lord bless your work and your day!
"But you, be sober in all things, endure hardship, do the work of an evangelist, fulfill your ministry." 2 Timothy 4:5 (NASB)
0 -
Kaye Anderson said:
I appreciate all the work you all put into Logos as staff and users so my experience is just about effortless. I get so many blessings from my time in The Word.
May the Lord bless your work and your day!
Kaye,
Thank you for the reminder of the tremendous blessing we have in studying God's Word through Logos. Your post was an encouragement and joy to read. Blessings to all the staff and users who contribute to our Logos Bible Study experience.
Giving thanks and praise to our Great God
0
