BUG: Concordance generates incorrect count for Person Jesus

Dave Hooton

Concordance SBLGNT:

Biblical Entity > Kind:Person

Person        Concordance    Bible Search

Jesus           15012                   7427     ==> each entry/reference is duplicated

Paul               3259                   3258

God               3136                    3098

Disciples       1690                    1690

Peter               907                      907

Timothy           798                      798

SBLGNT  version 2020-12-23T21:21:53Z. Logos 9.9 SR-1

Lemma counts appear ok, but Sense "to say (express)"  generates 1948 vs. 2791.

Reference count for Louw-Nida agrees with Search at 137,741.

EDIT: the error with Person Jesus is repeated in NA28.

Andrew Batishko

Thanks for the report. I've created a case to investigate.

Stephen Brockett

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1189726#Comment_1189726

I just noticed this bug when looking in the concordance of the KJV (1900), and all the references to Jesus are repeated in the list. Any update on when this is likely to be resolved?

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1208724#Comment_1208724

I just noticed this bug when looking in the concordance of the KJV (1900), and all the references to Jesus are repeated in the list. Any update on when this is likely to be resolved?

Yes, the results for Kind:Person are still unreliable.

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

I suspect this may be happening because Jesus is being counted as two Subkinds, both God (Supernatural being) and Man.

Unfortunately, it's been a bug for a while: https://community.logos.com/forums/t/136772.aspx 

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1209128#Comment_1209128

I suspect this may be happening because Jesus is being counted as two Subkinds

Apart from Jesus, the counts still do not match a <Person ...> Search.

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1209133#Comment_1209133

Apart from Jesus, the counts still do not match a <Person ...> Search.

The Concordance shows nested tags as separate items (e.g., Paul in Rom 1:1); Bible Search flattens them into one hit.

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1209159#Comment_1209159

Apart from Jesus, the counts still do not match a <Person ...> Search.

The Concordance shows nested tags as separate items (e.g., Paul in Rom 1:1); Bible Search flattens them into one hit.

Thanks Bradley, - I had forgotten that bit of history.