Comments on the OTL and NTL commentaries

John Fidel

Any thoughts on these two commentary sets? Thinking of purchasing some of them, but would like some input. I have and extensive collection of commentaries already, so I would be taking advantage of the sales price if these offer something exception over NIC/NOT, WBC, etc.

Morgan

I picked them up in an L9 package and have enjoyed them.I particularly enjoyed the volume on John. If there is a specific passage I can get you a screenshot for comparison.

They don't bog you down in the details and tend to take larger chunks of text instead of just a single verse. I'd say they're closer to NIC/NOT than WBC. Of the 53 total volumes I have 16 included in my top commentary collections. For comparison I have 39/50 for NIC/NOT and 34/61 WBC in my top list.