Lexham Geographic Commentary on the Pentateuch - Tagging?

When I run a Factbook search on „Exodus (Event)“ or “Exodus (Biblical book)“, the Lexham Geographic Commentary on the Pentateuch doesn´t appear in any search in the following versions:

- Desktop (Win) Verbum 3.1.6

- iOS 36.0.1 (1)

- Android Verbum 36.0.0

Is this a tagging issue? The LGC Pentateuch is prioritized as my highest-ranking commentary on the Pentateuch.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

MJ. Smith

bump of posts that have not received an answer

MJ. Smith

Is this a tagging issue?

I believe there is an alignment process done by the data team but I am not certain.

Dave Hooton

When I run a Factbook search on „Exodus (Event)“ or “Exodus (Biblical book)“, the Lexham Geographic Commentary on the Pentateuch doesn´t appear in any search in the following versions:

Why would you expect the Event from a Commentary when it requires a Bible Dictionary (my top one)?
When I promote the LGC-Pent to #1 commentary it appears for the Bible Book. But it is not the one I would want because it opens to Ex 23 in a chapter with three other milestones on two bible books!

The LGC Pentateuch is prioritized as my highest-ranking commentary on the Pentateuch.

It has to be your top Commentary with Exodus.

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316635#Comment_1316635

Is this a tagging issue?

I believe there is an alignment process done by the data team but I am not certain.

For Bible Books it uses your top commentaries. But it is different where Bible Dictionaries are concerned e.g. for a specific Pharaoh it uses my top prioritized ones whilst Pharaoh (the Exodus) appeared not to until I prioritized one of them. But I was surprised it preferred Dictionary of the Bible 1909 (Hastings) over the 1911 edition (and my other prioritized books).

NichtnurBibelleser

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316657#Comment_1316657

I would think that the LGC would show up in the commentary section, which it does not at all.

NichtnurBibelleser

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316664#Comment_1316664

And it would be nice to have the LGC being considered in Smart Search when asking about the date of Exodus (event / book).

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316664#Comment_1316664

I would think that the LGC would show up in the commentary section, which it does not at all.

That section is "Books from your library", which you would expect to contain commentaries for an article on the book of Exodus. But I would not expect LGC or any other background commentary to be here. Even the Lexham Context Commentary does not appear.

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316665#Comment_1316665

And it would be nice to have the LGC being considered in Smart Search when asking about the date of Exodus (event / book).

If you use Books Search and narrow it to a collection, you will get results from the LGC without excessive scrolling!

Chris Heil

When I run a Factbook search on „Exodus (Event)“ or “Exodus (Biblical book)“, the Lexham Geographic Commentary on the Pentateuch doesn´t appear in any search in the following versions:

- Desktop (Win) Verbum 3.1.6

- iOS 36.0.1 (1)

- Android Verbum 36.0.0

Is this a tagging issue? The LGC Pentateuch is prioritized as my highest-ranking commentary on the Pentateuch.

This is a Logos tagging problem. The LGC Gospels has Factbook tags for the individual books of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John and not for Gospels. The LGC Pentateuch has a Factbook tag for the Pentateuch but not for the individual books. As a result if you search Factbook for Pentateuch, the LGC Pentateuch book will display but it will not display if you search for the individual books. On the other hand if you search Factbook for Gospels, the LGC Gospel book will not display but will display if you search for the individual books. The LGC Acts through Revelation is not tagged for any Factbook entries so searching for any of the individual books or for Epistles etc will bring back nothing. If you search for Bible verses in Factbook rather than books of the Bible, the three LGC Commentaries will display as it is using a milestone search rather than a Factbook tag.

Mattillo

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316768#Comment_1316768

I wonder why they don’t tag their own books better…

Kyle G. Anderson

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316769#Comment_1316769

I've passed along a request to get this updated to the resource production team.

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316768#Comment_1316768

This is a Logos tagging problem.

Thank you for the explanation, Chris

Mattillo

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1316837#Comment_1316837

Thank you, Kyle