Concise BDAG vs BDAG

1Cor10 31

Hi everyone!

I have both Concise BDAG and BDAG. Sometimes, I just want the list of verses with a given meaning/sense (I don't know the exact technical word for this). This seems to be much easier to accomplish with Concise BDAG rather than BDAG. So my question is: Are the references in Concise BDAG the same as in the regular BDAG? Or, does Concise BDAG give only a select list? More generally, what part of BDAG is made "concise" in Concise BDAG?

Thank you all

DMB

I guess I'm drawing a blank on a concise BDAG. There's a Concise Danker: https://www.logos.com/product/230314/the-concise-greek-english-lexicon-of-the-new-testament?queryId=d33b9c0443d1cfff5ed69cfe94a14b3e

If so, below is a comparison. It's a mixed bag, in that 'concise' is relative to senses and Bible refs both. Sometimes it combines BDAG senses. Keeps some references, drops others. Pick and choose.

Personally, Rick's https://www.logos.com/product/4580/lexham-analytical-lexicon-to-the-greek-new-testament?queryId=5d614fd27e2ab446a9a3ecceb556cd2e is far better, both having a more complete list, and grouping them relative to Lou Nida.

DMB

I guess I'm drawing a blank on a concise BDAG. There's a Concise Danker: https://www.logos.com/product/230314/the-concise-greek-english-lexicon-of-the-new-testament?queryId=d33b9c0443d1cfff5ed69cfe94a14b3e

If so, below is a comparison. It's a mixed bag, in that 'concise' is relative to senses and Bible refs both. Sometimes it combines BDAG senses. Keeps some references, drops others. Pick and choose.

Personally, Rick's https://www.logos.com/product/4580/lexham-analytical-lexicon-to-the-greek-new-testament?queryId=5d614fd27e2ab446a9a3ecceb556cd2e is far better, both having a more complete list, and grouping them relative to Lou Nida.

Tony Lyles

Does the entry for John 1:3, John 3:5 refers to the knowledge and power or to the ALL things under (B) listed above.

1Cor10 31

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/1355758#Comment_1355758

Thanks DMB. I guess I will stick to BDAG.

This makes me wonder: what is the purpose of Concise BDAG? When would people use the Concise version?

btw, I too like the Analytical Lexicon .