Shiloh and taxes?

Lew Worthington
Lew Worthington Member Posts: 1,622 ✭✭✭
edited March 2 in English Forum

I'm probably missing something simple. If I click "Shiloh" in my Bible to activate the "Info" panel with it, the display first shows me the topic of "Tribute". The AYBD has an article on Shiloh and this article does not mention tribute or taxes. It also has an article on Taxes and taxation, but this article does not mention Shiloh.

image.png

If I use the Factbook and start typing "Shiloh" in the field to look it up, "Tribute" is listed right below it.

Please help me understand what's going on here.

Tagged:

Comments

  • Dave Hooton
    Dave Hooton MVP Posts: 36,036
    edited March 1

    I get the same result for Shiloh in HCBDRU (HarperCollins), my #1 Bible Dictionary.

    Ephraim brings up a Definition of "Israelites" but it brings up "Ephraim" in AYBD (when made #1).

    It is too early for me to figure this out!

    Dave
    ===

    Windows 11 & Android 13

  • Bob Venem
    Bob Venem Member Posts: 96 ✭✭✭

    A Smart search in my library for "Shiloh and tribute" produced this:

    Shiloh is a term with multiple interpretations, primarily appearing in Genesis 49:10 as part of Jacob's blessing to Judah. One interpretation suggests it refers to a messianic figure or designation, with possible meanings including "the peaceful one" or "to whom dominion belongs"[1]. Another view interprets Shiloh as "until tribute is brought to him," based on dividing the word into "shay" (tribute) and "loh" (to him)[2]. The phrase "until Shiloh comes" has been translated various ways in different Bible versions, including "until tribute comes to him" and "until he to whom it belongs shall come"[3]. Shiloh was also a city where the tabernacle was set up, playing a significant role in Samuel's early years[1]. The term has been subject to much scholarly debate, with various interpretations and translations proposed over time[2][3].

    [1] Chuck D. Pierce and John Dickson, The Worship Warrior: Ascending in Worship, Descending in War (Ventura, CA: Regal, 2010), 153.
    [2] D. K. Stuart, “Shiloh,” in The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia, Revised, ed. Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Wm. B. Eerdmans, 1979–1988), 478.
    [3] Douglas Mangum, Miles Custis, and Wendy Widder, Genesis 12–50, Lexham Research Commentaries (Bellingham, WA: Lexham Press, 2013), Ge 49:1–33.

  • Lew Worthington
    Lew Worthington Member Posts: 1,622 ✭✭✭

    Thanks, guys. I can see there's debate about the expression in Gen. 49, and debate about Shiloh itself. It seems maybe things got a little sloppy in the tagging department. But to equate "Shiloh" with "tribute" because of Gen 49:10 is akin to equate "cow" with eternity because of the expression, "Until the cows come home".

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,596

    naughty error … its makes Logos misbehave. While the word "shiloh" may be related to tribute, the place name Shiloh is not.

    err59.png

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

Categories