Balancing Commentary Ratings

I use Bestcommentaries.com. I am trying to find commentary ratings that my balance any theological bias of this site. I also want to know the value of LOGOS best commentary ratings. Sometimes the LOGOS best commentaries listed are way down on the BC.com list. Any help appreciated.

Find more posts tagged with

Library

Accepted answers

Donovan R. Palmer

To date, I have not seen a way to do this, except to aggregate from a number of sources, then weigh up my own opinions against those views. Sometimes, I really swim against the flow of the crowd, other times I agree with some of these sources.

To a certain extent, this makes sense. What might be something I find useful or I deem as quality, will be different for someone else.

On a practical level, by default all of my resources are given two stars when they enter my library. This is my neutral rating. Then I bump it up and down depending on my experience and survey. I have a collection of my five star resources then built, that is the creme de la creme. (again in my view)

Your mileage may vary on this, but hopefully this is helpful.

Wendell ray

thank you so much for your response. This is my first experience with the community.

All comments

Donovan R. Palmer

To a certain extent, this makes sense. What might be something I find useful or I deem as quality, will be different for someone else.

Your mileage may vary on this, but hopefully this is helpful.

Wendell ray

thank you so much for your response. This is my first experience with the community.

Quick Links

More Questions

Recent Posts

Seeking prolific authors' titles within Legacy Libraries
Jay Adams is a good example of this problem: From this Logos.com search, there seem to be 70 Legacy Libraries that include works by Jay Adams. From this Logos.com search, there seem to be 159 English single-titles resources by Jay Adams. How can I find which and/or how many of his titles are in some particular Legacy…
Logos Thinks My Network Has a Problem. (+ a profanity problem)
Logos sold me a profanity-laced book (think the worst words you can think of). Logos would not let me return the book because my order was a smidgen over 30 days old. Fair enough. But now I have this junk in my library. Distaste is growing. My confidence in Logos' quality isn't there anymore. But here is the real reason…
Logos Thinks my Network settings are Bad
Now what? I am trying to return a book with some nasty profanity. Attempting to contact someone on chat, I get this:
Power Lookup Resources Absent
My Power Lookup tool is showing only a very limited number of resources available to it (only 2, both Lexham Lexicons, when I look up Greek words in the NT). Is there a solution to this problem? All my resources are indexed (up to date). Thanks.
Can Fred Dickason, Angels: Elect and Evil be brought back
@Rick Mansfield (Logos) is there any chance this book can come back for sale in logos? It used to be for sale and it is hyperlinked in one of my systematic theology books but is no longer for sale. I see that it is a moody title and I know those went away for a little bit, but I thought they were all back.