Bug: Morph. Search Double Hits
The morph. search is reporting a single instance of a middle verb in a particular verse twice. I saw this behavior at 8:9, 11:16, 26:45, 27:34, 27:52 and 28:13 in the report. (This issue might already be known, but I wanted to make sure.) For example:
Comments
-
If you look at the results you will see that the word has two morphologies eg. Matt 27:34 satisfies @VR[^A]
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
In terms of the exclusion of the lemma the query is evaluated as:
... @VL[^A] OR @VF[MU] OR (@VA[MU] ANDNOT lemma:ἀποκρίνομαι@VAP)
because AND'd terms are executed before OR'd terms. So the query only excludes verses in which @VA[MU] occurs with the lemma! If you wanted to exclude occurrences of the lemma with ALL the previous terms you need
(... @VL[^A] OR @VF[MU] OR @VA[MU]) ANDNOT lemma:ἀποκρίνομαι@VAP
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Dave Hooton said:
the word has two morphologies
Dave, this seems to be the same issue you and I have both posted about previously.
0 -
Brian Davidson said:
Dave, this seems to be the same issue you and I have both posted about previously.
They are (slightly) different issues. The previous post is a bug with counting the hits of a lemma@morph search. The double hits from your morph search above arise because two morphologies are assigned to the one word. I would have been content with that until I tried a couple of queries:-
RI GNT RI = ESV, LEB, etc GNT = LGNTI, NA27
@VR[^A] 2 2 for a word with alternative morpholgies
lemma:μίγνυμι@VR[^A] 1 3 in Matt 27:34 where lemma has alternative morpholgies
lemma:γράφω@VR[^A] 1 2 in Matt 27:37 where lemma has one morpholgy (NOTE UBS4, Byz & Scrivener 1881 give 1 result)
Clearly Logos aren't sure how these results should be counted!
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Dave Hooton said:
Clearly Logos aren't sure how these results should be counted!
On reflection, the results for @VR[^A] are correct because it gives the number of occurrences of that term!
The lemma@morph results should always be 1 because the question is HOW MANY lemmas satisfy that morphology. If you want to dig deeper then Analysis will provide the details.
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
