NICOT/NICNT- old and replacement volumes

I was please to see that the NICNT prepub already includes the replacement volumes of 1 & 2 Thessalonians by Fee (published July 15th, 2009)

However, many of us find some of the old volumes quite valuable (Murray on Romans, Ridderbos on Galatians, Hughes on 2 Corinthians, and of course Bruce on 1 & 2 Thessalonians).

I understand that the publisher has a lot to say in the matter, but I would like to see the NICOT/NICNT set follow the example of the forthcoming TOTC/TNTC set and include old volumes that are still valuable along with the replacement volumes (i.e. Esther by Baldwin and the replacement by Reid).

alternatively, the old volumes (only the good ones [;)]) could be offered as an attractive prepub add on of 5 or so volumes

Alain

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Bohuslav Wojnar

I was please to see that the NICNT prepub already includes the replacement volumes of 1 & 2 Thessalonians by Fee (published July 15th, 2009)

However, many of us find some of the old volumes quite valuable (Murray on Romans, Ridderbos on Galatians, Hughes on 2 Corinthians, and of course Bruce on 1 & 2 Thessalonians).

Sounds like a very good suggestion, however I tend to think "the newer, the better". I don't claim it is better attitude, just I noticed I have this tendency.

Ted Hans

I would like to see the NICOT/NICNT set follow the example of the forthcoming TOTC/TNTC set and include old volumes that are still valuable along with the replacement volumes (i.e. Esther by Baldwin and the replacement by Reid).

I have suggested this previously to Logos. It will be nice to have all the older volumes not just the good ones[;)]

Well my friend it was L. Morris who wrote the Thessalonians volume in NICNT, Bruce wrote the Thessalonians volume in WBC.[;)]

Ted

1 & 2 Thessalonians by Leon Morris

The New International Commentary on the New Testament - Gospel of Luke by Norval
Geldenhuys

Paul's Second Epistle to
the Corinthians Philip Edgcumbe
Hughes.(NICNT)

The Epistle to the
Romans by John Murray (NICNT)

Epistle of the Galatians by Herman N. Ridderbos (NICNT)
The Epistles of Paul to
the Philippians and to Philemon by Jac J. Muller (NICNT)
John: The Gospel of
Belief by Merrill C. Tenney (NICNT)

Ephesians and Colossians
by E.K. Simpson and F.F. Bruce (NICNT)
Epistles of James and John by
Alexander Ross (NICNT)
The First Epistle to the
Corinthians by F.W. Grosheide.(NICNT)

Alain Maashe

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4347#Comment_4347

Well my friend it was L. Morris who wrote the Thessalonians volume in NICNT, Bruce wrote the Thessalonians volume in WBC.

Ted,

You are right, I stand corrected

shame on me, especially since I used it quite extensively a few weeks ago [:'(]

Alain

Matthew C Jones

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4328#Comment_4328

I was please to see that the NICNT prepub already includes the replacement volumes of 1 & 2 Thessalonians by Fee (published July 15th, 2009)

However, many of us find some of the old volumes quite valuable (Murray on Romans, Ridderbos on Galatians, Hughes on 2 Corinthians, and of course Bruce on 1 & 2 Thessalonians).

Sounds like a very good suggestion, however I tend to think "the newer, the better". I don't claim it is better attitude, just I noticed I have this tendency.

YES, yes, yes, How about including everything we can get , both new & old.[:P]

Ted Hans

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4360#Comment_4360

YES, yes, yes, How about including everything we can get , both new & old.

My thoughts exactly.[Y]

Sir T.

Edwin Bowden

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4361#Comment_4361

I would prefer to have the newest volumes as part of the complete set and the older versions available as individual volumes that could be purchased optionally.

There's no reason to add to the cost of an expensive set unnecessarily.

Alain Maashe

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4361#Comment_4361

YES, yes, yes, How about including everything we can get , both new & old.

My thoughts exactly.

Sir T.

Through bad (or is it good?) eisegesis and blatant disregard of the context I can even bring biblical to support the matter

"Every teacher ...is like a homeowner who brings from his storeroom new gems of truth as well as old." (

While the scholarship might be dated in the older volumes, many of them are pregnant with theological reflection that has stood the test of time

and if there is an opportunity to get them at a bargain price, it would be foolish to refuse

Alain

Mat 13:52 NLT) [:D]

Ted Hans

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4385#Comment_4385

Through bad (or is it good?) eisegesis and blatant disregard of the context I can even bring biblical to support the matter

"Every teacher ...is like a homeowner who brings from his storeroom new gems of truth as well as old." (

While the scholarship might be dated in the older volumes, many of them are pregnant with theological reflection that has stood the test of time

and if there is an opportunity to get them at a bargain price, it would be foolish to refuse

Alain
Mat 13:52 NLT)

"if there is an opportunity to get them at a bargain price, it would be foolish to refuse" Is Alain also a mind reader? Seeing that when Logos offer products in bundle it is heavily discounted i will not want to miss out. Individual volumes sale comes with a hefty price tag, i prefer the cheaper option.[:D]

Every Blessing,

Ted

Matthew C Jones

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4389#Comment_4389

Yep, Logos does know how to sweeten the deal. [Y] [H]

Ted Hans

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4367#Comment_4367

I would prefer to have the newest volumes as part of the complete set and the older versions available as individual volumes that could be purchased optionally.

There's no reason to add to the cost of an expensive set unnecessarily.

You need not worry, any addition to the NICNT/NICOT before it ships will cost you nothing if you have already Pre-ordered, at least that is what has happened previously. Individual volumes sales are highly priced, another way round this could be another collection for the older volumes.[:)]

Ted.

(‾◡◝)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/4391#Comment_4391

I was pleased to see Dan Pritchett's comments regarding the switchover for current Pradis owners to Logos(http://community.logos.com/forums/t/2361.aspx). I am also pleased to see that NICOT and NICOT is shipping soon.

But all of this makes me wonder if we ever got an official answer from Dan or anyone else at Logos regarding the older, no-longer-published volumes of NICNT/OT i.e., Murray, Ridderbos, Hughes, et al?