A PG on Matt 4:1-11 has both Holman "Commentaries" open to Matt 4:17-25 -->
Holman Concise Bible Commentary version 2009-10-26
Holman Bible Handbook version 2009-10-27
ie. they do not jump to 3:1-4:16!
A PG on Matt 4:1-11 has both Holman "Commentaries" open to Matt 4:17-25 --> Holman Concise Bible Commentary version 2009-10-26 Holman Bible Handbook version 2009-10-27 ie. they do not jump to 3:1-4:16!
CONFIRMED
Neither the Holman Concise Bible Commentary nor the Holman Bible Handbook opens to Matt 4:1-11 from the PG (nor to the section that contains those verses, which you cite above). I've seen this behavior with some other 'broad-stroke' commentaries, and just thought it was normal behavior for Logos materials. But you're right, it should default to the section before, rather than the section after the reference, when the reference is not explicit in the article heading.
(However I also tried opening the Holman New Testament Commentary from the PG and it did open to Matt 4:1-11.)
Some resources act like proper commentaries!
Some resources are proper commentaries. [;)]
The problem comes when the citation is not specifically indexed in the target resource. So the Holman Concise goes to the first index that contains the correct chapter number, or the first one following the citation. It would be nice if it would go to the citation previous, if an exact match is not found.
It would be nice if it would go to the citation previous, if an exact match is not found.
I agree. I also wonder if it's possible to open to any verse or range of verses that are within the range of the PG. E.g. I did a PG for Genesis 18:1-21. the Bible Knowledge Commentary opened to 2 Kings 18:13-16. The BKC is indexed as follows:
18:1-818:9-15
18:16-2118:22-33
Why couldn't it have jumprd to any of the first three which all fall within the PG range?
I did a PG for Genesis 18:1-21. the Bible Knowledge Commentary opened to 2 Kings 18:13-16.
Now that's an interesting bug, jumping to a section of 2 Kings labelled Genesis!
I also wonder if it's possible to open to any verse or range of verses that are within the range of the PG. E.g. I did a PG for Genesis 18:1-21. the Bible Knowledge Commentary opened to 2 Kings 18:13-16.
The problem here is not with the passage guide, but with the tagging in the BKC resource. A small section of 2 Kings, beginning on pg 573 of volume 1 is incorrectly tagged as Genesis.
I cannot confirm this. When I run a PG on Matthew 4:1-11, both the Holman Concise Bible Commentary, and the Holman Bible Handbook open to Matthew 3:1-4:16. I'm running 5.1.0.0943 on Windows.
A PG on Matt 4:1-11 has both Holman "Commentaries" open to Matt 4:17-25 --> Holman Concise Bible Commentary version 2009-10-26 Holman Bible Handbook version 2009-10-27 ie. they do not jump to 3:1-4:16! I cannot confirm this. When I run a PG on Matthew 4:1-11, both the Holman Concise Bible Commentary, and the Holman Bible Handbook open to Matthew 3:1-4:16. I'm running 5.1.0.0943 on Windows.
Mark, that original thread was from 2009. It works for me now too.
Mark, that original thread was from 2009.
[:$]
