Are these two works basically the same?

Milkman

Are these two works basically the same or is there is big difference? And which one would you chose if you only had the case for one?

David Beale.

https://www.logos.com/product/37459/historical-theology-in-depth

Gregg Allison

https://www.logos.com/product/26732/historical-theology-an-introduction-to-christian-doctrine

elnwood

Allison's book is organized by topic like a systematic theology, and its chapters are intended to line up with Grudem's Systematic Theology.

I haven't read Beale, but his is organized chronologically, like historical theologies usually are.

I would get Allison's if you like Grudem.