Carson or Fee?

It's always hard to decide how to vote in March Madness because you never know which volumes will be included. What do you guys think, will Fee's NICNT volumes be included? Which Carson volumes will be included? I'd like Justification and Variegated Nomism and his volume on Greek accents, but I don't know what the chances are that they'd include these. I voted for Wright just so I could get his book on Resurrection (I picked up the two earlier volumes from the series last year), but then that book ended up not even being available. What will it be for Carson and Fee? Any chance we can predict what the offerings will be? Some NICNT volumes have been made available through March Madness but some have not.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

abondservant

I'm going with not Carson. He won last year, and I'd like a chance to get the deep discount on someone else this time through

Bruce Dunning

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/577965#Comment_577965

I'm going with not Carson. He won last year, and I'd like a chance to get the deep discount on someone else this time through

[Y]

David Paul

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/577967#Comment_577967

Vote rigging...doubts about what may or may not be included...

It's a good time with good reason to consider my alternative suggestions to MM, aka March Gladness!

David Sloan

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/577969#Comment_577969

I'm still disillusioned by the decision not to include Moo's Romans volume in here. My guess is that they'll include only one of Fee's NICNT volumes. I don't know if they'll include the two Carson volumes I mentioned above, but I'm leaning Carson just in case I can pick up one of these two works. I still dream that someday I may be able to buy all of NICOT/NICNT, in which case a Fee discount today doesn't help me much.

Rosie Perera

What do you guys think, will Fee's NICNT volumes be included?

None of us has any idea. So what we think doesn't matter. It's all just useless speculation.

David Sloan

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/578419#Comment_578419

It's all just useless speculation.

If anyone paid attention to what was offered last year that might be an indicator. Or if anyone has paid close enough attention to say what percentage of NICOT/NICNT volumes have been available so far this year that might be an indicator. I know both of Waltke's NICOT Proverbs volumes were made available, and Morris's NICNT John volume and Marshall's NICNT Johannine Epistles were also made available. Moo's NICNT Romans was not made available. Are there other NICOT/NICNT volumes that were not included?

Also, does anyone remember when Logos came out with Justification and Variegated Nomism or with Greek Accents? If these were already available in Logos last year and were not made available in the sale, they probably won't be made available again this year. But if these are new Logos resources perhaps there's a chance.

So I don't think it's "useless speculation." I think we can make educated guesses here. (Though I admit that I guessed Wright's Resurrection of the Son of God would be available and alas, it's not.)

ChelseaFC

I'm going with Fee just for someone different to possibly win/advance.

Rosie Perera

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/578435#Comment_578435

It's all just useless speculation.

If anyone paid attention to what was offered last year that might be an indicator. Or if anyone has paid close enough attention to say what percentage of NICOT/NICNT volumes have been available so far this year that might be an indicator. I know both of Waltke's NICOT Proverbs volumes were made available, and Morris's NICNT John volume and Marshall's NICNT Johannine Epistles were also made available. Moo's NICNT Romans was not made available. Are there other NICOT/NICNT volumes that were not included?

Also, does anyone remember when Logos came out with Justification and Variegated Nomism or with Greek Accents? If these were already available in Logos last year and were not made available in the sale, they probably won't be made available again this year. But if these are new Logos resources perhaps there's a chance.

So I don't think it's "useless speculation." I think we can make educated guesses here. (Though I admit that I guessed Wright's Resurrection of the Son of God would be available and alas, it's not.)

Well, maybe it's not useless to you, but it's speculation nonetheless. Logos has no obligation to repeat the patterns of last year, or alter them for that matter. They can do whatever they want with this.

DAL

If Fee loses to Carson, his works will still be 50% off, so if NICNT 1 Cor. and the other Fee volumes are offered I'll get them no matter what. If he wins at 2nd then that'll be 60% off and if he wins at 1st then 75% - either discount is great at this point. Think about it, how many of us want a certain commentary included in the twitter daily deal, then if Fee stays at 50% off then pretend is the twitter daily deal you've been asking for. Now it's all a matter of Logos giving us the Fee titles (and/or Carson titles that we want/need and not they ones that don't sell as much or whatever the criteria is for choosing what goes on sale and what doesn't).

DAL

ChelseaFC

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/578435#Comment_578435

It's all just useless speculation.

If anyone paid attention to what was offered last year that might be an indicator. Or if anyone has paid close enough attention to say what percentage of NICOT/NICNT volumes have been available so far this year that might be an indicator. I know both of Waltke's NICOT Proverbs volumes were made available, and Morris's NICNT John volume and Marshall's NICNT Johannine Epistles were also made available. Moo's NICNT Romans was not made available. Are there other NICOT/NICNT volumes that were not included?

Also, does anyone remember when Logos came out with Justification and Variegated Nomism or with Greek Accents? If these were already available in Logos last year and were not made available in the sale, they probably won't be made available again this year. But if these are new Logos resources perhaps there's a chance.

So I don't think it's "useless speculation." I think we can make educated guesses here. (Though I admit that I guessed Wright's Resurrection of the Son of God would be available and alas, it's not.)

Justification title came out around the summer.

Bruce Dunning

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/578476#Comment_578476

So it looks like Carson is going to win over Fee unless things change soon.

Can anything stop Carson from winning the overall contest again?

Evan Boardman

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/578611#Comment_578611

His work on Matthew or the gospels wasn't available last year and if it isn't available this year, I'm gonna vote for him again next year.