Manton's James and Jude commentaries are not monographs

Manton's James and Jude commentaries are not monographs, but they are tagged as such in The Complete Works of Thomas Manton, Volume 4 and Volume 5.

The James commentary is also included in the Classic Commentaries and Studies on the Epistle of James, presumably tagged like a commentary, but I don't think I should have to buy it again to have it tagged like a commentary, should I?

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Dave Hooton

The James commentary is also included in the Classic Commentaries and Studies on the Epistle of James, presumably tagged like a commentary, but I don't think I should have to buy it again to have it tagged like a commentary, should I?

A resource cannot exist as both a commentary and a monograph. If you think it should be a commentary then create an entry in http://wiki.logos.com/Metadata_correction_proposals#Incorrect_Types, to have it actioned by Logos.

Liam

I agree. I have this resource as well, but in order to use it I have been creating reference notes for each verse with links to it. It would be much more useful to me if it was tagged as a commentary.

Kevin A Lewis

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/587992#Comment_587992

So added - now it's over to Logos.

Shalom

fgh

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/587992#Comment_587992

If you think it should be a commentary then create an entry in http://wiki.logos.com/Metadata_correction_proposals#Incorrect_Types, to have it actioned by Logos.

If it isn't tagged as a commentary, it isn't a metadata issue, so it shouldn't be on that page, it should be on Books Missing Bible Verse Indexing.

(To see whether it's a metadata issue or a tagging one, open the book, click on the circled 'i' at the top right, and scroll down to the Index section. If it has a Bible Index, it should be on the Metadata page, if it doesn't have one, it should be on the Index page.)

Dave Hooton

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/588103#Comment_588103

If it isn't tagged as a commentary, it isn't a metadata issue, so it shouldn't be on that page, it should be on Books Missing Bible Verse Indexing.

My excuse is not having this particular resource! However, a few suggestions there are (by design) missing so many bible verses/chapters that you can see why it was not indexed and why it is a monograph, plus they have a TOC to navigate to a particular spot in the bible.