Daily Office

DominicM
DominicM Member Posts: 2,995 ✭✭✭
edited November 2024 in English Forum

I know MJ submitted some datafiles a bit ago, but has anything happened with them, was looking for a daily office for the forthcoming year, but guess I will need to pull my Book of Common Prayer out..

Never Deprive Anyone of Hope.. It Might Be ALL They Have

Comments

  • Floyd  Johnson
    Floyd Johnson Member Posts: 4,002 ✭✭✭

    DominicM said:

    I know MJ submitted some datafiles a bit ago, but has anything happened with them, was looking for a daily office for the forthcoming year, but guess I will need to pull my Book of Common Prayer out..

    You might want to check out the ESV On-Line Study Bible at 

               http://www.esvonline.org/devotions/bcp/

    It includes the daily office as one of the resources available to assist in your study.

    A search of Google for :"Daily Office" will return a number of sites that suggest readings from the Daily Office.  Though they are non linked to LOGOS directly [:(], they provide enough information that you will not need to pull down your Book of Common Prayer.

     

     

    Blessings,
    Floyd

    Pastor-Patrick.blogspot.com

  • Rebecca RG
    Rebecca RG Member Posts: 17 ✭✭

    THANK YOU!  Thank you, Logos!  I've been waiting for this!

  • Floyd  Johnson
    Floyd Johnson Member Posts: 4,002 ✭✭✭

    Blessings,
    Floyd

    Pastor-Patrick.blogspot.com

  • DominicM
    DominicM Member Posts: 2,995 ✭✭✭

    Thanks, and I love the price even more.. Bless you

    Never Deprive Anyone of Hope.. It Might Be ALL They Have

  • Dan Francis
    Dan Francis Member Posts: 5,336 ✭✭✭

    All I really wanted. Thank you So Much LOGOS for making this resource available (I would gladdly have paid the 4.99, but am Happy to see it;s being made free for now anyhow).

     

    -Dan

     

  • tom
    tom Member Posts: 3,213 ✭✭✭

    The daily RCL is not the same as the daily lectionary.  I would like the daily office from the RCL.

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

     I would like the daily office from the RCL.

    I am not aware of an RCL daily office if you mean revised common lectionary. It's my understanding that there is a strong Lutheran component to the daily lectionary as a result of Gail Ranshaw's precursor. I believe that the readings are intended for whatever service the pastor chooses. The daily RCL is closely tied to the Sunday and Feast day RCL

    For the Catholic lectionary, the Sunday lectionary, daily lectionary and daily office each follow their own logic.

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • tom
    tom Member Posts: 3,213 ✭✭✭

    Sorry for the confusion MJ.  I use the RCL daily lectionary for my morning and evening prayers.

  • Dan Francis
    Dan Francis Member Posts: 5,336 ✭✭✭

    Sorry for the confusion MJ.  I use the RCL daily lectionary for my morning and evening prayers.

    After using the RCL Daily for 3 years I am very happy to get back to the 2 year Lectionary I had used for so many years. For me the Lectionary readings of the daily office (Book of Common Prayer, Lutheran Book of Worship, Book of Alternative Services of Anglican Church Canada), works better for me. it has a better flow for me.

    -Dan

  • James Matichuk
    James Matichuk Member Posts: 114 ✭✭

    Thanks for this! I have been using the reading plan, but am excited to use this in the coming year, particularly since the lectionary gives me more Psalms and I have been trying to focus there. 

     

     

  • Fr A
    Fr A Member Posts: 2 ✭✭

    Hello MJ, I can't recall if I've contacted you in a forum or not - so sorry if this is a repeat.

    I'm searching forums / google for any method to get an Orthodox Lectionary into Logos.  I'm willing to do any and all work as this would be tremendously useful for me.  I created a Lectionary Resource that Logos 4 was able to load on my homepage, but none of the reading links (or any other text besides the date) shows up. I'm a programmer and IT specialist (in addition to priest), so the syntax / code does not scare me - and I will probably script the bulk of the work once I have the format.

    But first - Is there an example format of a lectionary that loads properly in Logos somewhere?

    Thanks,
    Fr Aleksa

    (Nice quote by Bishop Hilarion, by the way - I got to know him as Deacon when he visited my seminary a few times. Brilliant - doesn't talk much though.  :-) 

  • Ken McGuire
    Ken McGuire Member Posts: 2,074 ✭✭✭

    I'm not MJ, but I did the work for the BCP daily office lectionary for Libronix.  That was basically XML.  But they changed the way they do things for Logos 4.  Now lectionaries are books, and I am not aware of any personal book lectionaries. They have a bit of information on this on the wiki http://wiki.logos.com/Personal_Books - probably enough to try something simple and learn as you go.

    To be honest, I am still not all that happy with the way Logos 4 does lectionaries - the old Lectionary viewer was much better for worship planning, IMHO.

    The Gospel is not ... a "new law," on the contrary, ... a "new life." - William Julius Mann

    L8 Anglican, Lutheran and Orthodox Silver, Reformed Starter, Academic Essentials

    L7 Lutheran Gold, Anglican Bronze

  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    Welcome to the forums! Since it's still fairly early in the day where MJ lives I'll start on an answer, and then she can add a much better one later.

    I created a Lectionary Resource that Logos 4 was able to load on my homepage, but none of the reading links (or any other text besides the date) shows up.

    I presume you did it as a Personal Book, and that you have seen the Wiki page for Personal Books.

    Is there an example format of a lectionary that loads properly in Logos somewhere?

    The only lectionary PB I'm aware of currently is a Messianic Jewish one. It doesn't have the actual readings, like e g Logos' Catholic Lectionary [sort of] has, but only a linked list of them. In the resource it looks like this:

    image

    When I try prioritizing it I see what I presume you saw:

    image

    So that isn't going to be much help for you, I'm afraid. Hopefully MJ has managed to get at least some of her many lectionaries in progress to 'load properly'. Don't get your hopes up too high, though. Even Logos own lectionaries leave an awful lot to be desired. But the more people that express their interest, the more likely it is that we can get Logos to prioritize these issues.

    If you do manage to get it to work, and there are no copyright issues, I hope you'll post it in the Files forum. I'd be interested. And given that Logos is working on the first part of Popular Patristics, I imagine there will soon be quite a few others that are too. In fact, given that, and provided the copyright isn't a problem, it might even be possible to get Logos to release an Orthodox Lectionary as a proper resource, as a kind of good will gesture towards new Orthodox users. Increasing that customer base would do wonders for resources like the Patrologia Cursus Completus, Series Graeca, Part 1 (vols. 1–18), which isn't exactly moving fast right now.

    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • Louis St. Hilaire
    Louis St. Hilaire Member, Logos Employee Posts: 513

    To get the lectionary information to show up on the home page, you need milestones for the YearMonthDay data type and you need to mark up the content with the following fields (as appropriate): reading, season, day (i.e. liturgical occasion), year, date.

    Here's an example of a couple of days marked up with the appropriate milestones and fields.

    [[@YearMonthDay:April 24, 2012]]
    {{field-on:date}}TUESDAY, APRIL 24, 2012{{field-off:date}} | {{field-on:season}}EASTER{{field-off:season}}
    {{field-on:day}}TUESDAY OF THE THIRD WEEK OF EASTER{{field-off:day}}
    {{field-on:year}}YEARS 1 & 2{{field-off:year}}

                  First Reading       {{field-on:reading}}Acts 7:51–8:1a{{field-off:reading}}
                  Response       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 31:6a{{field-off:reading}}
                  Psalm       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 31:3c–4, 6, 7b, 8a, 17, 21ab{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel Acclamation       {{field-on:reading}}John 6:35ab{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel       {{field-on:reading}}John 6:30–35{{field-off:reading}}

    [[@YearMonthDay:April 25, 2012]]
    {{field-on:date}}WEDNESDAY, APRIL 25, 2012{{field-off:date}} |{{field-on:season}} FEAST{{field-off:season}}
    {{field-on:day}}SAINT MARK, EVANGELIST{{field-off:day}}
    {{field-on:year}}YEARS 1 & 2{{field-off:year}}

                  First Reading       {{field-on:reading}}1 Peter 5:5b–14{{field-off:reading}}
                  Response       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 89:2{{field-off:reading}}
                  Psalm       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 89:2–3, 6–7, 16–17{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel Acclamation       {{field-on:reading}}1 Corinthians 1:23a–24b{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel       {{field-on:reading}}Mark 16:15–20{{field-off:reading}}

    I've tested this in the current beta and it appears to work as expected. (Previously, there was a bug that prevented Personal Book lectionaries from showing up on the homepage.)

    The text of the readings in Logos lectionaries is inserted with dynamic text. Dynamic text functionality is planned, but not implemented for Personal Books, but the homepage functionality does not depend on the dynamic text.

    fgh said:

    provided the copyright isn't a problem, it might even be possible to get Logos to release an Orthodox Lectionary as a proper resource

    Absolutely--particularly if we can determine what lectionary would be most in demand and obtain that.

  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    This is a really helpful post, Louis. Thanks a lot!

    Dynamic text functionality is planned (...) for Personal Books

    [Y]

    particularly if we can determine what lectionary would be most in demand

    That is, of course, always an issue when it comes to the Orthodox. [:D] Not that I have any idea how much readings vary between the different churches, but I imagine it may be quite a bit.

    (I hope someone who's good at Wiki editing sees this post and uses it to update the Personal Books page.)

    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • NB.Mick
    NB.Mick MVP Posts: 16,213

    I've tested this in the current beta and it appears to work as expected.

    Without being much into Lectionaries, I just copied your example into a word doc and PB compiled it. It looks like this on the ribbon:

    image

    and opens like this:

    image

    and this:

    image

    Imho only the first scripture works

    5618.Lectionary sample.docx

    Maybe someone can have an example that really does it (I'm still contemplating making the Moravian texts/Daily Texts/Watchwords/Losungen into a PB Lectionary)

     

     

    Have joy in the Lord! Smile

  • Louis St. Hilaire
    Louis St. Hilaire Member, Logos Employee Posts: 513

    Sorry, those links aren't from my source, but were automatically inserted in the forum post. You picked them up (and other formatting) when you copied and pasted.

    Here's the actual file I used:

    6837.PersonalLectionary.docx

    (Note that I'm just demonstrating the milestones and fields that are particular to lectionaries, and haven't done anything with formatting or other PB features.)

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

    I'm searching forums / google for
    any method to get an Orthodox Lectionary into Logos.

    I have some options in Excel spreadsheets. Now that Louis says the PB will support lectionaries, I give it a try. I'd been holding off even trying again until the PB sharing mechanism was in place.

    fgh said:

    That is, of course, always an issue when it comes to the Orthodox.

    Not all that much more than Catholic as our readings vary by rite or did - I've not kept track of the Ambrosian fiasco.

    (Nice quote by Bishop Hilarion,

    Isn't it - the Orthodox are very good at quotability in the best possible sense.

    I am still not all that happy with the way Logos 4 does lectionaries

    Nor am I. But I do think Louis St. Hiliare did a very good job of getting the best out of a flawed design and I have confidence that he now understands the issues so that L5 will have a better lectionary design.

    (Previously, there was a bug that prevented Personal Book

    This is good news. I'll try it out and see how well it works. The dynamic text bit, however, is still a major annoyance so I'll only say we're halfway there for creating basic lectionaries.

    you need milestones for the YearMonthDay
    data type and you need to mark up the content with the following fields
    (as appropriate): reading, season, day (i.e. liturgical occasion),
    year, date.

    Louis, What is the format for the second portion of the lectionary which gives the readings for the liturgical date independent of any secular date? (Yes, I know I can experiment but I'm feeling lazy.)

    After using the RCL Daily for 3 years I am very happy to get back to

    I'm glad to hear the feedback and am not surprised. Few of the modern invented lectionaries have the strength of the lectionaries that evolved over time.

    I have to dash off to visit Mother but will put out a simple lectionary in the next couple of days. After I see how it works on short lectionaries, I try to at least make a base for an Orthodox lectionary.

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • NB.Mick
    NB.Mick MVP Posts: 16,213

    Here's the actual file I used:

    6837.PersonalLectionary.docx">http://community.logos.com/cfs-file.ashx/__key/CommunityServer.Discussions.Components.Files/77/6837.PersonalLectionary.docx:550:0]

    (Note that I'm just demonstrating the milestones and fields that are particular to lectionaries, and haven't done anything with formatting or other PB features.)

    Thank you so much, this works perfectly!

    Have joy in the Lord! Smile

  • Louis St. Hilaire
    Louis St. Hilaire Member, Logos Employee Posts: 513

    MJ. Smith said:

    Nor am I. But I do think Louis St. Hiliare did a very good job of getting the best out of a flawed design and I have confidence that he now understands the issues so that L5 will have a better lectionary design.

    We're working on acquiring more liturgical books (stay tuned), so supporting liturgical calendars with data types will soon become much more worthwhile. This will be a first step in making the application itself "understand" liturgical data.

    MJ. Smith said:

    you need milestones for the YearMonthDay data type and you need to mark up the content with the following fields (as appropriate): reading, season, day (i.e. liturgical occasion), year, date.

    Louis, What is the format for the second portion of the lectionary which gives the readings for the liturgical date independent of any secular date? (Yes, I know I can experiment but I'm feeling lazy.)

    It's identical to what I've given, but without the YearMonthDay milestone and calendar date, and with YearMonthDay links to the calendar dates where it occurs in the lectionary. (In the Logos lectionaries, these are directed internally rather than to the top prioritized resource with YearMonthDay milestones, but I'm not certain myself how to best accomplish this in PB syntax.)

  • tom
    tom Member Posts: 3,213 ✭✭✭

    To get the lectionary information to show up on the home page, you need milestones for the YearMonthDay data type and you need to mark up the content with the following fields (as appropriate): reading, season, day (i.e. liturgical occasion), year, date.

    Here's an example of a couple of days marked up with the appropriate milestones and fields.

    [[@YearMonthDay:April 24, 2012]]
    {{field-on:date}}TUESDAY, APRIL 24, 2012{{field-off:date}} | {{field-on:season}}EASTER{{field-off:season}}
    {{field-on:day}}TUESDAY OF THE THIRD WEEK OF EASTER{{field-off:day}}
    {{field-on:year}}YEARS 1 & 2{{field-off:year}}

                  First Reading       {{field-on:reading}}Acts 7:51–8:1a{{field-off:reading}}
                  Response       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 31:6a{{field-off:reading}}
                  Psalm       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 31:3c–4, 6, 7b, 8a, 17, 21ab{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel Acclamation       {{field-on:reading}}John 6:35ab{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel       {{field-on:reading}}John 6:30–35{{field-off:reading}}

    [[@YearMonthDay:April 25, 2012]]
    {{field-on:date}}WEDNESDAY, APRIL 25, 2012{{field-off:date}} |{{field-on:season}} FEAST{{field-off:season}}
    {{field-on:day}}SAINT MARK, EVANGELIST{{field-off:day}}
    {{field-on:year}}YEARS 1 & 2{{field-off:year}}

                  First Reading       {{field-on:reading}}1 Peter 5:5b–14{{field-off:reading}}
                  Response       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 89:2{{field-off:reading}}
                  Psalm       {{field-on:reading}}Psalm 89:2–3, 6–7, 16–17{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel Acclamation       {{field-on:reading}}1 Corinthians 1:23a–24b{{field-off:reading}}
                  Gospel       {{field-on:reading}}Mark 16:15–20{{field-off:reading}}

    I've tested this in the current beta and it appears to work as expected. (Previously, there was a bug that prevented Personal Book lectionaries from showing up on the homepage.)

    The text of the readings in Logos lectionaries is inserted with dynamic text. Dynamic text functionality is planned, but not implemented for Personal Books, but the homepage functionality does not depend on the dynamic text.

    fgh said:

    provided the copyright isn't a problem, it might even be possible to get Logos to release an Orthodox Lectionary as a proper resource

    Absolutely--particularly if we can determine what lectionary would be most in demand and obtain that.

    Hi Louis,

    Right now, I am too tired to figure this out.  I have a simple question.  Can  I create a PBB for the daily RCL, and the text for Tuesday of Easter 4 year B will always show for the 4th Tuesday of Easter in Year B without having to recompile the PBB with different dates for the different calendar years?

  • Steve Egge
    Steve Egge Member Posts: 13 ✭✭

    I thought the Daily Office was the "litergy of the Hours" ... different from the Mass Lectionary

    I'd really like to see this in Logos format

  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    MJ. Smith said:

    fgh said:

    That is, of course, always an issue when it comes to the Orthodox.

    Not all that much more than Catholic as our readings vary by rite or did

    You've got a point, but you've taken my quote out of context. The context was Louis saying "particularly if we can determine what lectionary would be most in demand". I don't think there's any issue whatsoever with what Catholic lectionary is most in demand: Latin rite US. Now, if it was a question about determining what would be the second most demanded Catholic lectionary, then I grant you we have a situation that's more similar to the Orthodox: an Eastern rite? a religious order? another country? another language even? Unless, of course, everyone bow to authority and agree on the one the pope uses. [:P]

    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • Fr A
    Fr A Member Posts: 2 ✭✭

    Thanks to everyone for your quick responses - I got it to work as expected and am now in the process of setting the lectionary so that all I have to do is input the date(s) of Easter and a ready-to-go lectionary pops out for any number of years, sans any extra work.  :-)

    If I were to see about Logos making this a resource available to everyone, who might I contact? I'm not too hip w/ copyright issues, but this lectionary is widely published and available all over the place in many different formats.

    ~Fr Aleksa

  • Louis St. Hilaire
    Louis St. Hilaire Member, Logos Employee Posts: 513

    Hi Louis,

    Right now, I am too tired to figure this out. I have a simple question. Can I create a PBB for the daily RCL, and the text for Tuesday of Easter 4 year B will always show for the 4th Tuesday of Easter in Year B without having to recompile the PBB with different dates for the different calendar years?

    The application itself doesn't have the ability to determine the date for Easter or other occasions in the different liturgical calendars for a particular year. We handle this in our own lectionary resources by calculating the dates beforehand and generating the readings for each day of the year with the appropriate YearMonthDay milestone. (Also, if you're looking for the RCL daily readings, we've added them to the JG base packages, and I'm hoping we'll make it available for individual sale soon as well.)

    I thought the Daily Office was the "litergy of the Hours" ... different from the Mass Lectionary

    I'd really like to see this in Logos format

    The rights and permissions for the Liturgy of the Hours in English are somewhat complex, but we're working on acquiring it.

    If I were to see about Logos making this a resource available to everyone, who might I contact? I'm not too hip w/ copyright issues, but this lectionary is widely published and available all over the place in many different formats.

    If you'd like Logos to produce it, you can gather whatever information you do have (title, background, where it can be found, who has published it, etc.) and send it to suggest (at) logos (dot) com. (You might also cc me at lsthilaire (at) logos (dot) com.) If we can determine that it's public domain or if can obtain permissions to use it, we should be able to make it.

  • tom
    tom Member Posts: 3,213 ✭✭✭

    Thanks Louis

    The application itself doesn't have the ability to determine the date for Easter or other occasions in the different liturgical calendars for a particular year. 

    This is one of the reasons why I state that Logos 4 is not designed to be a Christian tool, but an Evangelical Christian tool.  I did not upgrade to L4 (I did the crossgrade option) because upgrading I did not see the added books being worthwhile for me.

    Calculating dates is not a hard thing to do.  While there are many lectionaries out there, it is my understanding that a good number of them use the same dates (Easter and Christmas) as their starting points.

  • Ken McGuire
    Ken McGuire Member Posts: 2,074 ✭✭✭

    Thanks Louis

    The application itself doesn't have the ability to determine the date for Easter or other occasions in the different liturgical calendars for a particular year. 

    This is one of the reasons why I state that Logos 4 is not designed to be a Christian tool, but an Evangelical Christian tool.  I did not upgrade to L4 (I did the crossgrade option) because upgrading I did not see the added books being worthwhile for me.

    Calculating dates is not a hard thing to do.  While there are many lectionaries out there, it is my understanding that a good number of them use the same dates (Easter and Christmas) as their starting points.

    While the evangelical background for Logos is obvious, it also seems obvious that Logos is trying to reach out beyond it.  While I am critical of the Lectionary functionality, I also remember the uproar among the Beta testers when the Catholic Lectionary was instantly displayed on the home page, and the difficulty with changing it or eliminating it.  Many users seemed honestly offended that it was there and were quite concerned about it.  But Logos kept it in there, because they recognized that this was a needed tool for many of us.

    My problems are with the implementation.  It seems crazy to have to, in effect, manually put in the date for each day in a lectionary.  It should be obvious that the Sunday of Easter 4 is three weeks after Sunday of Easter 1, and so if the Computer knows the date for Easter, it should be able to figure it out.

    But while that is only a problem for content providers for Lectionaries, I also found it frustrating to navigate around the year.  The Lectionary Viewer in Libronix was much more useful for me.  There are hints that it is getting better, but IMHO it isn't there yet.

    The Gospel is not ... a "new law," on the contrary, ... a "new life." - William Julius Mann

    L8 Anglican, Lutheran and Orthodox Silver, Reformed Starter, Academic Essentials

    L7 Lutheran Gold, Anglican Bronze

  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    all I have to do is input the date(s) of Easter and a ready-to-go lectionary pops out for any number of years, sans any extra work.  :-)

    Nice job! [:)]


    We're working on acquiring more liturgical books (stay tuned)

    [Y]

    so supporting liturgical calendars with data types will soon become much more worthwhile. This will be a first step in making the application itself "understand" liturgical data.


    Calculating dates is not a hard thing to do.  While there are many lectionaries out there, it is my understanding that a good number of them use the same dates (Easter and Christmas) as their starting points.

    When I went to bed yesterday, I was thinking that you'd need something similar to the verse mapping system. Something like 'LitDateGREG:Christmas Day' and 'LitDateJUL:Christmas Day' for the basic separation between Western and Eastern calendars, and then all sorts of combinations (calendar, rite, religious order, diocese, time in history...) before you end up with a datatype for a particular lectionary. 

    Then I woke up in the morning and realized that the system also needs to be able to handle references like "the Collect for the First Sunday in Advent" or "the hymn for Vespers on Holy Saturday".

    Then there's the issue that if someone makes a lot of notes in one lectionary, and then moves to another diocese with basically the same calendar, except for some different saints and a couple of days moved to/from the nearest Sunday, then the software needs to recognize when the texts are the same and show the old notes in the new lectionary.

    The more I think about it, the more I realize that easy it is definitely not. And I'm sure I've only scratched the surface. But I do eagerly wait for the day when it works!




    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • Louis St. Hilaire
    Louis St. Hilaire Member, Logos Employee Posts: 513

    fgh said:

    The more I think about it, the more I realize that easy it is definitely not. And I'm sure I've only scratched the surface. But I do eagerly wait for the day when it works!

    Yep. Limited as it is, the current set up at least has the advantage of being open-ended, so that if you're willing to do the alignment between dates and the readings and other data, almost any arrangement can be made to work. Even the handful of lectionaries we've done so far vary quite a bit in their calendars and (in some cases) get rather complex to calculate. Dealing with these variations intelligently without creating the kind of Procrustean bed we used to have with the Biblical canon will be a challenge.

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

    There are hints that it is getting better, but IMHO it isn't there yet.

    From communication with Bob P. and Lou St. Hilaire, I've come to think that Logos didn't understand the use of lectionaries beyond showing what the readings are for today (or next week). First, Logos didn't see the importance of lectionaries to use how a church used scripture as an element of Bible study. Second, they didn't understand the need to see readings that did not occur in a given year (or were in a historical lectionary). Third, they didn't think of prayer books, reading plans, etc. as often just another form of lectionaries with the consequences that not all lectionaries cover a full year and that one may use multiple lectionaries at the same time.

    I've been impressed with the progress made in L4 because the framework Logos had built made progress difficult. Would I have liked to see it completely rewritten - yes for both lectionaries and reading plans. Then again, even I would give notes more priority,

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

    fgh said:

    you'd need something similar to the verse mapping system.

    Hummm, I wonder who might have tables starting to address this issue? Have fun mapping the three Sundays preceding Lent.

    Because of the local variation, variation by order, pastoral options . . ., I would argue that the lectionary as it appears in the home page ribbon needs to be customized by the user. What I see as the largest outstanding hurdle that I've not heard anything implying that Logos is intending is attaching a note to multiple passages - which would also solve the issue of non-contiguous passage citations.

     

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • tom
    tom Member Posts: 3,213 ✭✭✭

    MJ. Smith said:

    I would argue that the lectionary as it appears in the home page ribbon needs to be customized by the user. What I see as the largest outstanding hurdle that I've not heard anything implying that Logos is intending is attaching a note to multiple passages - which would also solve the issue of non-contiguous passage citations.

    [Y][Y][Y][Y][Y][Y][Y]
  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    MJ. Smith said:

    Then again, even I would give notes more priority,

    Me too, except maybe for a couple of minor things.

     

    MJ. Smith said:

    I've not heard anything implying that Logos is intending is attaching a note to multiple passages

    [:'(]   (Definitely one of the things I'd give higher priority!)

     

    MJ. Smith said:

    Have fun mapping the three Sundays preceding Lent.

    I probably will some day, unless someone beats me to it. We still have the traditional ones -- thankfully! I'd be crying floods if they stole Quinquagesima from me.[:'(]

    Actually, this is one of the problems I considered when I thought about how one might do it. If I'm thinking about this the right way -- which I admit I might very well not be  -- then a basic 'LitDateGREG:' datatype should make it possible to make a Swedish PB lectionary with tags like 'LitDateGREG:Epiphany',  'LitDateGREG:Quinquagesima'  and 'LitDateGREG:Trinity 4', and have Logos automatically understand what dates these refer to in a a certain year, whatever Rome and US bishops do to destroy the traditional calendar. (I much prefer the 'new' Mass, but as you can tell I'm not a great fan of the new Roman calendar. [:)])

    Annunciation seems like a much harder nut to crack: not the exact date, not a Sunday with a particular number, not even necessarily the next Sunday (if that happens to be Palm Sunday or Easter Day). Have fun programming the rule for that, Logos. [:)]

     

    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

    fgh said:

    Annunciation seems like a much harder

    That's easy - it's my birthday[;)]

    Attached is a test file for the Moravian lectionary of 1923. Note this is a test - I've not added the appropriate front pages. It's somewhat interesting in terms of Sundays after Trinity rather than after Pentecost.

    Unfortunately, I'm not pleased with the results because it does not appear in the lectionary section of the Passage Guide. The other shortcomings are obvious. Advice on whether or not its worth making these files with the current limitations and bright ideas on how to improve its behavior is welcomed.

    3022.Moravian lectionary test.zip

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    MJ. Smith said:

    That's easy - it's my birthdayWink

    I agree your birthday is easy -- it doesn't move according to complicated rules, like Annunciation does. [8-|]

    Wait a second! I just checked your lectionary. You don't celebrate Annunciation at all this year or next? Either on the day or on a Sunday? No, wait again. The webpage for the Swedish diocese says it was to be celebrated on the 26th this year, but I can't find it there (or anywhere else) in Logos' lectionary. What's going on here?

    MJ. Smith said:

    It's somewhat interesting in terms of Sundays after Trinity rather than after Pentecost.

    To me that's normal, and 'after Pentecost' is the oddity. A quick search says that the Sarum rite as well as most of Northern Europe has counted this way since probably around 1300. Given that geography, it's hardly surprising that it was carried over into Reformation churches. It was, btw, also used in the Carmelite, Carthusian and, yes, Dominican rites. So it ought to be as normal for you as for me. [:P]

    Actually, this looks almost exactly like our calendar. Even the Latin names during Lent and Easter are there.

    Hmm, how come your file got a nice looking name when I unzipped it, when every other .docx I've downloaded comes with a four figure number at the beginning and a lot of %20's instead of spaces? Could you teach everyone else that trick, please? I'm sooo tired of having to tidy up every file name. 

    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

    fgh said:

    What's going on here?

    We did move the Annunciation to Monday, March 26. Generally the lectionaries I build lack secular calendar dates so I can blame Logos[:)]

    fgh said:

    Actually, this looks almost exactly like our calendar.

    That's partially why I chose it as a test case. I thought people would find it interesting - an thus be pleased - without being too disappointed with the limitations. If only it had shown in the lectionary section of the Passage Guide, I would have been motivated to provide several.

    fgh said:

    how come your file got a nice looking name

    Cause I live right? or it could be the software I used for zipping.

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • fgh
    fgh Member Posts: 8,948 ✭✭✭

    MJ. Smith said:

    We did move the Annunciation to Monday, March 26.

    We move it to Sundays, and you move it away from Sundays? I wonder if the bishops have really thought through the theological implications of that.

    MJ. Smith said:

    Generally the lectionaries I build lack secular calendar dates so I can blame LogosSmile

    Indeed:

    image

    Somehow the woman caught in adultery doesn't feel like quite the right text for Annunciation. [:P] Unless you want to give the impression that Talmud is correct...

    And no 2012 or 2013 here:

    image

    Did you see my question to you at http://community.logos.com/forums/p/31295/362328.aspx#362328?

     

    Mac Pro (late 2013) OS 12.6.2

  • Ken McGuire
    Ken McGuire Member Posts: 2,074 ✭✭✭

    fgh said:

    MJ. Smith said:

    We did move the Annunciation to Monday, March 26.

    We move it to Sundays, and you move it away from Sundays? I wonder if the bishops have really thought through the theological implications of that.

    The argument I have heard is that Sunday as a remembrance of Easter has priority over many festivals. More and more resources are doing this.  The practical problem with this is that it means that most people don't really notice church festivals that don't happen on Sundays are not attended by most members.

    Although this does make things more convenient to guest preachers when the pastor is on vacation right after Christmas since they don't have to deal with St. Stephen (Dec 26) Holy Innocents (Dec 28) or Name of Jesus (Jan 1) - Festivals which, while clear on what Jesus came here for, are not what most people think of for "holiday mood"

    On the other hand, last I checked, the US Roman Catholic calendar does move Epiphany from Jan 6 to the Sunday following that date...

    The Gospel is not ... a "new law," on the contrary, ... a "new life." - William Julius Mann

    L8 Anglican, Lutheran and Orthodox Silver, Reformed Starter, Academic Essentials

    L7 Lutheran Gold, Anglican Bronze