Open letter to Faithlife on overall direction

Page 1 of 1 (5 items)
This post has 4 Replies | 1 Follower

Posts 32185
Forum MVP
MJ. Smith | Forum Activity | Posted: Thu, Nov 1 2018 2:55 PM

You've spent a great deal of effort in the last few years making our theological materials accessible, culminating in the Theological Guide and the Lexham Systematic Theology Ontology. While there is still work to be done in terms of aligning resources to LSTO, and continuing work on the Time Line and Factbook, I would like you to turn the focus of your data staff back to the study of the Bible. You have major opportunities in the following areas ... and I am sure others can add extensively to my list.

  • An ontology of Bible study methods with commentaries and monographs linked
  • Ability to access Bible study monographs by primary passages under discussion and, perhaps, even a parallel to Important Passages based upon monographs
  • Of use primarily for Sunday School teachers not pastors, a scriptural index into the questions included in study guides ... think far back to the old lesson builder for access to questions ... don't think an actual lesson builder.

The direction I am thinking I saw first in Carvalho, Corrine L. Primer on Biblical Methods. Winona, MN: Anselm Academic, 2009. However, Felix Just, S.J. has a quick example of how to turn methodological techno-speak into something that actually helps the user (a) understand works based on the method and (b) to learn to use the method so as to make an informed decision about its value to them.

Thanks for listening.

MJ Smith


Various Methods of Biblical Exegesis / Interpretation:

The following table lists many different approaches or methods of biblical interpretation, as grouped in the document "The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church," by the Pontifical Biblical Commission (1993).

A) The Historical-Critical Method

Questions Typically Asked:

Composition History Questions

Who is the author of the work?  What do we know about him/her/them?
Is the attributed author the actual author, or is the work pseudepigraphic?
When, where, and under what circumstances was the work written?
Who were the original recipients?  Where did they live?

Traditional Literary Criticism

What words are used, and what range of meanings do they have?
What images and symbols are used, and what do they signify?
What characters appear in the story? What do we know about them?
How are the characters related to one another in the story?

Comparison of Translations

Are there any significant differences between various modern translations?
When were these translations done, using which translation philosophies?
Which ancient Hebrew or Greek texts underlie the various translations?
Has anything been lost or obscured in the process of translation?

Textual Criticism

Are there any variant readings in the ancient manuscripts?
Are the variants negligible (mere spelling) or significant (affecting meaning)?
Can the variants be explained as intentional changes, or as accidental ones?
How do the literary or historical contexts help explain the variant readings?

Source Criticism

Does the text have any underlying source or sources?
Which version of a source was used, in case there is more than one?
What do the sources actually say and mean in their original contexts?
How are the sources used (quoted, paraphrased, adapted?) in the later text?

Form Criticism

What is the literary form or “genre” of the whole work and the particular text?
Does the text follow or diverge from the usual expectations for this genre?
What is the normal purpose/goal of this genre?
In what social context would texts of this genre have been used?

Redaction Criticism

How has the author used the source(s) in shaping this text?
Are there any parallel texts, and how is this text similar and/or different?
What particular views or theological emphases does this author show?
How did the author’s life circumstances affect the shaping of the text?

Socio-Historical Criticism

If the story claims to be historical, what really happened?
What social, historical, or cultural information can be gleaned from the text?
What background information is necessary to better understand the text?
What was life like for the common people, not just the ruling elites?

B) New Methods of Literary Analysis

Questions Typically Asked:

Rhetorical Analysis

What message is the author trying to convey?
Is the author attempting to instruct, inspire, defend, or persuade the reader?
What rhetorical techniques does he use to achieve his goals?

Narrative Analysis

Who are the characters in the story? What roles do they play?
What is the plot sequence?  What narrative time is covered?
What is the author’s and/or narrator’s point of view?

Semiotic Analysis

What deeper patterns of meaning are conveyed by the words and symbols?


C) Approaches Based on Tradition

Questions Typically Asked:

Canonical Approach

Where does this text belong in the literary context of the entire Bible?
How is this text related to prior texts and/or later texts in the Bible?
How does its location in the Canon affect the meaning of this text?

Using Jewish Interpretative Traditions

How do traditional Jewish methods of interpretation read this text?
Are there any parallel or similar stories in Rabbinic literature?
Do Jewish and Christian interpretations of this text differ significantly?

History of Interpretation

How was this text interpreted by the “Church Fathers” and in later centuries?
Is the text interpreted differently by various churches and denominations?
How has the text been interpreted in art, music, liturgy, and popular culture?

D) Apps. Using the Human Sciences

Questions Typically Asked:

Sociological Approach

What insights from Sociology can help in the interpretation of the text?
What patterns of human social behavior are evident in the text?

Cultural Anthropology Approach

What models from Cultural Anthropology can help us understand the text?
What cultural presuppositions/patterns affect the interpretation of the text?

Psychological/Psychoanalytical Apps.

How can the text be interpreted using various theories from Psychology?
Can the text help us understand the human psyche better?

E) Contextual Approaches

Questions Typically Asked:

Liberationist Approach

Has this text been used for domination of oppressed people? How?
Can this text be used for the liberation of the poor/disadvantaged? How?
Can other texts counteract the detrimental effects of oppressive texts?

Feminist Approach

Does the text evidence gender bias?  Was later interpretation also biased?
How is the meaning of the text affected if read from a feminist perspective?
What other texts can be recovered and used to balance out biased texts?


Methods of Exegesis/Interpretation

Advantages/Strengths of These Methods:

Disadvantages/Weaknesses of These Methods::

A) The Historical-Critical Method



B) New Methods of Literary Analysis



C) Approaches Based on Tradition



D) Approaches Using Human Sciences



E) Contextual Approaches



Orthodox Bishop Hilarion Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."

Posts 997
Kiyah | Forum Activity | Replied: Fri, Nov 2 2018 6:21 AM

Great suggestions. And it would be nice if all of the resources in the bibliography of the page you linked to could be made available in the Logos store. Some good books on that list.

Posts 1551
Rick Ausdahl | Forum Activity | Replied: Fri, Nov 2 2018 10:39 AM

I think MJ's suggestions would bring some very nice balance to the excellent software we have in Logos.

Posts 32
Amy Esary | Forum Activity | Replied: Fri, Nov 2 2018 10:40 AM

Thank you for your thoughtful comments. 

Posts 510
Richard Villanueva | Forum Activity | Replied: Fri, Nov 2 2018 10:43 AM

This is great! And MJ may have sold me on a book as well... Ha! 

Love the chart and the ideas.

MBPro'12 / i5 / 8GB // 3.0 Scholars (Purple) / L6 & L7 Platinum, M&E Platinum, Anglican Bronze, P&C Silver / L8 Platinum, Academic Pro

Page 1 of 1 (5 items) | RSS