Notes not appearing

Michel Pauw · 2016-11-23T22:51:56+00:00

1 Samuel 10:8 ESV. I have made a note on 'Gilgal': * in ESV right clicked on 'Gilgal' * in the right menu I selected the Hebrew lemma for Gilgal * in the left menu I clicked 'Add a Note to "Notes on Bible Reading" * I wrote the note, assigned a yellow note indicator that shows up next to the lemma in the "Notes on Bible…

Michel Pauw

1 Samuel 10:8 ESV.

I have made a note on 'Gilgal':

in ESV right clicked on 'Gilgal'
in the right menu I selected the Hebrew lemma for Gilgal
in the left menu I clicked 'Add a Note to "Notes on Bible Reading"
I wrote the note, assigned a yellow note indicator that shows up next to the lemma in the "Notes on Bible Reading"

By doing this, I expect this note to appear in the ESV and the Hebrew text wherever the lemma Gilgal occurs.

However, the note indicator doesn't appear in either text.

The note indicator will appear when I write a note to the 'Reference' instead of to the lemma, using the same Notes. But of course I also want to see the note indicators for lemma notes.

To anticipate a question: 'Notes on Bible Reading' is ticked in the visual filters for ESV and the Hebrew.

Any help would be appreciated.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Graham Criddle

Lemma-linked notes only currently appear in Original Language texts not English translations.

So I wouldn't have expected it to appear in the ESV but would have expected it in the Hebrew text.

What Hebrew text are you using?

Michel Pauw

Okay, I didn't realize that.

But then still, it also doesn't appear in the Hebrew. I'm using BHS/WIVU

Graham Criddle

But then still, it also doesn't appear in the Hebrew. I'm using BHS/WIVU

For some reason the ESV and BHS/WIVU tag the word as different hononyms.

ESV has it as "2" while BHS has it as "4" so the lemmas don't match

The LHB tags it as "2" and so the note indicator appears there.

I don't know why they have been tagged differently - hopefully someone else will be able to comment on that.

Michel Pauw

Compare BHS/WIVU and BHS/SESB

Where do we go to address this mismatch?

Andrew Batishko

But then still, it also doesn't appear in the Hebrew. I'm using BHS/WIVU

For some reason the ESV and BHS/WIVU tag the word as different hononyms.

ESV has it as "2" while BHS has it as "4" so the lemmas don't match

The LHB tags it as "2" and so the note indicator appears there.

I don't know why they have been tagged differently - hopefully someone else will be able to comment on that.

This is because various resources use difference systems for analyzing lemmas (in the same way that they use different systems for analyzing morphology). If you right click on a word in the resource, select the lemma, and do a search, you can see the analysis as part of the search string. BHS/WIVU uses the WIVU analysis. ESV uses the LBS analysis (Faithlife's). BHS/SESB uses (I believe, I don't have the resource available to verify right now) the SESB analysis. Different analysis systems have different mechanisms for labeling homographs, which leads leads to different classifications of some words.

Generally the application takes care of converting between analyses for you (for example, both homographs will lead to the same entry in you lexicon, even though the lexicon likely shows it as homograph number 2). It may be a bug that the note marker is not properly converting to the correct analysis. I'll check on Monday.

Philana R. Crouch

Any help would be appreciated.

Michel,

This should now be fixed in

7.3 (7.3.0.0031)