WOC search discrepancies
When I run a Bible search in NASB95 for the word Peter, I get hits in 154 verses.
When I run a search for the word Peter, but limit to Words of Christ (by clicking All Bible Text and selecting), I get hits on two verses. Well and good.
I can also run a search with no limitations of-- Peter IN speaker:Jesus --I also get hits on two verses, which is what I would expect.
But I want to see everywhere Jesus spoke to or about Peter, so I run this search-- person:Peter IN speaker:Jesus --and I receive 183 results in 69 verses.
This looks like it is only giving me references to Peter in the words of Jesus. In Matthew 7:17 [And Jesus came to them and touched them and said, “Get up, and do not be afraid.” NASB95], the second "them" is tagged as referring to Peter, but it is not a result because it is not in the words of Jesus. The two verbs are also tagged with "Peter" and are in words of Jesus, so they register as hits. Good. That is what I expected.
NOW, here's the thing I'd like help with:
When I run a search in NASB95 for person:Peter and limit search to Words of Christ, I get 972 results in 369 verses.
I run a search for person:Peter with no limitations, and I get 972 results in 369 verses.
It looks like I am getting every tag for the person Peter without any consideration of the search field Words of Christ, including everything in Acts, 1Cor, Gal, 1&2 Peter.
I've tried this with other tags/labels and get similar results. If I search for anything other than plain text (place:Jerusalem, intertext:relationship:Quotation, etc) limited to Words of Christ then Logos returns a search that is exactly the same as All Bible Text.
However, the same searches IN speaker:Jesus return expected results.
Is this a bug, or a limitation of the search fields dropdown menu?
Is there a general rule as to when Words of Christ and IN speaker:Jesus will not agree?
Comments
-
It appears to be a bug - I'll give Dave a chance to report it but the results are simply wrong.
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
0 -
Is there a general rule as to when Words of Christ and IN speaker:Jesus will not agree?
The tagging for WOC tends can be speculative as can the (separate) tagging for words that Jesus spoke, but they appear to have the same scope:
- Peter IN speaker:Jesus = Peter in WOC and John IN speaker:Jesus = John in WOC; but
- person:Peter will ignore Field settings and Match settings for Case and Forms because datatype searches get their results from a dataset.
But I want to see everywhere Jesus spoke to or about Peter, so I run this search-- person:Peter IN speaker:Jesus --and I receive 183 results in 69 verses.
This looks like it is only giving me references to Peter in the words of Jesus. In Matthew 7:17 [And Jesus came to them and touched them and said, “Get up, and do not be afraid.” NASB95], the second "them" is tagged as referring to Peter, but it is not a result because it is not in the words of Jesus. The two verbs are also tagged with "Peter" and are in words of Jesus, so they register as hits. Good. That is what I expected.
You meant Mt 17.7, which you agree is included in the your search for the reasons given i.e. it is only giving me references to Peter in the words of Jesus.
If you want to see where Jesus spoke to Peter, you need the addressee datatype i.e.
addressee:person:Peter INTERSECTS speaker:Jesus.
You get extra results because Peter is not referenced in all Jesus' words e.g. Mt 10.5-10.
It is safer to use INTERSECTS as IN means wholly within.
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Dave, is it accurate to say that the Match case and Match all forms options apply only to text argument term and that the reference matching option applies only to topics, cultural concepts, preaching themes, counseling themes argument terms? If it is so, why aren't they greyed out until a search term is entered that activates them? And why not have a warning that the field filter will be ignored?
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
0 -
is it accurate to say that the Match case and Match all forms options apply only to text argument term
Yes
and that the reference matching option applies only to topics, cultural concepts, preaching themes, counseling themes argument terms
Reference matching applies only to datatype/keyword terms (except labels) where there exists an equivalent/similar reference value.
why aren't they greyed out until a search term is entered that activates them? And why not have a warning that the field filter will be ignored?
Perhaps they should be greyed out when not applicable to the query. They can still affect text terms, though.
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
and that the reference matching option applies only to topics, cultural concepts, preaching themes, counseling themes argument terms
Reference matching applies only to datatype/keyword terms (except labels) where there exists an equivalent/similar reference value.
Can you give me an example of datatypes that are similar references that are not topics, cultural concepts, preaching themes, counseling themes, theological topics . . . I suspect I am still missing something.
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
0 -
Thank you, Dave for the general rule. "Datatype searches ignore field settings." And yes, I transposed the Matthew reference. Thanks for catching that.
Thanks, MJ for weighing in with good follow up questions. I've learned a lot in this thread.
0 -
Can you give me an example of datatypes that are similar references that are not topics, cultural concepts, preaching themes, counseling themes, theological topics .
I can't find any examples for CT:Marriage (Counseling Theme) e.g. it is not included with topic:Marriage
What datatype is "theological topics"? If LSTO, then it is not subject to reference matching.
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
I can't find any examples for CT:Marriage (Counseling Theme) e.g. it is not included with topic:Marriage
What datatype is "theological topics"? If LSTO, then it is not subject to reference matching.
Other datatypes that could be subject to reference matching:
- figurativeLanguageTerm:Light has additional results to both topic:Light and culture:Light
Then we have topics that do not integrate for reference matching when there is significant overlap:
- topic:Dark is not enhanced for Default matching whilst topic:Darkness is significantly enhanced
- both provide a similar number of results for Broad matching because suddenly there is an overlapping of terms e.g. both include results for headword:Dark OR headword:Darkness OR Dark OR Darkness
- Note that topic:Marriage involves topic:"Marriage customs" and preachingTheme:"Courtship, Dating and Romantic Relationships” at the Default level when I would expect that at Broad level.
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Thank you Dave for taking the time to research this. It really helps me understand what happens in a search.
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
0
