Are Semantic Roles in Clause Participant in Bible Word Study a summary?
Can anyone confirm that the Semantic Roles in the Clause Participants Section on the Bible Word Study Guide contain a summary for each semantic role and that a search is needed to find the actual result for each Semantic Role?
If this is correct, does anyone know if the summary carries specific relevant information or are it just a random selection of verses? (Are there any specific rule in selecting verses to display?)
Or, are the verses only to indicate that Logos found some matches for that Semantic Role?
If it's a summary it would be nice if the Clause Participants Section can indicate that it's a summary. Something like "Adam (first man) 2 of 20 results". Then the "20" can be a link to a Clause Search to expand the Result in a Search Panel.
While I'm asking questions in Word Study: Why does the Word Study Guide return two lemmas for g:Jesus? The lemmas appear to be the same but does not return the same results. It feels as if something is missing in the information presented? I ran both Word Studies to try and see if it could figure this one out.
Comments
-
PJ said:
Can anyone confirm that the Semantic Roles in the Clause Participants Section on the Bible Word Study Guide contain a summary for each semantic role and that a search is needed to find the actual result for each Semantic Role?
No - in the example below there were seven results indicated for "A Slave" and the section shows 7 results
Please clarify what you are seeing.
PJ said:While I'm asking questions in Word Study: Why does the Word Study Guide return two lemmas for g:Jesus? The lemmas appear to be the same but does not return the same results. It feels as if something is missing in the information presented? I ran both Word Studies to try and see if it could figure this one out.
Do you mean in the dropdown outlined below? If so, one is Latin and one is English
If you mean something different, please clarify.
0 -
I figured out why I got confused between the counts of Clause Participants and a Search. When one do a clause search for example "person:Boaz" it finds Boaz in any column in a Search. I was not specific enough in my analysis, my mistake.
The problem with Word Study is as follow image indicate:
I can't see the difference between listings?
0 -
PJ said:
The problem with Word Study is as follow image indicate:
I can't see the difference between listings?
For me - one Guide returns lots of results (in both OT and NT), the other just returns 5 results in LXX
Are you seeing something different?
0 -
Thanks Graham, I discovered the problem by studying your screenshots. My Septuagint Translation's default did not work properly. After I prioritized the resource the default was fixed. Don't know why, but it helped.
Thanks
0 -
PJ said:
My Septuagint Translation's default did not work properly. After I prioritized the resource the default was fixed. Don't know why, but it helped.
Glad it's sorted
I think there might actually be a tagging problem in the LXX with the five verses that appear in the second guide which result in two lemmas being shown. The actual lemma seems to be linked to the definitive article associated with it.
0 -
PJ said:
I can't see the difference between listings?
English transliteration is a bit different over the u (one has Greek accent over u while other does not). Hovering mouse over pop-up choices shows Bible Word Study ring:
Keep Smiling [:)]
0 -
said: