Clause search returns "title" in results which can cause confusion

When researching the question raised in http://community.logos.com/forums/p/68230/474716.aspx#474716 I found something strange.

I reduced the problem to demonstrate it here.

Doing a Bible search for <Lemma = lbs/he/אָדוֹן> in Psalm 110 in NRSV returns two hits for verse 1 and verse 5.

Doing a Clause search for "person:God" in Psalm 110 on LHB gives 11 results including three from verse 1 and two from verse 5. However, the results from verse 1 are listed against "Ps 110:title-1" (not Ps 110:1)

If I create a Passage List from both sets of search results and merge them (on intersection) then I just end up with Psalm 110:5.

The first verse is not included, presumably because of the "title" included in the search results.

Is this correct and is it intended to work that way?

Graham

PS: Sorry about the lack of screenshots to demonstrate this - the editor isn't allowing me to upload them at the moment.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Rosie Perera

Sorry about the lack of screenshots to demonstrate this - the editor isn't allowing me to upload them at the moment.

Graham, I have found that when the editor is being finicky about allowing uploads, I can't upload .png files but if I try a different format (.jpg) it works. If you can save the screenshot as a .jpg try uploading that.

Graham Criddle

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/474773#Comment_474773

Graham, I have found that when the editor is being finicky about allowing uploads, I can't upload .png files but if I try a different format (.jpg) it works. If you can save the screenshot as a .jpg try uploading that.

Thanks Rosie - trying with that.

Doing a Bible search for <Lemma = lbs/he/אָדוֹן> in Psalm 110 in NRSV returns two hits for verse 1 and verse 5.

If I create a Passage List from both sets of search results and merge them (on intersection) then I just end up with Psalm 110:5.

The first verse is not included, presumably because of the "title" included in the search results.

Is this correct and is it intended to work that way?

Graham

PS: Rosie - thanks again for the tip about jpgs[:)]

Rosie Perera

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/474774#Comment_474774

PS: Rosie - thanks again for the tip about jpgs

Yay! I'm glad it worked.

I'm used to having to find workarounds to bugs. Sigh...

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

Doing a Clause search for "person:God" in Psalm 110 on LHB gives 11 results including three from verse 1 and two from verse 5. However, the results from verse 1 are listed against "Ps 110:title-1" (not Ps 110:1)

Although the search does run against clauses, each clause is linked to the verse(s) that contain it. I don't know for sure, but (it would make sense, so) I'd guess that the Clause DB uses the BHS versification.

Ps 110:1 (BHS) is Psalm 110:title-1 in most English Bibles; it appears that the verse is being converted to your default Bible's versification scheme for display. Since the primary results are coming from a Hebrew Bible, I think this is a bug and we should be displaying the LHB versification instead. I've filed a bug.

Graham Criddle

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/474983#Comment_474983

Since the primary results are coming from a Hebrew Bible, I think this is a bug and we should be displaying the LHB versification instead. I've filed a bug.

Thanks Bradley

Appreciated, Graham

Room4more

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/474983#Comment_474983

Thanks Bradley for the reply....

[I am hoping that this came around-a-bout way thru Rick<?>]

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/475097#Comment_475097

[I am hoping that this came around-a-bout way thru Rick<?>]

No, why?

(I answered it from my knowledge of the feature after browsing through recent posts in the forum.)