Let me start off by saying that I’m mostly satisfied with Logos and very pleased with the expansion of resources, both in quantity and variety, that has taken place in the last few years. It has helped me to acquire a much better library than what circumstances would otherwise allow. The 500 book megapack last year and the L6 base packages in particular have benefited me a lot.
That said, I have been somewhat disappointed with the lack of expected links in many resources. As I buy mostly theology books, I can’t really speak to the situation with the core biblical resources, but there’s a surprisingly large number of links missing from the books I read, and this limits the utility of these resources by a significant degree.
Examples: they are legion. One that is particularly glaring is Thomas Oden’s three volume Systematic Theology. This resource is mostly useful for its very extensive references to primary works. Although I have many of them in my library, a considerable number are not linked: Barth’s Church Dogmatics, Ritschl’s Christian Doctrine of Justification, Ursinus’s Commentary on the Heidelberg Catechism, the works of Arminius, the works of Menno Simons, and Harnack’s History of Dogma. Harnack in particular is a very big deal in the study of historical theology, but I don’t think have come across a single live link to it in any resource. The biggest problem—understandably so—seems to be with references to books that Logos produced after the resource making the citation; a lot of these I got via the Megapack. But that doesn’t explain all of them—Oden has been updated since Barth’s CD came out but does not link to it. I would think that would be a main priority for an update, but I don’t how much work this requires on Faithlife’s end to make a reality.
Another more recent one that stands out is the lack of links to Kelly’s Early Christian Creeds in the Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church, both of which I acquired via an L6 Reformed base package. The Oxford Dictionary is what I would consider a “premium resource” (in contrast to some of the PD books acquired in bulk.) “Great!” I thought when I saw what I was getting in the package; “Not again,” I sighed when I realized that I couldn’t go from one to the other by a single click.
Another example, also from Reformed Gold, is Torrance’s The Christian Doctrine of God. Not surprisingly, there aren’t links to Mackintosh’s Doctrine of the Person of Christ—it just came out last week. What’s more surprising is the lack of linkage to Irenaeus and other church fathers. Aren’t those sort of standardized at this point?
There are many, many other examples, but this post is getting too long as it is.
In a different thread, Bob Pritchett expressed his commitment to rich tagging of resources. I’m glad to hear that. I bought these resources for the work of a lifetime. I don’t expect them to get fixed overnight; I do hope it’s reasonable to expect them to be fixed eventually. So, both for peace of mind and for guidance in buying future resources,* I’d like to discuss a few questions:
-
Is there a plan to improve the links in existing resources (especially theology books)?
-
What’s a reasonable amount of time to wait for this to happen for a particular book?
-
Will new releases have better tagging than some of these older ones? Will it ever be the case that links automatically become “live” after a previously unavailable cited resource is produced and acquired?
-
Is there anything that users can do to help this process?
I look forward to (hopefully) hearing from Faithlife staff as well as the experiences of other users with this issue. Thanks for reading this far!
*In most cases this is not a deal breaker. In the case of Oden, if I’d known the tagging was so bad (well, and didn’t have a coupon
) I probably wouldn’t have bought it as it offers little advantage over the print edition.