[resolved] More Searching Problems
I have the Logos Now trial subscription, and I wanted to look at articular infinitives in Paul. I can do a right click on δουλεύειν in Romans 6:6, select the grammatical construction and do a search from the SBLGNT or my NA27. The same search doesn't work from the NA28, though the construction does show up in the right click menu. I can do a successful inline search from the NA28. Am I missing something or is this a bug?
Thanks.
Comments
-
Clint Cozier said:
I can do a successful inline search from the NA28
Do you have NA28 GBS?
It works there
I believe the tagging has been applied to one and not the other but not completely sure of the reason
0 -
I guess I'm not sure what the NA28 GBS is, but I can do the grammatical search on the Byz text and it works. I would think / hope that if the tagging was absent, it wouldn't show up on the right click menu.
0 -
Clint Cozier said:
I would think / hope that if the tagging was absent, it wouldn't show up on the right click menu.
I agree. It also occurs for NLT, NA27/UBS4.
It works on SBL Greek bibles + Byz + English RI's (exceot for NLT).
Dave
===Windows 11 & Android 13
0 -
Dave Hooton said:
It works on SBL Greek bibles + Byz + English RI's (exceot for NLT).
English RIs give inconsistent results Grammatical Construction Inconsistency.
0 -
Jack Caviness said:
English RIs give inconsistent results Grammatical Construction Inconsistency.
Is this any different than the inconsistencies always present in RI's?
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
0 -
Dave Hooton said:
It also occurs for NLT, NA27/UBS4.
It works on SBL Greek bibles + Byz + English RI's (exceot for NLT).
Apologies: found ArtInf in NLT and NA27 w/Apparatus along with English and Spanish RI's plus UBS5 and LDGNT:
Edit: can replicate NA28 right click showing ArtInf that cannot be found
Keep Smiling [:)]
0 -
MJ. Smith said:Jack Caviness said:
English RIs give inconsistent results Grammatical Construction Inconsistency.
Is this any different than the inconsistencies always present in RI's?
Probably no difference, but this does make them unreliable for Grammatical Construction searches. Would not have tried them at all except that my preferred Greek text (NA28) does not appear to have tagging for this search—Grammatical Constructions with NA28?
0 -
Graham Criddle said:Clint Cozier said:
I can do a successful inline search from the NA28
Do you have NA28 GBS?
It works there
I believe the tagging has been applied to one and not the other but not completely sure of the reason
Basically, the {Section } searching relies on newer versions of resources. So resources that have been built recently (e.g. with 6.x release and after) generally support the feature; older builds do not. You might think that it would be simple to just rebuild everything, but some of the resources involved are older and key. I won't bore you with details, it just isn't as easy as you might think (well, if keeping notes, highlights, etc. in sync is important to you). We have a strategy and I believe we've done some initial work and testing, but don't have results to release yet. When we do, then the updated resources will be made available via update.
Rick Brannan
Data Wrangler, Faithlife
My books in print0 -
Thanks Rick - that's helpful
And I wasn't suggesting it was easy just that I didn't understand!
Graham
0
