BUG report or SUGGESTION:Sermon section duplicates

When a sermon appears multiple times in my library - usually a patristics issue - it would be nice to have it appear only once in the sermon list with a link to the highest prioritized resource containing it. The is especially true since the recent pairing of the Catholic/Protestant versions of Schaff to make links work for everyone.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Eli Evans (Logos)

A worthy idea, though given the current technology, I'm not sure how we would know that sermons are "the same." It seems like one edition treats a number of homilies as one where another edition breaks them out individually. As the tagging strategy currently goes, we tag what's presented in the book with minimal editorial.

Speaking of minimal editorial, it does look like there's a tagging inconsistency here, because (I think) "Basil" and "Basil of Caesarea" should be tagged the same. I'll let Kyle know.

MJ. Smith

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/803711#Comment_803711

Ah, I misunderstood. I thought the same value for the same datatype was sufficient to identify "same sermons".

Eli Evans (Logos)

https://community.logos.com/discussion/comment/803720#Comment_803720

Same datatype value probably would work in this case, but not in the general case since not all sermons (especially outside patristics) have datatype milestones to compare.