RC2: Disappointing

Dave Hooton · 2014-11-19T23:28:19+00:00

There are still some fundamental problems:- * My highlighting Label definition has not sync'd from v6.0 where it was created * No results from <Event xxx> searches in or from the main RI's * Factbook <Culture> item >> Search Everything for <Culture> ---> no results (incl. Factbook section)! * Factbook item >> Community…

Dave Hooton

There are still some fundamental problems:-

My highlighting Label definition has not sync'd from v6.0 where it was created
No results from <Event xxx> searches in or from the main RI's
Factbook <Culture> item >> Search Everything for <Culture> ---> no results (incl. Factbook section)!
Factbook item >> Community Tags or Search >>Community Tags ---> resources not opening

I'm sure others could add to the list.

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

Don Awalt

EDIT: Sorry this is the bug Dave listed above, at least here is a thread reference to it:

Seems to me a very big bug is that most/all event searches don't work in this scenario

Fr Devin Roza

I agree with Dave. I don't think this is ready for release.

Apart from what he mentioned, there is still this serious, repeatable lockup issue when Biblical Things is open in a customized passage guide: https://community.logos.com/forums/t/95234.aspx

Fr Devin Roza

Factbook <Culture> item >> Search Everything for <Culture> ---> no results (incl. Factbook section)

Maybe I'm remembering wrong, but I think in the beta trials someone explained that this is by design, and that <Culture XXXX> should only return results when within a {Section} search extension.

Mark Barnes

Why delay? It's only a point release.

So long as a 6.0b comes along fairly soon, I'm not sure why this should be delayed, particularly if it solves the Yosemite download bug.

Dave Hooton

Maybe I'm remembering wrong, but I think in the beta trials someone explained that this is by design, and that <Culture XXXX> should only return results when within a {Section} search extension.

A Search for <Culture> should at least provide a link to the Factbook item!

Why does the Factbook item provide a Search Everything link for <Culture> as well as a link for (Section <Culture>}?

Dave Hooton

So long as a 6.0b comes along fairly soon, I'm not sure why this should be delayed, particularly if it solves the Yosemite download bug.

That is the only point of merit, but the other bugs were known before this became prominent.

Fr Devin Roza

Why delay? It's only a point release.

So long as a 6.0b comes along fairly soon, I'm not sure why this should be delayed, particularly if it solves the Yosemite download bug.

I guess it just depends on how long the open issues would take to resolve, which is something we don't know but Faithlife does, or at least can estimate. If it were just a few days to fix some of these especially the <Event> and lockup, I would be in favor of waiting (as I would imagine that 6.0b RTM will be at least a month or month and a half out). If it's a week or longer that's obviously good reason to just ship now.

Although, I guess there are always the Service Releases where they can fix these things too.

Fr Devin Roza

Why does the Factbook item provide a Search Everything link for <Culture> as well as a link for (Section <Culture>}?

Where do you see this? I only see a link at the bottom of the Cultural Concepts section for searching {Section <Culture Topic>}.

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

A Search for <Culture> should at least provide a link to the Factbook item!

Like <Biography>, this is a known issue.

Bradley Grainger (Logos)

AFAIK, none of the problems in 6.0a are regressions from 6.0, so 6.0a is a net improvement. We have made the decision to ship with known issues. These bugs are on our list to fix in future releases.

Dave Hooton

Where do you see this? I only see a link at the bottom of the Cultural Concepts section for searching {Section <Culture Topic>}.

It has to be a specific <Culture> item e.g. enter <Culture Ability> as opposed to Ability (which gives you the topic item). Under See Also the Search link will be for <Culture Ability>

Don Awalt

AFAIK, none of the problems in 6.0a are regressions from 6.0, so 6.0a is a net improvement. We have made the decision to ship with known issues. These bugs are on our list to fix in future releases.

This makes sense, I had lost sight of the strategy here to keep squashing bugs in quick releases once 6.0 was out. This was a good and correct decision to keep progress going. Nice job Bradley on keeping things on track and making 6.0 better with 6.0a. On to 6.0b! [:D]

Quick Links

All Categories
Recent Posts
Activity
Unanswered
Groups
Help
Best Of