Bug: Clause Search Broken
Run a search on subject:god Verb:laugh
No results come up. Ps. 2:4 along with a few others should come up.
Mission: To serve God as He desires.
Comments
-
Same on the stable channel. Can someone try and see if they can get this to work.
Mission: To serve God as He desires.
0 -
Lynden Williams said:
Run a search on subject:god Verb:laugh
No results come up. Ps. 2:4 along with a few others should come up.
Needed a selection from the dropdown to make this work, but Ps 2:4 is still MIA
Remove any of the terms, and received an invalid search term red box.
Don't understand absence of Ps 2:4, since it appears to be tagged correctly
Sure wish Logos would fix the forum, I hate jpeg (and png) bug [:@]
0 -
Thanks Jack. When I use the drop down menu supplied I get 2 results. Ps. 37:15 and 39:8
Mission: To serve God as He desires.
0 -
Lynden Williams said:
That's what I got, but Ps 2:4 is appropriately tagged, and thus should have appeared in the search results.
Jack Caviness said:Sure wish Logos would fix the forum, I hate jpeg (and png) bug
See that the pictures showed up after I posted this and left the thread. Makes this comment look kind of clueless.
0 -
Jack Caviness said:Lynden Williams said:
That's what I got, but Ps 2:4 is appropriately tagged, and thus should have appeared in the search results.
Psalm 2:4 has:
He who sits in the heavens laughs; (NRSV)
- "Sits" as tagged with Person:God
- "Laughs" isn't tagged with any Person so doesn't match.
Looks like a tagging issue to me.
0 -
Graham Criddle said:
He who sits in the heavens laughs; (NRSV)
- "Sits" as tagged with Person:God
- "Laughs" isn't tagged with any Person so doesn't match.
Looks like a tagging issue to me.
Perhaps, but the participle יוֹשֵׁ֣ב (the one sitting) is the subject of the sentence while יִשְׂחָ֑ק (shall laugh) is the predicate, so the tagging may be correct.
0 -
While the surface-level tagging seems to be correct, it looks like the clause processing somehow missed the connection between the subject (God) and the verb "laughs"
0 -
Peter Venable (Logos) said:
While the surface-level tagging seems to be correct, it looks like the clause processing somehow missed the connection between the subject (God) and the verb "laughs"
Now that someone at Logos has identified the problem, can we expect a fix? Clause Searching is nearly worthless if the user cannot trust the tagging.
0 -
I have been seeing a rash of user reports on search errors. But Logos has been wanting.
For instance, see here, and here
If one looks around one will find more reports, and some of them seem to be ignored by Logos, in that they do not seem to be responded to as "bugs" in their own right. When you get a bug, Logos employees come out and file a case. Is it the same with search errors? Judge for yourself. One almost gets the feeling that Logos would rather users sweep these errors under the carpet.
Now, I suppose that problems will be eventually fixed. But can anyone know for sure?
It's a high calling, what Logos is promising. I hope that Logos achieves it. I cannot emphasize enough how critical an accurate search function is. If the software fails in this regard, to me its value diminishes to the level of an expensive electronic reader.
0
