BUG? Context Menu Resource List for References

Dave, I removed every other resource from my prioritised list:

Mt 25:2

LGNTI: ESV; NET; LGNTI; NA27int; Lexham Sentence Diagrams (?)

ESV: ESV; NET; LGNTI; NA27int; Lexham High Definition New Testament (?) 

NRSV: ESV; NET; LGNTI; NA27int; NRSV

NJB: ESV; NET; LGNTI; NA27int; NJB  

Gen 4 3

LHI: ESV; NET; LHI; AFAT: AYBC Genesis

ESV: ESV; NET; LHI; AFAT: Ancient Christian Commentary Genesis

NRSV: ESV; NET; LHI; AFAT: NRSV

NJB: ESV; NET; LHI; AFAT: NJB

I wonder what the logice is for finding resources not on the priority list?

I thought to check that my Prioritised resources were appearing on the Context menu for bible References, but the results were quite unexpected (see Table below).

To reproduce:

• Prioritize resources in Library as per Table (I have some Greek and Hebrew lexicons between NET and LGNTI)
• right click a word in ESV at Gen 4:3, select Reference, and note the 5 resources in bottom left 
• right click a word in ESV at Matt 25:2, select Reference, and note the 5 resources in bottom left
• right click a word in LHI at Gen 4:3, select Reference, and note the 5 resources in bottom left
• right click a word in LGNTI at Matt 25:2, select Reference, and note the 5 resources in bottom left

Why are my Prioritised resources matched only with the Greek bible LGNTI?

Why is the NET ignored by all but LGNTI?

Why do Concise Bible Commentary and Harmony of the Synoptic Gospels appear in the results?

Prioritized	ESV Gen 4:3	ESV Matt 25:2	LHI Gen 4:3	LGNTI Matt 25:2
ESV	ESV	ESV	ESV	ESV
NET	TNIV	OpenText Clauses	LHI	NET
LGNTI	Concise Bible Commentary	Harmony of Syn Gospels	AFAT	LGNTI
LHI	AMP	TNIV	AFPMA	NA27Int
NA27Int	ASV	Concise Bible Commentary	BHSMorph	OpenText Clauses
AFAT

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Further tests show that:-

TNIV results for Matt 25:2 match LGNTI above.

TNIV results for Gen 4:3 are ESV, NET, TNIV, Concise Bible Commentary, AMP.

NA27Int results match LGNTI above.

BHSMorph results match LHI above.

If I Prioritize Newberry Interlinear after AFAT, then results are "as expected" i.e. it appears before OpenText Clauses in the ESV NT results and replaces OpenText Clauses in the LGNTI results.

==============

If it helps I attached a log where the activity starts about 13 Sept 21:50. I added BBC (29.1.24) to the list between NET and LGNTI and performed the above tests twice before removing BBC and repeating the tests with above results.

 

 

Dav , I tried setup as above and get following results..

TNIV matches my ESV results for Gen 4:3. However for Matt 25:2 it differs in that the last resources shows up as the Harmony of Synoptic Gospels.

NA27Int matches my LGNTI also...bit stange though that since NA27Int is the base resource that it shows up as a destination option.  I would expect it to in this instance to drope out, the number 5 item to become number 4 and a new number 5 to appear.

BHSMorph match my LHI results also....

JNT (Jewish New Testament) matches my TNIV results. Tanakh matches my LHI results

I tried Luther 1912 bible and found that though the type is bible it is not indexed by refernce but will do a separte post on that issue.

When I slot in Newberry after AFTA also get expected behaviours.

Taking away NA27 and AFAT from fourth and fifth priority positions (newberry also left out) I get

So indeed some strange results, almost seems like some preset advanced priority options hidden from us.  Where my results difered from Dav I believe it related to the difference in resources we have in our respective libraries as this last test seems to indicate.