How to identify all Catholic authored resources so I can hide them
Hello everyone.
Thank you for reading and / or replying.
I was Reformed Portfolio on Logos 9, I recently purchased the Collector Edition with Logos 10, thinking it would be a larger collection of Reformed resources. I certainly have a lot more of those, but I now have resources / books from Popes, and I doubt I would know any other names of Catholic authors to be able to manually hide them.
A bit of a conundrum and I feel like I am walking through a minefield now. I sought help from Logos Support, they mentioned they do not have the ability to categorize resources by denomination, I asked how they could offer the different base packages then, they suggested I come here to see if I could find help from another who has walked this particular walk.
Thanks for any insight or direction.
- Pete
Comments
-
Welcome to the forums. There is no way to avoid all Catholic authored resources which would arguably include removing all resources written before the Reformation, including the Bible itself. The way to remove all resources that you perceive as being written by Catholics is to manual tag the books with a tag such as Catholic (or heresy or trash if it better fits your sense of humor). I say "that you perceive as being written by Catholics" as there are books written by authors bearing other denominational tags whose work is thoroughly Catholic. This is especially true of some Anglican, Lutheran, Orthodox, and mystical writers. Now create a collection of all your books minus the books with your tags. I do something similar to remove all "popular trash theology" from my library when I want to do academic work and don't want to wade through books intended for the popular market.
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
2 -
The Collectors Edition contains all the Logos ( insert denomination) here Porfolio Libraries including the Stanard Portfolio Library. It's the big grab bag for those who want it all regardless of denomination.
So not only have your got 'Reformed' and 'Catholic' authors but also 'Baptist', 'Anglican' 'Lutheran', 'Orthodox', 'Pentecostal & Charisatic', 'Messianic Jewish', 'Methodist & Wesleyan' authors and no doubt authors from other traditons as well that are mixed into these lbiraries that don't have a speficic package of their own. If you looked clossely at every author in your Logos 9 Reformed Portfolio library you will find not every author is 'Reformed'. because in Reformed circles and seminaries you will find they don't just use books written by 'Reformed' authors.
So if you are not comfortable with reading the views of authors from some of these other denominations you are gong to have a lot more to tag and hide. And then you will have books in your library like the Perspectives and Counterpoint Series that include authors from diferent denominations or theological posistions dicussing their views on a given topics. So even individual books in your libary will be written by authors across denominations.
If it was me I'd tag all of the 'Reformed' authors that I was familar with and creating a collection based on this tag and using this collection to get only reformed views when this is important to what I was are trying to achieve. And at other times I'd look at my wider library to get a borad perspective. But that's just how I would go about it, not saying you have to take this approach.
0 -
To be complete you'd end up hiding the Bible too, or at least the New Testament, as it was written by Catholic authors.
1 -
There are collections of authors per denomination and Logos even classifies commentaries per denomination (not yet exposed in the library, unfortunately), so of course it is possible to build such a collection or to simply use it. You might want to follow the Faithlife group https://faithlife.com/logos-library-theology-denomination-tags/activity then you can look e.g. in Logos under Documents / Groups and will find collections.
Have joy in the Lord!
1 -
Peter McCallum said:
Hello everyone.
Thank you for reading and / or replying.
I'm a tag'er. Every book that arrives, either gets a tag, or gets hidden. I recognize buying Collectors would be overwhelming, but the nice thing is, the tags (or collections) 'stick' for years and years. Worth the effort.
And I tag theology coming into the library. One for Catholic, one for Orthodox, and the rest for Protestant. Yes, where not obvious, I 'thumb' the TOC. But author-wise, I tag by historical author ... they get ref'd frequently, so it's good to be able to see each author in my library.
Nice and neat.
"If myth is ideology in narrative form, then scholarship is myth with footnotes." B. Lincolm 1999.
0 -
DMB said:
I'm a tag'er. Every book that arrives, either gets a tag, or gets hidden.
Same here. This is probably the single best thing I learned from the forums. And, thankfully, I learned it when my library was still small. New books get tagged first of all, then get recorded in my Calibre library.
1 -
Thanks Simon's Brother, a good approach, I know most Reformed Authors, next to none for Catholic Authors.
0 -
Thanks Yasmin, I will now be a Tag'er, and a Googler.
0 -
Thanks for the welcoming M.J.
0 -
Pete, FYI. if you purchased the Collectors Edition within the last 30 days, and feel it is not meeting your needs/expectations, you can contact customer services and return it for a refund as Logos has a 'thirty-day money-back guarantee return period on all non-subscription products'.
0 -
Thanks Dave, good to know.
0 -
Thanks Mick. I will take a look.
0 -
The bible is not Catholic. The bible teaches Faith alone, and Catholics teach the false heretical gospel of faith + works. try again!
Your assertion is incorrect. I know reasonably accurately what Catholicism teaches and what Catholics have done historically - good and bad. If you would find it useful, I can recommend books both on the formation and transmission of Scripture and of Church history. Please follow the Logos guidelines - note I said "arguably" rather than asserting a particular position.
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
3 -
MJ. 😀? I'd be interested in some of those resource recommendations.
mm.
0 -
Mobile Ed: NT281 How We Got the New Testament (4 hour course) | Logos Bible Software
Mobile Ed: OT281 How We Got the Old Testament (5 hour course) | Logos Bible Software
How We Got the Bible | Logos Bible Software
The Origin of the Bible | Logos Bible Software
Old Testament Textual Criticism: A Practical Introduction, 2nd ed. | Logos Bible Software
Holy Resilience: The Bible’s Traumatic Origins | Logos Bible Software
1 -
@Kiyah. Now, that's quite a list. I'll have to check to see what's naughty and nice 🤣👵
Thanks!
1 -
Thank you, Kiyah. I was attracted to the Carr volume (Holy Resilience), though Logos sells at list and the big A more competitive. So.
But. Then I found Carr's other volume on Logos.com (canon related):
Which … on the Big A goes for a whopping $185. Although different page count, same contributors/articles etc. A find!
"If myth is ideology in narrative form, then scholarship is myth with footnotes." B. Lincolm 1999.
1 -
Don’t waste your time with that guy! Next thing you’ll know is he’ll be harassing you with private messages 🙄
0 -
If anything, I'd want the option to hide every author I agree with. I mean, who wants to live in an echo chamber? I want resources that challenge me with new ideas.
0
