PBB - Converting pdf and epub to docx

Mike Childs
Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭
edited November 2024 in English Forum

Many public domain documents are in pdf format, and must be converted to docx before making a Logos PBB resource.

I have found that the AVS document converter does this pretty well, and it is pretty cheap.  It will convert between pdf, epub, docx, html and other formats.  So you can download a pdf or epub public domain book, and convert to docx in one step. 

I have no interest in promoting AVS or any other software, but I found this helpful and thought I would mention it.  Works for me. 

Of course once the document is converted you have some work to do in preparing it - depending on the type of resource.

Again, AVS Document Converter is not free, but it is very reasonable.  I bought it some time back because it has lots of uses.


"In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

Comments

  • Lee Herbst
    Lee Herbst Member Posts: 1 ✭✭

    Calibre is free. It is an eBook library manager and it has a lot of conversion tools. It can't convert to docx, but it can convert to rtf (which Word reads) and that works for me. Just another option for those looking to convert eBooks.

  • Brother Mark
    Brother Mark Member Posts: 945 ✭✭

    Calibre is free. It is an eBook library manager and it has a lot of conversion tools. It can't convert to docx, but it can convert to rtf (which Word reads) and that works for me. Just another option for those looking to convert eBooks.

    [Y] I totally agree that Calibre is wonderful.  Probably the most comprehensive document conversion tool out there.  Since its free, the price is PERFECT!

     

    "I read dead people..."

  • Bohuslav Wojnar
    Bohuslav Wojnar Member Posts: 3,477 ✭✭✭

    Calibre is great, better IMHO than AVS software (I just tried that one). The best conversion from pdf is done by Adobe Acrobat and Nitro. However non of those tools does it really well. Footers and Headers are not recognized and footnotes are not converted to docx footnotes. Headings are also not recognized to create a structure of the document in docx file. You have to do all those things manually. If somebody would find a conversion tool that does all of those things, that would be a real help in creating PBBs from pdf files. 

    Bohuslav

  • Stephen Chaffer
    Stephen Chaffer Member Posts: 75 ✭✭

    Hi, I use a OCR program to convert pdf (or pic files); it does not place the foot-End-notes at the bottom of each page, so one has to go through them in WORD to make (docx). for the mac there is a program called TUFO IS FREE [it also allows you to open password protected PDF], this open the PDF and you can copy paste into WORD (paste as text only (don't use the formet paste).

    If someone whats their doc files changed to docx, I'd be able to do that conversion for you [this is me opening and saving the files only].

  • gigiwill
    gigiwill Member Posts: 1 ✭✭
  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    gigiwill said:

    But this does not solve the footnotes problem.  There are dozens of easy conversions, but I know of none that converts the footnotes to Word doc footnotes.  Any body found one that does?


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • Room4more
    Room4more Member Posts: 1,730 ✭✭✭


    gigiwill said:

    But this does not solve the footnotes problem.  There are dozens of easy conversions, but I know of none that converts the footnotes to Word doc footnotes.  Any body found one that does?


    And you probably won’t either. Just consider how the footnotes are added to the word doc, you need to do them. U can convert a doc to pdf but then u loose the connection that was created in the doc. Unfortunately that connection is not restored once u convert to a word doc.

     

    U can however, copy/paste the text from the pdf to word and have the link………

     

    DISCLAIMER: What you do on YOUR computer is your doing.

  • NetworkGeek
    NetworkGeek Member Posts: 3,764 ✭✭✭

    I really think a Word macro to create true footnotes from a converted PDF is quite possible, I just haven't gotten time to play much with it. Rosie did a post on a similar thought. In short it would:

    -search for the next numerical footnote in the next (matching the superscript/format used in that document; this would need to be edited from document to document but not a big deal)

    -once found - mark location - find that formatted number at end of document. Select all text to end of that section (or could be to select up to next superscripted number matching footnote format, etc.) - cut that text and the footnote number

    - go back to the marked location - delete the footnote text, add a true endnote or footnote, then paste the text back in. Proceed to beginning until there are no more footnotes to process.

    Maybe Steve can work on this, he is a macro guru? [8-|]

  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    Sounds like I need to get busy learning about how to do a Word macro.


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • Mitchell
    Mitchell Member Posts: 454 ✭✭

    I use Calibre myself, but I find that HTMLZ is a better intermediary format than RTF, because it supports images and a few more formatting options. Word still opens it fine. I don't remember how it does with footnotes, but it wouldn't surprise me if they worked.

  • Alen
    Alen Member Posts: 1 ✭✭

    You can try out some online resources if you do not want to install additional applications on your PC.

    From interesting:

    convertonlinefree.com

    go4convert.com

  • Tes
    Tes Member Posts: 4,035 ✭✭✭

    Many public domain documents are in pdf format, and must be converted to docx before making a Logos PBB resource.

    I have found that the AVS document converter does this pretty well, and it is pretty cheap.  It will convert between pdf, epub, docx, html and other formats.  So you can download a pdf or epub public domain book, and convert to docx in one step. 

    I have no interest in promoting AVS or any other software, but I found this helpful and thought I would mention it.  Works for me. 

    Of course once the document is converted you have some work to do in preparing it - depending on the type of resource.

    Again, AVS Document Converter is not free, but it is very reasonable.  I bought it some time back because it has lots of uses.

    HI, Michael,  before buying it, to know whether  it works with the link I have shown here, could you please try this and post it  in a screenshot? (From Romans)http://www.biblica.com/bibles/amharic/

    Blessings in Christ.

  • Rusty Davidson
    Rusty Davidson Member Posts: 90 ✭✭

    Microsoft Word 2013 has an automatic pdf converter so that you open a pdf and save as docx. I have been using the preview version for several days and it does a good job. Seems to be faster than Adobe"s OCR technology and some of the online versions (including Nuance, which used to be my favorite.) It seems to be much more accurate as well. Naturally, like all converters in has its flaws, but seems to be something Microsoft has actually done fairly well for a change. You can find Office 2013 in a preview version for now, but they have not released pricing or date of full release yet.

  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    Tes said:

    Many public domain documents are in pdf format, and must be converted to docx before making a Logos PBB resource.

    I have found that the AVS document converter does this pretty well, and it is pretty cheap.  It will convert between pdf, epub, docx, html and other formats.  So you can download a pdf or epub public domain book, and convert to docx in one step. 

    I have no interest in promoting AVS or any other software, but I found this helpful and thought I would mention it.  Works for me. 

    Of course once the document is converted you have some work to do in preparing it - depending on the type of resource.

    Again, AVS Document Converter is not free, but it is very reasonable.  I bought it some time back because it has lots of uses.

    HI, Michael,  before buying it, to know whether  it works with the link I have shown here, could you please try this and post it  in a screenshot? (From Romans)http://www.biblica.com/bibles/amharic/


    Tess, yes I will try several programs including AVS, and post results. Just got home tonight from a conference all this week. It will be Monday before I can do it.

     


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • Tes
    Tes Member Posts: 4,035 ✭✭✭

    Tes said:

    Many public domain documents are in pdf format, and must be converted to docx before making a Logos PBB resource.

    I have found that the AVS document converter does this pretty well, and it is pretty cheap.  It will convert between pdf, epub, docx, html and other formats.  So you can download a pdf or epub public domain book, and convert to docx in one step. 

    I have no interest in promoting AVS or any other software, but I found this helpful and thought I would mention it.  Works for me. 

    Of course once the document is converted you have some work to do in preparing it - depending on the type of resource.

    Again, AVS Document Converter is not free, but it is very reasonable.  I bought it some time back because it has lots of uses.

    HI, Michael,  before buying it, to know whether  it works with the link I have shown here, could you please try this and post it  in a screenshot? (From Romans)http://www.biblica.com/bibles/amharic/


    Tess, yes I will try several programs including AVS, and post results. Just got home tonight from a conference all this week. It will be Monday before I can do it.

     

    Thank you Michael.I am looking forward.

    Blessings in Christ.

  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    Tes,

    I tried with AVS, Calibre, and a few other programs.  However, I got none that could convert that pdf and preserve the language or scrpt.  It all came out jibberish.  I think a big part of the problem is that I do not have a Windows font for that language or alphabet.

    I regret that I was no help to you. 


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • Tes
    Tes Member Posts: 4,035 ✭✭✭

    Tes,

    I tried with AVS, Calibre, and a few other programs.  However, I got none that could convert that pdf and preserve the language or scrpt.  It all came out jibberish.  I think a big part of the problem is that I do not have a Windows font for that language or alphabet.

    I regret that I was no help to you. 

    HI,Michael, it was discussed in this thread:http://community.logos.com/forums/p/27083/199945.aspx#199945 Gary Keene was able to convert  it to Word decument correctly,long ago before there was no PB,where he highlighted it: and he discovered the fonts as well,he has attached them under his comments,it would be veryhelpful if you could refer the thread, I thank you once again for helping me.

    Blessings in Christ.

  • Bohuslav Wojnar
    Bohuslav Wojnar Member Posts: 3,477 ✭✭✭

    Microsoft Word 2013 has an automatic pdf converter so that you open a pdf and save as docx. I have been using the preview version for several days and it does a good job. Seems to be faster than Adobe"s OCR technology and some of the online versions (including Nuance, which used to be my favorite.) It seems to be much more accurate as well. Naturally, like all converters in has its flaws, but seems to be something Microsoft has actually done fairly well for a change. You can find Office 2013 in a preview version for now, but they have not released pricing or date of full release yet.

    Yes, I also tried many converters (Adobe, Nitro, Calibre, AVS, etc. etc.) with not good results. I installed MS Office 2013 Preview version and it's converting ability from pdf to docx is very promising. Especially those pdf that have been saved from docx by MS Word are converted very well. 

    Bohuslav

  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    I installed MS Office 2013 Preview version and it's converting ability from pdf to docx is very promising. Especially those pdf that have been saved from docx by MS Word are converted very well. 

    Sounds like wonderful news.  I am going to give it a try as well.

     


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • David Sloan
    David Sloan Member Posts: 183 ✭✭

    What's the latest on this? Is Microsoft Word 2013 the best route? Calibre? I have a number of pdfs that I would like to convert to personal books, but I have yet to discover a good way of doing the conversion, especially with Greek fonts and footnotes.

  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    David,

    The best solution I have found - and it is very reasonably priced - is by Adobe.  For about $20 per year Adobe will convert PDF  documents to docx for you on line. This service is a part of the Adobe Reader program.  


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • Tes
    Tes Member Posts: 4,035 ✭✭✭

    [quote user="Michael Childs"]

    David,

    The best solution I have found - and it is very reasonably priced - is by Adobe.  For about $20 per year Adobe will convert PDF  documents to docx for you on line. This service is a part of the Adobe Reader program.  

    [/quote]

    Hi Michael. I want to see if it works fine with the Link I am sending.Could you please try it?

    Blessings in Christ.

  • Mike Childs
    Mike Childs Member Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭

    Tes said:

    [quote user="Michael Childs"]

    David,

    The best solution I have found - and it is very reasonably priced - is by Adobe.  For about $20 per year Adobe will convert PDF  documents to docx for you on line. This service is a part of the Adobe Reader program.  

    [/quote]

    Hi Michael. I want to see if it works fine with the Link I am sending.Could you please try it?

    Just saw you post, Teas, and I tried to convert the Philemon PDF. It looks like the original except the font is wrong.  Apparently I don't have that font.


    "In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley

  • Danny Parker
    Danny Parker Member Posts: 438 ✭✭

    Word 2013 appears to create appropriate footnotes from a PDF. It worked on the free ebook Story of God Philippians. I have not done extensive research on it, but it looks like it did everything properly.

  • Danny Parker
    Danny Parker Member Posts: 438 ✭✭

    Second book did not convert footnotes properly (Sermon on the Mount Story of God). Don't have time right now to research why there is a difference, but it did not work on the second book.

  • Royce Odiyar
    Royce Odiyar Member Posts: 2 ✭✭

    Hi Friends, I have been searching for months now how to easily create a .DOCX file for building a personal book in Logos and have given up several times, never finding a good solution. But once again I found myself experimenting this morning when I should have been working on a sermon and a million other things.

    Conclusion: just before giving up again an idea popped into my mind half inspired by this thread and the other half by our kind and all wise heavenly Father. So I hope this solution helps you as much as it did me and happy fathers day to any fathers and to The Father of Lights!

    Nine to 14 Simple Steps:

    1. STEP 1: Create or download a PDF 

      Note: if 

    2. STEP 2: Upload PDF to Microsoft OneDrive 

      Note: if you do not have a Microsoft account it is totally worth getting. Also, note that they let you use any email address to sign up, so you don't even have to manage a 


    3. STEP 3-6: Open PDF in OneDrive / click, "EDIT IN WORD" / then a Dialogue Box will pop-up called 'File Conversion' click 'Convert' after the conversion the same Dialogue box will come back, this time click 'Edit'. 

    4. Once the file is open and in edit mode, you can now make any changes you desire before saving it. 

    5. STEP 7-9:  click 'FILE' in the menu bar / click 'Save As' / click 'Download a Copy'

      AND bada bing bada boom and your done...but if your not completely sure how to build the book, here are your final simple steps. 

    6. STEP 10-14: Open 'LOGOS' / click 'Tools' / click 'Personal Books' under the 'Library Column' / click 'Add Book' in the new window that opens / then just file in parts 1 and 2 and then part 3 is the final click 'Build Book'. 

      As soon as your book is built it will open up and you can see if everything formatted perfectly. 

    Note: This is the easiest and best way to build personal books in Logos 5. It's free, fast and highly functional. I haven't spent much time playing around with it, but all of the 5+ books I built that have chapter headings are automatically recognized in Logos. In other words, as far as I can tell, any headings that you want Logos to recognize need to be designated as "headings" in your OneDrive Word App. 

    Hope this helps. 

    God Bless you all!

  • Fred Chapman
    Fred Chapman Member Posts: 5,899 ✭✭✭

    Nine to 14 Simple Steps:

    Note: This is the easiest and best way to build personal books in Logos 5. It's free, fast and highly functional. I haven't spent much time playing around with it, but all of the 5+ books I built that have chapter headings are automatically recognized in Logos. In other words, as far as I can tell, any headings that you want Logos to recognize need to be designated as "headings" in your OneDrive Word App. 

    Hope this helps. 

    God Bless you all!

    You do not need a OneDrive account to do this if you have a word processor that will open .pdf files. I know MS Word and Openoffice are two that do.

    The problem in converting PDFs is the way the particular file is formatted. With some the process will work great. With some the process will work but requires some editing before you save it as a .docx. With some PDF's the editing work required after opening in Word is overwhelming and maybe impossible.

    I have tried several free PDF converters (downloaded and online) and found none that are perfect. Calibre does a decent job on many files, but is not perfect either. I know there are some paid apps (some quite costly) that claim to be great. I do not need that feature enough so it would not make sense to spend any money on it. 

  • Brother Mark
    Brother Mark Member Posts: 945 ✭✭

    I can echo Fredc's experience completely.... I have finally moved from Calibre to the best conversion tool I've found: Wondershare PDF editor Pro.  It costs $79 US, but so far it has been perfect, and as a side benefit.... also converts to any MS Office format and does a good job with OCR conversions.

    "I read dead people..."

  • Robert M. Warren
    Robert M. Warren Member Posts: 2,459 ✭✭✭

    BroMk:

    How do to the files converted by Wondershare fare with regard to pictures? My experience with converting in Word 2013 is that the pictures/graphics in the docx generally do not make it into the PB when compiled, without a great deal of agony. Word does do a great job with footnotes, if they were "live" in the PDF. If Wondershare maintains live footnotes and the resulting docx has images that will compile in PBs without a lot of noodling around, it would be worth 80 bucks, indeed,

    FWIW: I currently employ a hodgepodge of methods, depending on the source of the file and the relative prominence of footnotes vs images. See the two link in my signature.  

    macOS (Logos Pro - Beta) | Android 13 (Logos Stable)

    Smile

  • Everett Headley
    Everett Headley Member Posts: 951 ✭✭

    This my be OT, but I am wondering why yall pay for converting pdf files?  I use this one online and it's free and I don't have to sign up for anything.  Am I missing something?  

    http://www.pdfonline.com/pdf-to-word-converter/?utm_expid=127285-82.hVyA0iq5Q9ynae28757vDQ.0&utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2F

  • Bishop Salamat Khokhar
    Bishop Salamat Khokhar Member Posts: 105 ✭✭

    Hello friends.. greetings.  I have converted several PDF for PBB.  I have expereinced that the Hebrew and Greek  just  get messed up in the converted DOCX.  

    If you had any success with proper conversion of Hebrew and Greek with any software, please share the name of the software.  

    Thanks

    BSK

  • Brother Mark
    Brother Mark Member Posts: 945 ✭✭

    BroMk:

    How do to the files converted by Wondershare fare with regard to pictures? My experience with converting in Word 2013 is that the pictures/graphics in the docx generally do not make it into the PB when compiled, without a great deal of agony. Word does do a great job with footnotes, if they were "live" in the PDF. If Wondershare maintains live footnotes and the resulting docx has images that will compile in PBs without a lot of noodling around, it would be worth 80 bucks, indeed,

    FWIW: I currently employ a hodgepodge of methods, depending on the source of the file and the relative prominence of footnotes vs images. See the two link in my signature.  

    Robert,  Why not link a freely redistributable PDF with pictures, footnote references, etc. that you'd like to compare to a Wondershare converted file.  I'll convert it and post it here for everyone's review and comments.

    "I read dead people..."

  • Robert M. Warren
    Robert M. Warren Member Posts: 2,459 ✭✭✭

    macOS (Logos Pro - Beta) | Android 13 (Logos Stable)

    Smile

  • JohnB
    JohnB Member Posts: 1,085 ✭✭

    I have yet to discover a good way of doing the conversion, especially with Greek fonts and footnotes.

    The biggest problem here that I have is where the original document did not use Unicode Greek & Hebrew fonts but instead used custom pre-unicode fonts. The only way to deal with that I have found is to type in the words manually using unicode fonts. Sadly many theologians still do not seem to have discovered the virtues of unicode yet and still use specialist fonts. I do speak as a non-Greek/Hebrew student so might not appreciate possible problems of using unicode fonts!

  • JohnB
    JohnB Member Posts: 1,085 ✭✭

    But once again I found myself experimenting this morning when I should have been working on a sermon

    GREAT!!!!  IT DOES WORK FOR FOOTNOTES!!!

    This is the most practical & useful sermon that I have read for a while. [:D]

    I wish someone had preached this to me several months ago it would have saved me so many hours of re-creating live footnotes! For the record & for the benefit of any other readers I have Word 10 which will not open pdf documents itself.

    Thanks so much.

  • JohnB
    JohnB Member Posts: 1,085 ✭✭

    I have experienced that the Hebrew and Greek  just  get messed up in the converted DOCX.

    This is often the same with me!

    This my understanding of things and if I am not correct I hope that someone will correct me.Briefly I know of no pdf converters that will always produce perfect results for Hebrew & Greek from all types of pdf. I am guessing that IF the original document had been a MSWord document that had been turned into a pdf using Word 2013 or OneDrive as suggested by Royce Odiyar might well usually work perfectly.

    There appear to be several causes to the problem that you are facing (other than a pdf that is so poor that the software can't identify the characters correctly). One is associated with the method that was used to produce the original Greek or Hebrew and has caused most of my prodlems.

    Before Unicode fonts were introduced, there were only 255 or so characters in any specific font so that special Greek or Hebrew fonts were produced and as long as the actual Greek or Hebrew words were formatted with the relevant Greek or Hebrew font all was well. Many (most? all?) pdf converters are unable to detect when a specialised font was used on the original document (and the font probably does not exist on the users computer anyway so could not be displayed) so on conversion  you get a bunch of gibberish.

    If Unicode fonts were used in the original document (as Logos seems to)  Greek & Hebrew have their own specific dedicated characters which are usually included in the main common fonts used on most computers so the Greek & Hebrew usually comes through the conversion correctly.

    Sorry not to give you a nice solution.

  • Nora Limpsung
    Nora Limpsung Member Posts: 1 ✭✭

    The easiest way is to go through an online service like http://online-pdf.org. I know there are more sites doing this but i found this one reliable enough. Hope this helps, god bless you :)

  • Scott
    Scott Member Posts: 23 ✭✭

    This is not to disparage the kind and helpful people in this thread offering workable solutions (thank you!), but like virtually everything else about this software, this seems like a ridiculously cumbersome thing to have to do. The "P" in "PDF" means "portable." Logos should just provide the ability to upload a PDF so it can be read in the software. What would be so difficult about that? I get that it would not be able to take advantage of some Logos functionality with the book, but I'd be OK with that. They can still allow all the convoluted mess described above to import fully functioning books, but forcing me to have to recreate and reformat a document from PDF to DOCX just to read it? Not exactly user friendly.

    So much about this software is a user experience nightmare (like requiring obscure code to search for text across your library highlighted with a specific highlight style). It's a real shame they can't figure out a way to create a better user experience since the resources are so spectacular.

  • MJ. Smith
    MJ. Smith MVP Posts: 54,952

    What would be so difficult about that?

    A great deal - have you ever tried to process a proprietary format document?

    Logos developed personal books as a means of users including their own works in the software and intended to build a PB bookstore based on that assumption. It was not designed as a means of importing books from other sources - we just decided to use it as such.

    Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."

  • The "P" in "PDF" means "portable."

    Portability works well for printing. Document format allows text and/or images to be in file. Images of text can humanly be read, but need conversion to digital text for use in Logos, which includes highlighting and searching. Image conversion provides opportunities for many discussions.

    Thankful can include images in personal books (avoid "tight" formatting around image in Word).

    ... but forcing me to have to recreate and reformat a document from PDF to DOCX just to read it? Not exactly user friendly.

    Creating and modifying docx file(s) for personal book(s) can be labor intensive, but also allows tagging to be added. Thankful for forum discussions, which include => Power Tip: Using variables to Search and Replace in Word and => Unpointed Hebrew Masoretic Text Personal Book

    It's a real shame they can't figure out a way to create a better user experience since the resources are so spectacular.

    Suggestion is creating new thread(s) to discuss user experience issue(s); ideally one issue per thread with what is frustrating about current implementation plus any idea(s) about what could be better.

    Anticipate some discussions will result in Logos User Voice suggestion references and new ones => https://logos.uservoice.com/forums/42823-logos-bible-software-7 

    Every Logos and Verbum user has 10 votes with the option to place up to three on one suggestion.

    Suggestion Implement PDF import for PBB was declined

    We do not currently plan to implement PDF import, but instead recommend the use of a PDF to Word converter (there are many available, and the forums are a good place to ask for suggestions).

     

    You can also add your votes to this open case for PDF support: http://logos.uservoice.com/forums/42823-logos-bible-software-5/suggestions/1096505-pdf-docx-files

    Suggestion PDF, docx files has been completed

    Personal Book Builder can convert docx files into Logos books.

     

    We will not be adding PDF import/conversion. There are many commercial programs available that can convert PDF to docx (which can then be imported using Personal Book Builder). Discussions of these programs (as they relate to PBB can be found in our forums: https://community.logos.com/forums/

    For highlighting, personally prefer visual filters whose search results have my desired highlighting. Current implementation of highlighting words has textual fragments in Note document(s), which is unattractive for searching since word(s) are missing.

    Keep Smiling [:)]

  • Bernhard
    Bernhard Member Posts: 728 ✭✭✭

    This is not to disparage the kind and helpful people in this thread offering workable solutions (thank you!), but like virtually everything else about this software, this seems like a ridiculously cumbersome thing to have to do. The "P" in "PDF" means "portable." Logos should just provide the ability to upload a PDF so it can be read in the software. What would be so difficult about that? I get that it would not be able to take advantage of some Logos functionality with the book, but I'd be OK with that. They can still allow all the convoluted mess described above to import fully functioning books, but forcing me to have to recreate and reformat a document from PDF to DOCX just to read it? Not exactly user friendly.

    So much about this software is a user experience nightmare (like requiring obscure code to search for text across your library highlighted with a specific highlight style). It's a real shame they can't figure out a way to create a better user experience since the resources are so spectacular.

    I think if you see the whole picture, it is a wise decision on Faithlife's part to not allow import of PDF. Some of the criticism comes from people not really understanding what PDFs are (and what they are not). PDF is a format to recreate on the screen exactly what you would see in printed format. It looks exactly the same on any device you open it with. It is also a good format to print from. But it is not a good format, if you want to do anything more than just read the page as is.

    Logos could implement PDF support in two ways:

    The easy way would for it to be just a viewer with very basic functionality, but not automatic tagging of Bible references or any of the options in the right-click menu. The text would not re-flow, so you would need to reserve a lot of your screen space to the pane showing the PDF (as most of those are in A4 or Letter format). I am not sure where this would be better than to store links to your PDFs under Favorites and open them from there in your normal PDF reader program.

    The second way would be to try to actually process the content of the PDFs and allow for text re-flow, look-ups etc.I think that would be a support nightmare and we would have daily questions here in the forum: "Why does this not work with my PDF?"

    A few of the issues that would come up:

    • Lots and lots of formatting/layout issues, columns that run into each other, page numbers in the middle of the text, font issues, especially with non-Latin scripts, etc.
    • PDFs that are scans of books where the text is actually just a picture, now way for Logos to process that
    • PDFs that are scanned, but have a text layer in addition to the image. Which one should Logos show? The text layer only would probably show very bad formatting. In most cases there are also many mistakes in the text (OCR) layer, which you usually don't notice just looking at the PDF
    • people trying to open PDFs that are protected by DRM

    Just try to open a few PDFs in MS Word (directly possible from Word 2013, I think). Whatever you see there is probably what an implementation in Logos would look like. If you like what you see, which will be the case for some PDFs, why not just click "Save as", chose .docx and then import that as a PB in Logos? It's only one additional step.

    If you don't like what you see, the file needs manual work - it's almost impossible to do that work in an automated way. And where better to do that kind of work, than in a program like MS Word?

    What would be so difficult about that?

    A lot, actually, as I have shown above.