Highlighting: Single-tap selects a highlight
Comments
-
As I use often use a wide variety of highlights, I much prefer the old way of selecting highlights using a single tap. The new way takes considerably more time and effort. Please, please consider reverting.0
-
@Ben last week the status of this suggestion was changed to "In Progress". That means that we'll be releasing an update that will be restoring the old functionality that tapping on a highlight will select it.0
-
We've heard you all! We'll be releasing an update that restores the old functionality of tapping on a highlight to select it. I'm sorry for the disruption to your workflows. We try not to cause too much disruption, but this particular issue wasn't flagged during our beta process, so we misunderstood how important it was to some of you. But I appreciate your prompt feedback, which will allow us to put it right fairly quickly.0
-
@Mark Barnes (Logos) I'm happy to confess that I now realize that all of my intuitions on this matter were wrong. When I used to work in software, the words "We changed this for several reasons" meant "this is how it is forever now ". Thanks for hearing us.
What happens now for the users who were delighted with this change ?0 -
@Mark Barnes (Logos)
Mark ,
What about those of us who were so excited to see this new change that allowed us to easily move between menus?
What about those of us who found the ability to choose between multiple highlights to be a better use than having to figure out how to differentiate between them?
Save for having a way to copy the contents of a highlight, the new change is much more precise than the old way, even if it does take an extra click or two.
Perhaps you could find a way of letting the user choose how they use single-tap, double-tap, and long-press - as choosing just one way only will alienate one group or the other. One of the great advantages of Logos has always been having a number of different ways to do things within the program, with the ability to choose the one that works best for you.Above all these things, walk in love, which is the bond of perfection. - Colossians 3:14
0 -
@Sam Shelton – Long-pressing and double-tapping will still work in the same way they do now. The only behavior we're reverting is what happens when you single-tap on a highlight. In v32, that dismisses the UI. In v33, that will select the highlight.0
-
Definitely needs to be reversed. There's already a way to see the menus: you tap the top of the screen. This just removed functionality without adding new functionality.
Please reverse this to the prior functionality that selected the entire bible verse with the single tap on it if there was no highlight on that verse.0 -
@Geoff B There's already a way to show the menus. You tap the toolbar visible at the top of the screen where it shows the name of the current document.0
-
Am I missing something? Lots of talk about needing a way to show the menu bars. There already is one. You tap the small toolbar at the top of the screen that shows the document name. Doing that makes the top and bottom menu bars visible.
I don't know how to do it on Android but that's how it works on iOS.0 -
@Mark Barnes (Logos) Thanks Mark — for listening to Logos users , responding to Logos users , and for trying to make Logos work in a manner that is beneficial to all of us!
Above all these things, walk in love, which is the bond of perfection. - Colossians 3:14
0 -
Thank you for making the decision to roll back these changes. I really thought I was experiencing some sort of bug.0
-
-
We will be restoring this functionality in an upcoming release.
Ali Pope | Logos Desktop and Mobile Program Manager
0 -
We are restoring the single-tap functionality to select a highlight. This will come in an upcoming release.
Ali Pope | Logos Desktop and Mobile Program Manager
0 -
@Mark Barnes (Logos) Mark, please remember these principle in UI design
This one is straight from the Apple HIG, and straying from it got swift opposition as it always will:
• Respond to gestures in ways that are consistent with other apps on the device. People expect most gestures to work the same regardless of their current context. For example , people expect tap to activate or select an object.
• Handle gestures as responsively as possible. Gestures enhance the experience of direct manipulation and provide immediate feedback
If there’s a way , people will find it and cling to it. Long-presses are the least preferred gesture that should never be used to select an object like a highlight that’s in direct view.
Similarly , revealing the menubar by tapping inside a scrolling view is intrusive.
The mindset behind the most recent change is what is most troubling about it
The fact that someone thought this long press on part of the sentence was a better approach to managing highlights indicates the people who work on this app don’t necessarily use it heavily , thus things like verse selection aren’t about to get easier , nor the many inconsistencies such as highlight behavior when the verse number is selected versus without , etc.0 -
I hate these new changes. I wish you would've left them alone as it was much easier to use.0
-
@Mark Barnes (Logos) Please do it soon. I'm discouraged from reading on my ipad with Logos.0
-
@Gary Takahashi It will be available in v33, which is due to be released on April 9.0
-
@Ali Pope is this happening any time soon? So hard to use right now0
-
The change will be released in a few short weeks. I will update this post when the update is available.
Ali Pope | Logos Desktop and Mobile Program Manager
0 -
This is available in the latest update on the app (version 33).
Ali Pope | Logos Desktop and Mobile Program Manager
0 -
Tap-to-select for highlights was restored in v33, which was released earlier this week.0
-
@Ali Pope I really appreciate this update and the great customer support in general.0
