Logos Now and Faithlife Connect: The Why
Background Facts
(This is context, not the explanation for Faithlife Connect; the explanation follows.)
The software world is moving to subscription products accessed from any device anywhere via the cloud.
If we were to start new today, we would probably be a subscription-only product.
New users are asking for, and expect, a subscription offering.
Existing users are accustomed, and often prefer, to pay once and 'own' the software. They expect that upgrades will need to be purchased every other year or so.
Logos Bible Software has historically been priced in such a way that our bills are paid by book purchases; we've never charged enough for 'software' or 'features' to actually cover our costs.
We wouldn't do it that way if we were starting from scratch today, but that's where we are based on history and user expectations.
Many (but thankfully not all) of our "best customers" have built 'large enough for now' libraries, and are purchasing fewer ebooks, yet continue to want new features, and (as everyone adapts to the continual upgrade model of apps, subscription software, etc.,) they _expect_ new features more often, and at lower and lower (or no!) cost.
As previously noted, we've never charged enough for our software to cover our costs; ebook purchases have to cover book production costs, royalties, AND our non-trivial software development and other costs.
At the same time, pricing on other ebook (and content) platforms with different cost structures and pricing models are creating pressure to reduce the price of ebooks, lowering the revenue that we (unlike the competitors) use to subsidize our development costs.
What Logos Now Attempted
Logos Cloud was our plan for a subscription-only product, for new customers who wanted it. It was an alternative to transactional purchase, which we still offered. (We underestimated how many people would be confused that it wasn't a primarily inside-the-web-browser experience, which only now works well.)
Logos Now was a hybrid offering, essentially a kind of 'dynamic price' for people who had made a transactional investment, allowing them to get Logos Cloud without paying full price, since they already had lots of books and a significant investment.
How Logos Now Failed
Access to new features early, as they were released, was just a little part of what we imagined Logos Now would be, which we hoped would make it more attractive to transaction users, helping them transition to a subscription world.
It worked too well, and the tail began to wag the dog. Logos Cloud didn't mature quickly enough (because it needed a stronger web app, which wasn't yet there) and Logos Now's 'new features every six weeks started to feel like its primary benefit.
New customers, who should have only needed to choose between "Buy" or "Subscribe" were regularly being sent into a very confusing, and frustrating, pitch to both buy AND subscribe. Pure subscription wasn't attractive enough (without larger libraries and a pure-web solution), but just buying and owning felt 'left out' because Logos Now offered 'new stuff without the wait.'
Worse, as the tail wagged the dog, Logos Now subscribers (who turned out to vastly outnumber Logos Cloud subscribers) began seeing the product's entire value as the regular release of new features. (Which was not the original intention.)
And trying to make a new feature every six weeks leads to smaller, less significant features just to 'check the box'. It hurts our ability to dedicate team energy to bigger features and changes that might take months to develop, but which deliver more value.
Planning for the Future
The old and new models are less compatible than we'd hoped, and the user needs are different. We tried to make a hybrid model, and it just frustrated and confused people. Moreover, hybrid models mess up business models, contracts, etc.
We need a true 'no purchase necessary, pure subscription' product. That's Faithlife Connect, and it's a great value that offers Logos Bible Software via the web (and mobile, and even download if you want), as well as Faithlife TV, Courses, and more.
We also need to support the pure transactional model for people who want to 'buy it, own it, and not have to pay again.' That's what we've always offered, and what we plan to continue to offer.
We need to remove the 'purchase, own, and yet you still need to subscribe to get the coolest/latest/best' model which confused everyone and particularly frustrated new customers. In addition to creating unrealistic expectations for exciting new features every six weeks. (Because, tying back to the facts above, pricing it just for new features doesn't cover the cost to create them, and the kind of features we can ship every six weeks may have diminishing utility over time.)
No Harm Was Done
Behind all the smoke, there's a simple fact being obscured: Nobody lost anything with this week's announcement. We didn't kill Logos Now yet, we are delivering everything we promised, we are honoring everyone's subscription and delivering what was promised in it AND MORE.
We're just letting you know that around nine months from now we will no longer be offering Logos Now in the existing price and configuration. That's a lot of advance notice, and more than many companies give when they change product offerings.
Wait, isn't this harm?
"But I got new features for $X/month, and now it'll cost more!"
Kinda, but not really. Because we weren't going to be able to keep up the pace of high quality, high value new features on such a regular schedule. We want to do the best thing for the product -- whether that's a tiny feature, a massive big new feature, or a lot of invisible work on speed and stability -- without having to check a 'cool new feature' box every six weeks. So that part of Logos Now was fading out anyway.
"But I passed up purchasing the feature set, and now I'll lose it if I don't double my monthly subscription cost!"
We have tried to address every case of this through credits to help you purchase the feature set, and thus lock in the new features even if you cease subscribing. It was our intention that every Logos Now user who'd chosen to 'upgrade via Logos Now instead of purchase' have the option to re-make that decision, choosing purchase-for-ownership, with the help of a credit.
"You're punishing your best customers!"
No. We've done detailed analysis of what people invested in transactional purchase, as well as what they spent over the life-time of their Logos Now spend, and have emailed credit (or even free Faithlife Connect subscriptions) to ensure we're taking care of people.
"You didn't take care of me!"
If you didn't get an email, or think we somehow let you down, contact us. We'll make it right.
"Is this all about raising prices?"
Yes and no. Mostly no.
We have extensive data (25 years!) on what people spend on average to start with Logos Bible Software, and what they spend each year to grow their library, upgrade, etc. We have also built a business with hundreds of employees serving these thousands of customers and we know what it costs to provide that service.
Faithlife Connect is designed to be a great value for users, and a sustainable business for us. Its value is subscription access to Logos Bible Software tools, content, video, courses, and more. Yes, that product (like all web-based subscription products) will be continually updated -- often quietly and with little fanfare. But 'new features every six weeks' is not its value proposition: the value is the tools and content by subscription, with no large up-front cost.
Logos Bible Software for purchase continues to be what it was: something you can buy and never pay for again, or buy and add books and occasional upgrades to.
You can also choose to do both, and build your own hybrid either way. Subscribers can buy specific books; purchasers can choose to subscribe for the extra content and tools, and the _incidental, not primary_ side effect of some new stuff sooner.
I'm going to say that again, because it's important: "new features sooner" isn't the primary value of Faithlife Connect.
So yes, since everything in Logos Now is now in Faithlife Connect (and more, of course), and since Logos Now is no longer sold separately, you could argue that we raised the price of Logos Now.
But, since Logos Now's old 'primary value' was fading away, it's more like we are retiring Logos Now and offering a new subscription product, which you may not want, but which new users may value and consider a great deal. And we're taking care of you by giving nine months of notice, letting you 'rewind' to a purchase-the-new-features-and-never-lose-them model, or, if you see the value in Faithlife Connect and its extra content/tools, transition to the new subscription product.
“I am not going to renew.”
It may be that you don’t value the other components of Faithlife Connect, and simply want to stay up to date with new versions of Logos Bible Software. In that case, you may not want to subscribe to Connect, and simply stay with the existing upgrade model. We hope to keep adding value to Connect in order to make it a smart move for everyone, even if they have already invested in Logos Bible Software, but that’s an individual decision based on what’s important to you.
My analogy attempt:
You subscribed to a weekly paper news magazine for $100 / year. They announce a new product that is a subscriber-only news website with daily updates, plus a monthly paper magazine, plus a gym membership, for $200 / year. Every present subscriber will get the new monthly magazine and the gym membership now, and the weekly paper news magazine will continue through the end of your paid subscription, but then you'll have to pay the higher price or cancel.
Is this sad? Maybe, if what you loved was a weekly paper news magazine for $100, and if you don't want to read online daily or go to the gym.
Are you being cheated? Not if they deliver your paid subscription through its term. And you're getting more than promised for the remainder of your term.
Is this raising the price of the news? Yes and no, but really it's just offering a different product configuration at a different price point.
Shouldn't they offer the original deal too? Things change, and businesses need to offer products that are financially sustainable and that work in the market.
Technology changes, by definition; those changes aren’t always just about the tech, though. We are all navigating a major change from buy to subscribe in lots of businesses. It’s here now all over the web, and it’s rolling up all the older software business models, and then it’s coming for everything else -- maybe in surprising ways. (Most of us probably won’t buy cars in ten years, but will subscribe to transportation services.)
We’re doing the best to navigate these changes at Faithlife while continuing to serve you well. We understand that every change has the potential to frustrate someone’s plans or expectations, and we’re trying to do it as gently and wisely as we can. Sometimes we make mistakes, or launch things that don’t turn out the way we plan, and sometimes we’ve got to take another shot at it.
I’m sorry when that frustrates you, and promise that we will continue to try and do right by every user, even if we have to address each user’s situation specifically. We will also continue to listen to your feedback; it is the most important thing in helping us make decisions.
Thanks for letting us know what you think, even if you're unhappy.
Comments
- Logos 7 Basic Library and Logos Cloud Basic in Faithlife Connect Basic
- Logos 7 Starter Library and Logos Cloud Starter in Faithlife Connect Starter
- Logos 7 Bronze Library and Logos Cloud Essentials in Faithlife Connect Essentials
- Logos 7 Silver Library and Logos Cloud Standard in Faithlife Connect Standard
- Logos 7 Gold Library and Logos Cloud Plus in Faithlife Connect Plus
- Logos 7 Platinum Library and Logos Cloud Professional in Faithlife Connect Professional
- Logos 7 Diamond Library and Logos Cloud Premium in Faithlife Connect Premium
- Logos 7 Portfolio Library and Logos Cloud Ultimate in Faithlife Connect Ultimate
- The Narrative Lectionary used by a group of ELCA churches
- The Creation Lectionary used by a variety of churches in a variety of countries
- Updating the Compare Pericopes to include more recently added Bibles
- Updating the Saints data to include at a minimum Anglican and Lutheran data
- Addition of the data-types for the Protestant Confessions and Catechisms to allow the viewing of multiple translations in parallel
- More noticeable/lightlighted progress on the Factbook
- Additional entries in Interactives such as Before/After, Bible People Visual Timeslines, Bible Outline Browser, Narrative Character Maps ...
- Add an attribute for text of sermons based on Catechism or Confession (in my library primarily Heidelburg, Augsberg, Armenian, and Westminster)
- Add a predefined label with the standard attributes used by the music feature for users to add the attributed to the hymn texts in their library (preferably as community labels)
- Add the ability for users to add milestone tags to any documents in Text Creation Partnership bundles (preferably as community milestones) to make them more usable (I'm thinking especially of the Psalters). Note we can label the sermons to make them more directly useful.
- Basic Logos Engine - Free (would just give basic function and access to all purchased resources)
- Logos Starter - $50/year (would provide some basic features suitable for casual Bible study)
- Logos Advanced - $100/year (would provide more features, plus one free book a month)
- Logos Pro - $150/year (would provide all features, plus two free books a month)
- Faithlife TV - $50/year
- Proclaim -$50/year
- Mobile Ed 1 - one course per year - $50/year
- Mobile Ed 2 - three courses per year - $120/year
- Offer one year free subscription to the Logos Pro software & feature package described above. This introduces them to the product and its features with no financial risk.
- Offer textbook packages - at least common generic ones - ideally customized to each seminary (I know this would likely be a lot of work and may not be feasible). Students have to buy the textbooks anyway, and this would be a great way to get them to start committing to Logos as their main platform for Bible study.
- Keep up with book editions (I understand that you can't afford to freely upgrade book editions, but please allow for multiple editions of books in your store). I've had to buy one or two textbooks from Amazon because Logos didn't have the latest edition.
- Logos Engine: Needs to be purchased each upgrade by anyone wanting to run Logos natively on a computer.
- Logos Subscription: One subscription tier that includes web access to Logos AND all Logos published content AND public domain resources.
- Logos Base Packages: Include the latest version of the Logos program and PRIMARILY resources that need royalties. No more public domain fluff. Maybe include subscription content, but maybe instead you want to give them an incentive to subscribe.
- No dynamic pricing for subscription plan. All or nothing. No one's got time for that.
- Individually purchased resources integrate with the user's library, whether subscription based or natively based, just like normal, and of course you keep them.
- Don't miss a FREE Book, COUPON, or OFFER! Join the Free Faithlife Books Group
- Faithlife Connect itself is a decent deal for new Logos customers. New Logos customers are able to test the waters with Logos without a major up-front commitment, as well as customers who need to use Logos resources more on a temporary than permanent basis could benefit from Faithlife Connect.
- Bundle deals of Faithlife services that combine Logos with other services such as Mobile Ed and Faithlife TV isn’t necessarily a bad idea in and of itself. For some customers, there are some benefits to it.
- I am grateful that Logos essentially gave us back our Logos Now membership cost in the form of a $100 coupon we can put toward purchasing the features directly, as well as extending our Logos Now membership through early November so we can prepare for the transition (Logos is likely legally obligated to do so since in essence, we signed a “contract” with Logos in which they would fulfill our membership benefits until at least the end of our membership term).
- Faithlife always has, and continues to, have fundamental issues with marketing and communication. Simply put, my Dyson vacuum cleaner, while it has powerful suction, pales in comparison to Faithlfe’s marketing and communication. Every upgrade of Logos I’ve gone through has been a confusing and complicated mess which has only worsened over the years, and instead of improving with my Logos Now membership, it was even more confusing and complicated than before. It’s gotten to the point where it’s been so confusing to upgrade to new major Logos releases, I can’t even enjoy the upgrade experience or really embrace the new features. I spend more time trying to figure out how to upgrade to a major new Logos release over enjoying the upgrading experience or new features. This is only one area where Faithlife has had marketing and communication issues: others over the years include: Logos Mac, Theological Journal Bundles, Encyclopedia Britannica Noet Edition, the Logos Now membership phase out of the monthly subscription and the first annual price increase, just to name a few. I’ve watched time and time again when the Logos forums would catch fire faster than the wildfires in California.
- Faithlife as an organization has “bitten off way more than it can chew”. In addition to its flagship Bible study product (Logos), Faithlife also offers brands such as: Verbum, Noet, Faithlife eBooks (formerly Vyrso), Faithlife Proclaim, Faithlife Groups, Logos Mobile Education, Bible Study Magazine, another Print Journal for Academics, Soundfaith, Lexham Press, Kirkdale Press, Biblia, Bible Screen, Beacon Ads, just to name a few (there’s other websites and services tied to Faithlife). Faithlife used to simply be “Logos Bible Software” and focused on quality Bible software. Now it has ballooned itself into a larger organization, but the more it has taken on, the more it costs to run, and the balloon can pop any moment (Faithlife even discussed creating a Christian online dating site once, which would have been insane to even attempt to deliver, and it was insane to even think about offering it). One issue with Faithlife is that I’ve read in the past where Bob “admires” Amazon. If he likes shopping at Amazon as a customer, that’s one thing. If he “admires” Amazon as a business model to emulate, that’s an issue. The only reason why Amazon can keep their Titanic of a company afloat is Jeff Bezos is a multi-multi-billionaire (even then, I see Amazon headed for a day where it’ll have to streamline and focus on select core businesses, as any business can get too large and fail, no matter how much money one has). Bob and the rest of the Faithlife team aren’t Jeff Bezos. The more markets Faithlife unnecessarily expands into, the quicker it is setting itself up for a trainweck. Faithlife would be better off to cut the fluff, streamline and simplify, and focus on one or a handful of core markets it can really succeed in (similar to the way Apple did with the return of Steve Jobs in 1997). Bible software is a “niche” market. There’s only certain people who are going to invest in Bible software, and an even smaller number of people who will invest regularly and heavily into the software. However, I’ve been customers with software products that serve even smaller niche markets (Nota Bene being one of them. Nota Bene primarily markets its word processors to academics, and even a large group of academics stick with Microsoft Word. Nota Bene will never have Microsoft Word’s marketshare, yet they’ve been successful for years and continue to have a devoted, loyal following). In the Bible software market, Faithlife’s competitors are still successful, even without subscription models and with software with less overall features and resources than Logos (Accordance is a solid product for scholars, WORDsearch endured a rough time but is still in the industry and doing well enough to thrive, and even YouVersion as a nonprofit Bible study app relying solely on donations and doesn’t charge users for features has survived and thrived and even offers features and new Bible versions faster than Logos has). Faithlife’s competitors have been successful with a fraction of the business, revenue, features, and resources offered by Faithlife and Logos, and their success is due to their focusing on succeeding in key areas instead of attempting to do too much at once. I work for a company who went through a similar ordeal and bit off way more than it could chew and had some fundamental communications issues. We got to the point where we had to sell off our well-known consumer brand to another company and had to spin off the “fluff” markets we attempted to get into into a separate company, even to the point where our CEO and top leadership left and transitioned to the new company. Now that we’ve streamlined our offerings and focused on a core market we wanted to tackle that we could truly make a difference in, we’ve been growing in revenue by leaps and bounds and securing lasting, major partnerships, and we’re in a position to seriously win time and time again in our industry. It took some massive fundamental simplification and changes to get there, but it was a move we needed to make.
- The larger Faithlife gets, the more issues with overall customer service begins to surface. I had a major issue with Logos a while back right in the middle of a school semester when I needed Logos to function the most. I called into customer service to resolve my issue. The rep provided me with half-baked and inaccurate information and actually worsened my issue and quickly rushed me off the phone so that he could go message other customers on Faithlife Groups. Only after letting loose on the forums and in an email to Bob did a higher support person assist with resolving my issue, and even then, it was a painful resolution that set me back when I needed Logos the most. Contrast this with one of your major competitors. I had another somewhat-major issue with my Bible software and called into their support teams. The support rep spent over an hour with me on the phone putting in as much effort as he could to resolve my issue. He even called me again after the office closed while I was performing some additional troubleshooting. It turned out the issue wasn’t even with the Bible software company but with my ISP blocking access to their server due to a security update. The rep even emailed me back the following day to ensure my issue was resolve. Bottom line, your competitor treated me as a valued customer, even though I’ve spent a fraction of my funds in their platform versus Logos, and when I called into Logos, not only did I have such a major purchase history, I had an active Logos Now membership, Logos Cloud subscription, payment plan on a Logos 7 library, and another subscription. The customer service rep treated me as if I were no different than someone who’s only downloaded Logos 7 Basic and wanted to rush and get me off the phone as quickly as possible without even taking the time to ensure I was provided accurate information.
- I won’t be discontinuing using Logos itself. I’m not “leaving” Logos in the sense of dumping my copy of Logos entirely. I’ve invested way too much money in the product to let it go completely. I won’t be making any hasty posts to the “Logos Resales” group trying to dump as much Logos content as I can. I also have a high-end $5,000 iMac Pro to run Logos on it, and overall, it runs as speedy as it’ll ever run since I’m running it on workstation-class hardware. I am re-evaluating how I handle my Bible study workflow and transitioning more of my regular tasks to competitors of Logos in order to spend less overall time in Logos regularly.
- I will be allowing my Faithlife Connect membership to expire at the end of its term. I’m not keen on paying 140% more to retain a membership that includes access to all the Logos features I enjoyed in Logos Now, plus books I’ve already invested in hundreds of dollars for, and with overall less value than Logos Now. I have no intentions on transitioning to Verbum Now either, as it’s only a matter of time before Verbum Now is dropped and replaced with another pricier, bloated mess. Additionally, Bob’s reasoning to drop Logos Now at its price point and retain Verbum Now at its price point for the time being makes zero sense. In terms of Faithlife Connect, it’s not even the money. I can easily afford $20/month, and I’ve even given Faithlife $20/month in other services in the past. The way Faithlife has marketed and communicated Faithlife Connect is the issue, and my trust and confidence in Faithlife has diminished to the point where I’m not comfortable investing in Faithlife Connect.
- I will either upgrade to a Logos 7 feature set in a reasonable period of time or wait and upgrade to a Logos 8 feature set. For the moment after examining the new Logos Now features since Logos 7, I’m not sure if I’d want to upgrade to a Logos 8 feature set (I certainly wouldn’t pay hundreds of dollars for the new features as they stand now). I may go for the Logos 7 feature set, wait and get the Logos 8 engine for free, then decide if a Logos 8 Feature Set is worth it. I see no reason to continue investing in Logos base packages when Logos 8 is released. While I’m not sure if I would have continued to invest in Logos base packages now that I need more specific resources, generally I’ve continued to invest in them or at least look into them as an option to get some solid resources at a discounted price. When Logos 8 is announced, I’m not even going to give the base packages a glance. Even in terms of the Logos feature sets, they’re confusing. Even your highly-trained sales reps don’t understand what feature set I’d need to ensure I retain all the features I was accessing in Logos Now, and even I have had issues wading through them.
- I’ve set my other Logos subscriptions not to renew including Bible Study Magazine. While I’ve enjoyed the content of BSM in the past, the Faithlife Connect transition has left me burned on subscriptions with Faithlife. Instead of the marketing email that was released, it would have been better Bob would have drafted up an email that had been released to customers telling us up front that Logos Now was becoming an issue for Faithlife to maintain (especially on its current feature release schedule), that it would be completely retired, offering us the $100 coupon as a means to “give us back the cost of our Logos Now membership” that could be put toward a Logos feature set to “permanently buy the features we had in Logos” (as well as mention it could be used for either Logos 7 or Logos 8, and for those with a Logos feature set, it could be used for any Logos.com purchase), as well as mention that Logos Now would go through early November. In the same email, Bob could have mentioned that Logos Cloud has also been an issue for Faithlife to continue marketing in parallel with Logos Now, and that Logos Cloud would be morphing into a new offering called Faithlife Connect. It would have been made clear in the email that Faithlife Connect as a re-brand of Logos Cloud (not Logos Now) is a subscription version of Logos that costs more for the complete Logos feature set and includes resources customers may already have in a Logos 7 library. Therefore, while Logos Now members would be invited to take a risk-free trial of Faithlife Connect in case it would be a good value for some, since Faithlife Connect costs more than Logos Now for features that include Logos 7 library content, it may not be the best option for many current Logos users, and if it isn’t, customers can transition back to the traditional purchase method, while being encouraged to share Faithlife Connect with new Logos customers. Had that been the case, I’d already be promoting Faithlife Connect to friends of mine who aren’t Logos users yet. However, Faithlife has marketed the Logos Connect transition as a replacement for Logos Now, in which customers are paying more for the same features customers had in Logos Now (140%), plus double-paying for Logos 7 library content for those with Logos 7 libraries, getting overall less value for the money, then marketing the coupon as a way to push Logos 8 sales. The way Faithlife marketed the Logos Connect transition sends a message saying to customers that Faithlife wasn’t financially satisfied with the membership dues of Logos Now, wanted to loop customers into paying 140% more for the same features, then pushing us onto a Logos 8 base package in which customers would be paying for books and features in Logos 8 already owned in Faithlife Connect, plus still keeping Verbnum Now at the same price point which is heavily confusing and doesn’t make sense that Logos users cannot retain Logos Now but Verbum users can. It has shattered my confidence in Faithlife’s handling of subscriptions, and I cannot in good confidence recommend any Faithlife subscriptions to anyone in fear they’d also become burned.
- I have canceled all my current Logos pre-publications and community pricing resources (except for a free book which I don’t even need but will take it since it’s free). After the way Faithlife has handled the Connect transition, my confidence in Faithlife is shattered enough where I don’t feel comfortable even investing too heavily in major book purchases moving forward. I also canceled the Master Journal Bundle 3.1 and will stick with subscribing to the Galaxie database. Looking over the 3.1 bundle, some of the journals I use the most are already somewhat out-of-date before it’s even shipped. The bundle doesn’t include key journals I use regularly such as JETS, and the bundle contains a bunch of journals I’d probably never use. While the $150 dynamic pricing upgrade wouldn’t be too bad, I can pay into Galaxie for three years on that and get fully up-to-date journals and the journals I really need. I’ve never been a fan of accessing journals through a web browser instead of Logos, but I started my searches on the Galaxie database first during my last research project, and surprisingly, I easily found the journals I needed. Even with journals in Logos, I tended to run my own searches using the existing search commands in Logos over the new “journal tagging” that was added and the Journals guide section in Logos. Those additions haven’t been that beneficial in helping me find the articles I really needed, and while Logos has been off looking for ways to increase service revenues, it’s taken Logos too long to deliver regular journal upgrades to customers, and even the current product arriving doesn’t meet the expectations of I and those who use journals on regular basis.
- I’ve removed myself from many of the sales promotion newsletters from Logos, as well as many of the sales-related stuff from the Logos home page. I’d rather not continue to keep a watch on Logos promotions until Faithlife doubles down on improving communications and customer service, and even then, it’d take some major steps for Faithlife to re-earn my trust. I’m pivoting away from major future sales in Logos, as well as I’ll be cross-grading some of my Logos resources into a competitor platform to ensure for future sustainability. Logos will also no longer be by first choice for purchasing resources in general. In the past, I generally purchased all of my resources in Logos first, and I only turned to competitors if Logos didn’t offer the resource I needed, or if I needed to invest in a resource from a competitor to better integrate with my Bible study workflow in the competitor platform. Most of the time however, the bulk of my resource purchases went to Logos. Moving forward, the bulk of my resource purchases will be with competitor platforms, and I’ll only turn to investing in Logos purchases for resources I can’t get anywhere else. I’ll also have a very difficult time highly recommending Logos to students and schools I work with, and I’ll recommend students look at competitor platforms first and only turn to Logos for content they can’t get elsewhere.
since Logos Now's old 'primary value' was fading away,I am sure that there were many reasons why users subscribed to LN. From my perspective, based upon nearly two years of promoting your vision as well as the hundreds of posts today, I think you are completely wrong about the "primary value" of LN. The reason so many were sold on the membership is that it was an alternative to purchasing features. Users could "buy" books and have an inexpensive means to keep "up to date" on features. In your words, "just a few dollars each month."
I am not upset that you killed LN as a program, but you should still have an inexpensive means to subscribe to the features. Why can't it be included in Faithlife Connect Starter (or Starter Plus, if need be)?
EDIT: I take back the "starter plus." It should be a stand alone offering. Just as you are offering "Verbum Now," with datasets, you should offer the datasets to the rest of your customers.
So we're trying to find a better middle ground; our goal is to use subscription products to ensure that people who are heavy users forever are also revenue generators forever. By stretching the revenue out over time -- and having it continue as long as the use does -- we ensure that revenue and expenses are more in sync. (As opposed to getting it all up front and hoping it lasts till the next big thing you can sell ships.) And when this model works, a wonderful side-effect appears: the cost-of-entry to the platform goes down. Starting with the product doesn't have a large up front cost; it's just a few dollars a month. That invites more participation, more trials, and (hopefully) more users. Which lets us spread our costs over more customers, and ultimately offer more value for less overall cost. That's how you can watch a movie every night of the month (on Netflix, for $8.99) for less than the price of buying a single movie on DVD.
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
since Logos Now's old 'primary value' was fading away,I am sure that there were many reasons why users subscribed to LN. From my perspective, based upon nearly two years of promoting your vision as well as the hundreds of posts today, I think you are completely wrong about the "primary value" of LN. The reason so many were sold on the membership is that it was an alternative to purchasing features. Users could "buy" books and have an inexpensive means to keep "up to date" on features. In your words, "just a few dollars each month."
I agree with JT. I can almost say for sure that most people signed up for Logos Now based on staying up to date with features which was the main driving point. NOT new features, NOT free books, NOT Faithlife TV, NOT any other things those were just added bonuses. Now you are saying if you want to keep that you have to take all those EXTRA things and pay more than double when in reality most of Logos Now customers wanted to stay up to date on features!
Keith Pang, PhD Check out my blog @ https://keithkpang.wixsite.com/magnifyingjesus
I am not upset that you killed LN as a program, but you should still have an inexpensive means to subscribe to the features. Why can't it be included in Faithlife Connect Starter (or Starter Plus, if need be)?
Agreed with JT - I'm happy to chip in all the time for the development of the app, its amazingly useful... but my main interest is in learning from books, which I'm also happy to pay for. TV isn't my thing...
גַּם־חֹשֶׁךְ֮ לֹֽא־יַחְשִׁ֪יךְ מִ֫מֶּ֥ךָ וְ֭לַיְלָה כַּיּ֣וֹם יָאִ֑יר כַּ֝חֲשֵׁיכָ֗ה כָּאוֹרָֽה
Agreed with JT
I modified my post after you replied. The primary difference is that I don't see "Faithlife Connect Starter" as a likely option for what we are requesting. Part of the cost includes paying for resources. It would be better as a standalone product. Just as FL is continuing with "Verbum Now," a similar offering should be made available to protestant users.
FWIW - I think "Faithlife Connect" can be a great thing... but for many users it isn't the right thing.
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
FWIW - I think "Faithlife Connect" can be a great thing... but for many users, it isn't the right thing.
I would agree with several points in this thread - many new users are accustomed to the subscription model - I have heard time and time again where I have shared the idea of Logos to people and they are on board... until they hear the price. But for some reason, people are perfectly fine dolling out as much or more in a smaller monthly payment. I'm thinking mostly of my lay leadership team and church members. This subscription method may make Logos "accessible" to a new community of the "average" church membership since the high spending users (like myself and several other forum users) may be reaching a slowed pace of purchasing power. (Although, I know I got plenty more books to buy, wife-willing!)
If Logos is committed to continuing making the software experience more user-friendly for the devotional and congregational life of a Christian, then I believe a larger adoption of the software would continue. The subscription model seems to make sense for that customer.
I personally feel like the LN switch to FLConnect was abrupt - maybe a teaser email before the rollout would have been nice? On the other hand, this rollout gives us 9 months heads up (at least) before any real changes happen. The challenge is for those that anticipated LN to continue on indefinitely and used it as a way to not have to get a purchased feature set.
MBPro'12 / i5 / 8GB // 3.0 Scholars (Purple) / L6 & L7 Platinum, M&E Platinum, Anglican Bronze, P&C Silver / L8 Platinum, Academic Pro
I am not upset that you killed LN as a program, but you should still have an inexpensive means to subscribe to the features.
How inexpensive is inexpensive enough? Is there something magical about the Logos Now price point vs the Faithlife Connect price point?
And what if your definition of inexpensive is below my definition of 'covers costs'? How are we supposed to make that work? (A serious question, not sarcasm.) Yes, I hoped that the math would work -- and it would have, IF more people took the deal, and IF people also kept buying books... So I'll acknowledge that we set the price expectation, but it was based (as it had to be) on guesses about the future, some of which were wrong.
Users could "buy" books and have an inexpensive means to keep "up to date" on features.
Right... except what happens if they started buying dramatically fewer books, and books were baked into the revenue model as the subsidizer of the 'inexpensive up to date features'?
Is there something magical about the Logos Now price point vs the Faithlife Connect price point?
$9.99 (a month) is definitely a magical price point.
For example, I would buy a $9.99 movie or ebook, but likely won't buy a $14.99 movie or ebook. Blame Apple for starting that price war [:)]
$19.99 isn't magical at all. It's psychologically twice the cost, and there's some bias against it, even though it comes with more benefits than LN.
(Still I mentioned I'd pay ~$12/month for FL Connect, if it left out book/feature rentals. So there's some leeway to get some of us to pay more for a subscription than $9.99/mo.)
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
Bob - this sort of feels like a punishment.
I have a hard time seeing the value.
Forcing people like myself who have paid 10k, and have 10k still being paid off are on the short end of the stick when it comes to subscriptions.
If I thought I had a chance to get it, I'd ask for my 10k back, and to give back the licenses to the 10k (roughly, thats not the exact number) still owed. They can have all the licenses back.
THEN 240$ a year might be an acceptable price. THEN now/cloud/connect might be a good thing for me.
I could use 10k to finish my masters degree. To repair my house from IRMA, to pay off medical bills. Truck repairs... The list goes on. I feel like I've invested in a company that no longer values me. That may change. But thats how the continued march towards subscription feels.
You've been more than fair over the years, and I have no doubt that your fairness will continue.
I just feel sort of like reagan must have when he said he had been left behind by his party. I sort of feel left behind by my bible software company, while at the same time feeling the financial pressures of life, of pastoring a small church, of not being paid a living wage, and yet still trying to pay for seminary.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
Forcing people like myself who have paid 10k, and have 10k still being paid off are on the short end of the stick when it comes to subscriptions.
I don't have access to your individual email credit offer at the moment (I'm on the road), but I know that we're paying particular attention to users with significant investments in the purchased resources. If you've spent $10k with us, that's a significant investment we appreciate, and the difference in price between the two subscriptions is small in comparison. This should already have been addressed, or will be soon.
Forcing people like myself who have paid 10k, and have 10k still being paid off are on the short end of the stick when it comes to subscriptions.I don't have access to your individual email credit offer at the moment (I'm on the road), but I know that we're paying particular attention to users with significant investments in the purchased resources. If you've spent $10k with us, that's a significant investment we appreciate, and the difference in price between the two subscriptions is small in comparison. This should already have been addressed, or will be soon.
Bob,
I too am a five-figure customer, and that's just what shows on the order history, it doesn't go back to 1995-96 when I was an undergrad Bible major and purchased my first copy of Logos on multiple CD-ROMs that you had to switch out when prompted I haven't yet received the email, but Chris duMond is working to figure out why. With regards to decreasing book sales for us with large libraries, I can only speak for myself, but there are dozens of books I'd still like to purchase. Some our on my wish list and are a matter of having the money or a good sale. But many are stuck in pre-pub and community pricing where they languish often for years. I've got over $1,000 in pre-pubs just waiting (one was released yesterday). And then there's the new releases that are available on Amazon but not FL. I HATE Kindle books, especially with no page numbers (how is that helpful?). My first choice is ALWAYS the Logos version if available. But when you have to have it for class or you just want to read it, and it's not available in Logos, then my finite book budget goes to Amazon instead of FL. And that's true of the majority of my required readings, they're not available in FL. So while it's true that those with large libraries probably need less books than they once did, that doesn't mean that we don't still want/need to buy books on a regular basis. After all, there are hundreds (thousands?) of Bible-related books released every year. I know there are all sorts of reasons for what makes it into FL format and what doesn't, but I'd certainly spend even more than I did with FL if more of the books I want were available.
Shalom
I'm not going to get one - and thats probably as it should be. I was unable to afford now when the renewal came up and let it drop. I'm not fishing for a credit. It still feels like you are moving away from the model I've invested heavily in (checked my spreadhseet that tracks my purchases its actually about 13k). With so much spent, and 7k yet to go on a student and pastors salary big changes that are unfavorable to my model - hearing that its a model you want to get away from (that I have supported with a significant investment, and significant commitment to continued investment eg payment plan) and are taking steps that direction is an alarming turn of events.Forcing people like myself who have paid 10k, and have 10k still being paid off are on the short end of the stick when it comes to subscriptions.I don't have access to your individual email credit offer at the moment (I'm on the road), but I know that we're paying particular attention to users with significant investments in the purchased resources. If you've spent $10k with us, that's a significant investment we appreciate, and the difference in price between the two subscriptions is small in comparison. This should already have been addressed, or will be soon.
Especially when you say things like no body was really buying cloud, so lets "double down" on it.
I could be wrong, but for me it wasn't the 6 week cycle that I saw as the value when I had subscribed to it, it was being a part of the cutting edge. If that takes 5 or 6 months or more, I was willing to pay (when i could afford it) to be a part of that. Plus the discounts, and free books, and so forth. When I was subscribing I didn't even realize there was a 6 week cycle.We wouldn't do it that way if we were starting from scratch today, but that's where we are based on history and user expectations.
It worked too well, and the tail began to wag the dog. Logos Cloud didn't mature quickly enough (because it needed a stronger web app, which wasn't yet there) and Logos Now's 'new features every six weeks started to feel like its primary benefit.
New customers, who should have only needed to choose between "Buy" or "Subscribe" were regularly being sent into a very confusing, and frustrating, pitch to both buy AND subscribe. Pure subscription wasn't attractive enough (without larger libraries and a pure-web solution), but just buying and owning felt 'left out' because Logos Now offered 'new stuff without the wait.'
Worse, as the tail wagged the dog, Logos Now subscribers (who turned out to vastly outnumber Logos Cloud subscribers) began seeing the product's entire value as the regular release of new features. (Which was not the original intention.)
Maybe I'm alone in not caring about the 6 week element. I doubt it.
I also don't care about a web app. I doubt I'll have a need for faithlife tv. Its a neat idea. But I don't even own a tv. Much less a roku. I probably have an apple tv (1st gen maybe?) in a box somewhere. The courses are a nice touch, and if I could subscribe to two courses a year (without the books, and with the old now benefits I'd be interested) but honestly I'm not going to be able to spend the 20$ monthly (what I have going out is a struggle as is). Not until the church grows and then eventually pays me more money, or seminary becomes free (or finished) - 9 classes left, and at my current rate, I'll graduate in 9 more years.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
Thank you for the explanation Bob.
I'm not sure where the idea came from that we'd get new feature updates every six weeks. But I guess I must have missed that or not considered it important when signing up to Logos Now when it first was launched. My understanding was that Logos Now was launched in order to stabilise your income stream between major versions. The perk for signing up was that we got the new features sooner than we would with the major upgrades. I signed up as that was appealing to me, but also to support the ongoing development of Logos. I never expected new features every six weeks, maybe twice a year or so...
The biggest thing I have against Faithlife Connect is that I have to pay more than double the amount to keep the original benefit of Logos Now. If I was working at the moment I'd probably just shrug it off in appreciation for the work Faithlife does, but I'm just starting a four year MDiv, so I'm not eager to pay a lot more money. I can understand that prices will go up over time, and expected this to happen with Logos Now, but going to Faithlife Connect is a steep jump in pricing if you don't want the other parts of the package.
I appreciate that you've given a big discount to us so that we can use to lock in the new features by buying the Extended Features set, and I may need to do that, and that would save me money over the next few years, even compared to the current Logos Now subscription. However, I also would love to keep supporting the development of Logos and keep getting the latest features. I'd love to see an option in Faithlife Connect where we could customise our package, allowing us to only choose the Logos portion of it.
I wish you all the best in what I'm sure is a challenge job in planning the future for Faithlife.
Thanks for the explanation Bob.
As a retiree and a lay person I was happy with the cost and value of Now. I didn't realize you guys were on a 6 week cycle. And it didn't mean anything to me. I was mostly after the Logos 7 feature set and the free book of the month.
I can't afford the jump to Essentials to get the same features I have now. and the $100 coupon code won't do me much good as it is too little to get me the Logos 7 full feature set. That really disappoints me.
Bob thank you for taking the time to explain.
All that you have said might be well and good, but is there a lesson for you in this about the order of things?
a company that is trusted does not have the panic seen here.
this Excellent explanation should have come a week, a year, before making the change.
Hi,
With the Logos Now Membership and the free book each month, I started to collect the J. C. Ryle Expository on the Gospels, I Got 2/4 books on John, now with the switch over to Faithlife Connect, will all the same books be available to choose from so I can get the rest of the set?
"Your speech must always be with grace, as though seasoned with salt, so that you will know how you should respond to each person." - Colossians 4:6
With the Logos Now Membership and the free book each month, I started to collect the J. C. Ryle Expository on the Gospels, I Got 2/4 books on John, now with the switch over to Faithlife Connect, will all the same books be available to choose from so I can get the rest of the set?
Hi Nathan,
yes, the free classic books under FLC are the same as under LNow.
Have joy in the Lord!
I'd love to see an option in Faithlife Connect where we could customise our package, allowing us to only choose the Logos portion of it.
I get how that would be attractive, and wish we could offer just that. And if we find a way, we will -- we have a long history of trying to deliver more value for less money over time. But until we can get the whole Church purchasing Bible software (we're working on it!) we need to find a sweet spot of the lowest price that covers the costs.
Cable companies want $50/month for 200 channels; they offer lots of configurations and plans yet it seems the total always comes out to $50... why can't I just buy the channels I want for 25 cents each? I just want four, and $1/month is much better than $50....
Except it might cost a lot closer to $50 than $1 to run the cable company and bring cable to my house, answer my tech support calls, send technicians out to re-string wires after storms, etc.
While this is a useful example about bundling in general, it's actually even more helpful in understanding that happens to Logos' revenue: Most early customer purchases are bundles, but as customers build bigger libraries they start buying single specific books over large collections... and over time, more customers enter that category.
(NOTE: While I keep coming back to this revenue explanation, it is a simplified one; our business is large and complex, and the customers vary greatly in behavior. And I'm not blaming anyone for buying fewer books -- you should buy what you need and can afford, and no more. I'm just trying to point out that just as you're trying to be wise with your resources, we have to do the same on the other side of the table; we can't (for long) spend more to deliver the product than we collect for it. And no matter what the reason for changes in customer spending patterns, good, bad, our fault or Amazon's fault or the economy's fault, we have to work with the math.)
But until we can get the whole Church purchasing Bible software (we're working on it!) we need to find a sweet spot of the lowest price that covers the costs.
Let's suppose your dream came true and the entire church used FL software: then what? Where will you get the new customers and new revenue streams that you WILL NEED since, your business model requires that you can never stop growing? When is enough ever enough?
Moral of the story: FL must continually grows its customer base or die.
Unfortunately, that is the software business and tells me that subscription only for Logos features is not far away, no matter what they say.
I have no problem with that except for one thing:
Those who have invested a lot in the platform that got it where it is today should be first on your mind, not last. FL should think long and hard about keeping them as strong advocates for Logos, not bitter subscribers.
BTW, this is why I also own and very much appreciate software from one of your competitors. It costs little more than one year of FLC Essentials and, with things like original language/lemma/ queries etc, provides far greater power and functionality than Logos. They know their lane and stick to it. Thus, it is the one piece of BIble software I feel most confident will be around for a long time and maintain ecxcellent functionality.
Where will you get the new customers and new revenue streams that you WILL NEED since, your business model requires that you can never stop growing? When is enough ever enough?
Moral of the story: FL must continually grows its customer base or die.
Unfortunately, that is the software business and tells me that subscription only for Logos features is not far away, no matter what they say.
Bingo. Since there is no customer "demand" for such a service, inevitably it has to be forced. The present action of folding LN into Faithlife Connect is the next step. Notice that Bob is no longer saying that a subscription only model won't happen, he is now saying he doesn't "plan" for it to happen.
I wish Bob well, but, I do not see how a Bible software subscription model can be very successful. The reality is that our base is limited, our finances are limited, and there are many Bible software options available, including free. Logos' wishing will not change that reality.
It will be interesting to see how this plays out. But this move introduces uncertainty about Logos' long-term intentions and sustainability. If this uncertainty becomes general, sales will noticeably decrease. We will see what happens.
Notice that Bob is no longer saying that a subscription only model won't happen, he is now saying he doesn't "plan" for it to happen.
I'm sorry if I created confusion; I didn't mean to change any phrasing or plan... I do think it's a bad idea to say 'never' -- we hope to be here a long time and we have no idea what the future holds 20+ years out -- but we are not planning / hoping / designing for a subscription only world. In many ways the transactional world is much better for us; our business works better with larger amounts up front. But it's getting harder and harder to sign up new customers for that larger initial purchase, and even the technology platforms are moving to designs that discourage downloaded desktop software, which creates ongoing support / update costs even if users would have been happy to just 'stay with what worked'.
But we want to offer both, and nothing I said here was meant to signal any change in that plan.
Thats good, I sorta felt like a guy on a sinking boat that was watching the captain leap into the sea.Notice that Bob is no longer saying that a subscription only model won't happen, he is now saying he doesn't "plan" for it to happen.But we want to offer both, and nothing I said here was meant to signal any change in that plan.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
Please answer a "but how does this affect ME" kind of question. I signed up for Now rather than upgrade to Logos 7. My thinking was that at $89 per year Now was a better deal than upgrading every two years. Had I known that Now would last less than two years I would have upgraded. So now, when L8 appears, I will not be upgrading from L7 but from L6. Am I better off upgrading now to the L7 "Starter feature set" (I do not need any more books) for my dynamic price of $50.20 and then to L8 at that time, or should I wait until L8 appears and upgrade then from L6? My email informs me I will get a $200 credit/coupon code.
Am I better off upgrading now to the L7 "Starter feature set" (I do not need any more books) for my dynamic price of $50.20 and then to L8 at that time, or should I wait until L8 appears and upgrade then from L6?
Phil recommended that it would be better to wait for L8.
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
Am I better off upgrading now to the L7 "Starter feature set" (I do not need any more books) for my dynamic price of $50.20 and then to L8 at that time, or should I wait until L8 appears and upgrade then from L6?Phil recommended that it would be better to wait for L8.
I've been lead to believe, that if one skips for example, from Logos 6 to Logos 8 (not buying Logos 7) then Logos 8 is going to cost much more. The recommendation to wait till L8 is ok but there is no specific reason given to do so other than a recommendation.
From what I understand, barreling out of LN and having had L6, it would be about the same cost-wise for me to presently buy Logos 7 and when Logos 8 comes down the tubes, yes, I'm going to pay but not as much as if I had remained with L6.
Has something changed or am I close to being right. I hope I'm near being right because I jumped the gun yesterday and bought L7. Please make my day and tell me I've made a horrific mistake! :-/
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
Let's suppose your dream came true and the entire church used FL software: then what? Where will you get the new customers and new revenue streams that you WILL NEED since, your business model requires that you can never stop growing? When is enough ever enough?
This is a classic problem for all businesses; the answer is generally 'adjacent markets' -- hence Faithlife TV, Faithlife Proclaim, etc. (Sometimes it is demographics -- the country is growing too, and the population continues to increase....)
It would be nice to say "my business is done, and we can freeze at this size" -- and some very tiny businesses do that. (Restaurants, a flower shop, etc.) But that's harder when you're bigger or where you employ in categories where people's skills (and payroll expectations) grow more quickly than your pricing does. When you hire, say, software developers right out of college, you need more than 1% revenue growth just to meet their increasing pay expectations as they gain experience. A restaurant can just 'always hire the same person' at the same wage by having 100% annual staff turnover -- skills requirements are low, recruiting is cheap, and training is short. It's harder to do in our business.
And then add into all that our maturing (in years with us, not age!) customer base, which I described earlier, which spends less over time while keeping most support costs constant...
You're right -- we have to keep growing.
Cable companies want $50/month for 200 channels; they offer lots of configurations and plans yet it seems the total always comes out to $50... why can't I just buy the channels I want for 25 cents each? I just want four, and $1/month is much better than $50...
Bad analogy...cord cutting is decimating the traditional cable/satellite subscription model because they refused exactly this, or to say it differently they refused to listen to what their customers wanted, and tried to force a lot of extra bloat on them at higher prices. There are quite a few "micro" packages of much smaller focused content that people are buying at much faster growth rates that the loss of customers cable companies are experiencing. THIS is the analogy to adding more unwanted bloat to a Logos subscription at double the cost.
You can also choose to do both, and build your own hybrid either way. Subscribers can buy specific books; purchasers can choose to subscribe for the extra content and tools, and the _incidental, not primary_ side effect of some new stuff sooner.
I like how you coined that. I will always buy base packages and full feature sets at releases, but I will take this year you gave me and try it out. If I like it I will subscribe at the end and make my hybrid system. I subscribe to a lot of stuff already so once I see the value I am in. Thanks for the year to try it out.
Matt
Access to new features early, as they were released, was just a little part of what we imagined Logos Now would be, which we hoped would make it more attractive to transaction users, helping them transition to a subscription world.
This really makes me sad. My only motivation for joining Logos Now was to keep up on new features and support in that way, the development of the program. I thought of it also as a way to "pay in advance" to help with the sticker shock of each upgrade. I am sad because it appear to reveal the true motivation, something we all have had reason to suspect and that is that one day, our investment in Logos downloadable is going to be outdated software just like Adobe Photoshop downloadable (Which no longer exists) is outdated, or Microsoft Office Suite is outdated. Your sentence here is the reason for us who have invested heavily to worry regardless of what we hear. It is the reason for slowing down our purchases. We have been losing confidence over the years with the decision making process.
We need a true 'no purchase necessary, pure subscription' product.
I thought that was Logos Cloud. Why not kill Logos Now and that solves the problem you seem to be addressing. Logos Cloud is subscription only. Logos Bible Software is downloadable. The downloaded product can have a feature to pay for accessing their content only online. Why is this so difficult?
Why could you not first email long term, heavily invested customers these ideas of yours to get feedback before implementing what amounts to a shock? Do you not think that many of us would be willing to engage in an honest exchange to help in the thinking process? You have valid points. But the roll out of these things could be much better. Would it be correct to assume that people on the beta channel were in the know about this as they were in the change from L3 to L4?
Would it be correct to assume that people on the beta channel were in the know about this as they were in the change from L3 to L4?
No, that isn't correct. No mention of this was to be found until today.
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
I understand the need for Logos to have a subscriber service as it produces a steady stream of income. However, I am one who prefers to own the product instead of "renting" it so I didn't try Logos Now and everything I have is what I have bought.
I do have a substantial library (13000+), so I don't to purchase as many resources as I did several years ago and I'm sure I'm not the only one who doesn't need to buy new resources every month. This just reinforces the need for a subscription based model, but again, it's not what I prefer. I do make regular purchases, but just not as much or as often.
From what Bob said, it sounds like the purchasing option will be around for a while and I hope it stays that way.
I know there are a number of people not happy with the change from Logos Now to Faithlife Connect. I can't offer my opinion on which is better, but I do hope that who subscribe to Faithlife Connect find it a worthwhile purchase. I'm very happy with my Logos library and hope that the company stays around for a long time.
I agree Mark!Access to new features early, as they were released, was just a little part of what we imagined Logos Now would be, which we hoped would make it more attractive to transaction users, helping them transition to a subscription world.This really makes me sad. My only motivation for joining Logos Now was the keep up on new features and support in that way, the development of the program. I thought of it also as a way to "pay in advance" to help with the sticker shock of each upgrade. I am sad because it appear to reveal the true motivation, something we all have reason to suspect and that is that one day, our investment in Logos downloadable is going to be outdated software just like Adobe Photoshop downloadable (Which no longer exists) is outdated, or Microsoft Office Suite is outdated. Your sentence here is the reason for us who have invested heavily to worry regardless of what we hear. It is the reason for slowing down our purchases. We have been losing confidence over the years with the decision making process.
We need a true 'no purchase necessary, pure subscription' product.
Bob: So you are getting rid of a program people did like, and do use, to prop up something that YOU like, but isn't selling as well? seems risky.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
Bob: So you are getting rid of a program people did like, and do use, to prop up something that YOU like, but isn't selling as well? seems risky.
We're getting rid of a program that only a tiny fraction of our customers embraced, which didn't generate enough revenue to be practical even though the tiny fraction loved it, in order to simplify a very confusing product offering into a clearer plan with two options, both of which should be financially sustainable.
We're also extending credits to the people who did participate to address the cost of transition. And I am apologizing to you, right here, that we couldn't make it live up to our hopes in that configuration.
Bob, I am just amazed that you'd ask me to shell out $200 a month for access to less than 3,000 resources (Connect Ultimate).
The first thing I wanted to know is what commentaries were included. For $2,400 a year, or $24,000 in ten years I get access to a bunch of old public domain texts, a few ECC commentaries, a handful of secondary commentaries, and as far as I can see, just one top tier commentary (Pillar). (Some would add Hermeneia as top tier, but many would disagree.) No NIC. No NIGTC. No Baker Exegetical. No ICC. No Socio-Rhetorical. No Word. Not even NAC.
Under dictionaries there is Anchor Yale, but not a single one of the many IVP dictionaries.
Under Hebrew lexicons there is no HALOT.
The journal offerings are extraordinarily weak. Not sure who your target is with that random collection.
What does a serious student/pastor/seminarian do? He/she is forced to buy commentaries, HALOT, many other dictionaries and journals, and still pay you for some sort of subscription? I don't think so.
Exactly who is your target? It looks to me like this model will fail as Logos Cloud did, and likely for the same reason - lousy content. Lay people will give you $10 or $20 a month. But for that you offer nothing and next to nothing. I would never recommend either to a lay person in my church. I'd rather they bought Tyndale at full price so at least they'd have a decent commentary at the end of a year.
If you offered access to everything FL produced for $200 a month that would still be a whole lot of money for what one actually used. I've used Logos for well over 20 years. Imagine: I'd be out $48,000, own nothing, and have used mostly second-rate commentaries that whole time. WOW.
When you can get permission to rent your whole catalog, and figure out how to distribute the earnings to the publishers, and price your offerings in a reasonable way, then you may have a lot of customers.
Right now you are fixin' to get very few.
I wish you and FL well. I have a lot invested with you. I don't think you have a model that is going to work no matter how desperately you need it to, but of course, we'll just have to wait and see.
Pastor, North Park Baptist Church
Bridgeport, CT USA
Some how I missed this way back on page 3.And I am apologizing to you, right here, that we couldn't make it live up to our hopes in that configuration.
Thank you for that.
It still doesn't sit well. I don't know what the future holds RE 7 or 8. I know I cannot buy more now. I probably won't be buying 8 later.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
It is the reason for slowing down our purchases. We have been losing confidence over the years with the decision making process.
Absolute truth.
That which we have asked for largely goes unanswered. That which we don't ask for, gets pushed onto us.
I have been here for nearly two decades, and if I could recoup my investment, I would sell.
We may not be your shareholders, but in a very real sense there has been much of the public trust between us broken. It is time for Bob to see this, realize it, and revitalize this base that helped build his company.
You've said it better than I had. My last major purchase was under L6. All the changes feel almost predatory, or at least descriminatory towards those who have spent money like water with the company. I said in another (maybe this thread... Lost track) if I could get the money spent back, and forfeit all the licenses I've bought I would. I would happily sign up for now/cloud or whatever they want to call it. Short of that, I'd have to pay twice for resources - once to own, once to rent. A thing I have absolutely no interest in.It is the reason for slowing down our purchases. We have been losing confidence over the years with the decision making process.Absolute truth.
That which we have asked for largely goes unanswered. That which we don't ask for, gets pushed onto us.
I have been here for nearly two decades, and if I could recoup my investment, I would sell.
We may not be your shareholders, but in a very real sense there has been much of the public trust between us broken. It is time for Bob to see this, realize it, and revitalize this base that helped build his company.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
That which we have asked for largely goes unanswered. That which we don't ask for, gets pushed onto us.
You're fair to suggest that you all (collectively) are our most important constituency. I agree.
But the general accusation that we don't give what's requested, and force what isn't requested, is a little too general. We provide a lot of what's requested -- much of what we offer is at user request. We do offer some things not requested -- some of our best (and most popular) products and features are things we came up with that you didn't know you wanted, but liked.
But if what you're asking for is "more for less", there are going to be some limits in every business, no matter how customer-friendly. We keep trying -- and over the long arc of our business, I think the evidence is there that we have delivered that -- but it has to make sense for survival.
But if what you're asking for is "more for less", there are going to be some limits in every business, no matter how customer-friendly. We keep trying -- and over the long arc of our business, I think the evidence is there that we have delivered that -- but it has to make sense for survival.
Instead of looking at the business as "How can we be profitable with the products, services etc. that we want customers to buy", after all this time why not think about "How can we be profitable selling what customers want"? People here want features - ways to do more with what they already have - they need help in using the product better, it is very sophisticated and most would say they use a small percentage of the features yet there is this hope that one day they will use more. They want quality - performance - usability features that get long ignored. And yes they still want books - quality books that are cornerstones of their faith if they can be published in a reasonable timeframe.
It seems there is a lot of potential there that people would pay for, and jettison those ventures that nobody wants...
Thanks for letting us know what you think, even if you're unhappy.
Thank you for the thorough explanation. (I was one of the people who owned the feature set, but still subscribed for early release access, although when fewer features were getting rolled out, I was considering letting LN lapse.)
If I was a brand new customer, I'd definitely subscribe to FL Connect, as it would be much cheaper to rent books and features, than to spend the amount I have over the past few years!
Unfortunately, I've made a large investment now, and I can't see how subscribing is anything but being charged to rent books and features which I already own.
The only apparent option remaining is to buy new features, but miss out on any early release access for two years. In that regard, I feel that I am missing out, since there is no middle ground but to pay 2.4x each year to get what I previously had.
I'll say it again. I didn't mind paying $99/yr for early release access -- LN was an amazing value -- but I don't think that early release access is worth $240/yr.
I'll likely take my $X00 and buy the L8 feature set. It makes no sense to rent features at $240/yr when I can own them outright. (I understand there are other benefits to Connect, but features are what drive/advance the software.)
I'm not unhappy. It is what it is, and FL is making a reasonable and fair adjustment in how they market and develop software. Thank you very, very much for the benefits (voucher, extension, and so forth).
If FL Connect changes by the time my subscription lapses -- i.e., a tier without book/feature rentals to avoid being charged for what we own, for ~$120/yr -- I'd probably subscribe.
Thanks again for writing, and for listening. May God bless you and your company, Bob.
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
If I was a brand new customer, I'd definitely subscribe to FL Connect
I would not...because believe it or not, I still go to places where there is no internet access. And I am in need of a program like Logos offline. Even at home there are times when I do not have internet access.
Unfortunately, I've made a large investment now, and I can't see how subscribing is anything but being charged to rent books and features which I already own.
And if I could have seen this many years ago, I would not have invested so heavily. Logos has been and continues to be a great program. But not worth the investment it has become. I agree with those who see it more as a program being filled with bloatware.
I would not...because believe it or not, I still go to places where there is no internet access. And I am in need of a program like Logos offline. Even at home there are times when I do not have internet access.
Just a quick clarification that whether you buy a base package or subscribe to Connect (or Cloud or Now before that), you have the same offline and online options. Base package owners can use the desktop app, the mobile app, and the web app. The same is true for Connect (and Cloud and Now). The fundamental difference is owning a perpetual license vs. subscribing to a temporary license, not offline vs. online.
Just a quick clarification that whether you buy a base package or subscribe to Connect (or Cloud or Now before that), you have the same offline and online options. Base package owners can use the desktop app, the mobile app, and the web app. The same is true for Connect (and Cloud and Now). The fundamental difference is owning a perpetual license vs. subscribing to a temporary license, not offline vs. online.
I do not see this and I guess you can help me to see it. But I think you misunderstand. (Maybe I misunderstand). IF I owned nothing and I subscribed to Connect but I owned NO resources...it was all subscription based...then there is nothing to download. It is all done via a web app. If this is not true, then FL has failed miserably to make it clear.
I still go to places where there is no internet access.
Which is why the downloadable, transactional model is still better for some users, and why we're still offering it.
I agree with those who see it more as a program being filled with bloatware.
I don't want to become bloatware. Unfortunately that's a tendency as things mature, for two reasons:
1) As a general tool matures, it goes into more niches both to respond to users and to chase new market segments with targeted features. The first version of Excel did math on numbers. Later versions had features specifically for tax professionals, construction estimators, and soccer moms. That's bloat to me, but value to those specific people.
2) Somewhere along the way most users have their basic needs met, but still want fresh updates, free tech support, etc. Sometimes they even stop upgrading, ending the revenue stream without ending the support expense stream. Companies add bloat to increase (for some people) the value perception, to capture revenue from alternate sources (like PC manufacturers being paid to incorporate third-party software), etc.
Subscription models help cure this second bloat problem by keeping revenue and costs more in sync (though introducing other costs, like constant customer acquisition). But the transition can be difficult and expensive...
This is my problem, not yours, but I'll share it anyway: the only thing scarier than the phrase "I've never heard of Logos" (which I used to hear a lot years ago) is running into lots of people who say "I've had Logos for years, I love it, it's so powerful, I feel bad that I only use 5% of its incredible power... no, I haven't upgraded it, even though I use it every week, because it already does everything I need and more, and I couldn't possibly read more books."
I suppose we could declare victory and dissolve the company... but A) we've got mouths to feed and even those users might someday decide they need an update, or support, and wish we had more than a skeleton crew around to serve them.
Again, my problem, and a relatively high-class problem as problems go, but a problem none the less... which is what keeps leading us to narrower feature areas (to capture niches in the market that haven't bought yet) as well as to new product categories (like Proclaim and more) where we can continue to deliver value and get paid for it.
I know, most users would like to buy once, and then just have us continue to polish the gem, making it faster and prettier and easier to use... that's how I feel about most products I buy!
But.... math. :-)
Bob, you keep saying that new features wasn't the primary focus. That just didn't sound true to me. So I searched me email archives for "Logos Now" and guess what I discovered. Early on nearly every email from Logos was about the new version features. Then it became Scott half new features and have new book discounts or free books. Lately it was more about books.
The reason we thought it was about new features is you made it about new features at the outset.
Second, you say that you're ok with us not subscribing and just buying at the upgrade. Great. Can you then offer a .5 feature upgrade that I can but before the big new .0 upgrade? So let's say I get 8.0 got $400 in Nov. Then in May you sell a feature upgrade for $79. When 9.0 comes out I'll probably get it. Then if 9.5 comes for that $79 price awesome. I subscribe to Now ONLY for the feature upgrades but won't subscribe for $240. So let me give you a smaller amount more often for a software upgrade. I get what I want. You get more $$ from me that you would not hey with this new model. And everyone's happy. Unless you really are just doing this to push everyone over to subscriptions then in my scenario I'm there only one happy.
Dr. Kevin Purcell, Director of Missions
Brushy Mountain Baptist Association
If I was a brand new customer, I'd definitely subscribe to FL Connect
I hope, and expect, that many people will agree with you.
LN was an amazing value
In a way, part of the problem... maybe too amazing...
but I don't think that early release access is worth $240/yr.
Probably not; that's why there's a lot more in there then that, but if those things aren't valuable to you, then it's not right for you. Which is okay, because...
I'll likely take my $X00 and buy the L8 feature set.
...that works too.
Thanks again for writing, and for listening. May God bless you and your company, Bob.
Thank you.
but I don't think that early release access is worth $240/yr.Probably not; that's why there's a lot more in there then that, but if those things aren't valuable to you, then it's not right for you. Which is okay,
It's not that those things aren't valuable. I think you bundled a lot of value into Faithlife Connect (and like LN, it pays for itself due to the benefits). Back issues of Bible Study Magazine is a big deal that I just found out about earlier today.
The difficult thing to swallow is paying rental costs for books and features which I own. Is there any solution for that sticking point?
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
It's not that they're not valuable. I think you bundled a lot of value into Faithlife Connect (and like LN, it pays for itself due to the benefits).
Just because there's more stuff in it doesn't mean it's valuable for everyone. I, personally, am not the least bit interested in mobile ed unless they start offering post-grad or post-doc level courses, and I've not even glanced at FaithLifeTV (or whatever it's called) even once. The problem is FaithLife is continuously pushing us to go bigger and more expensive in order to just keep up. At some point, people will say, "Enough!", and for many people, this is that point.
Worse, as the tail wagged the dog, Logos Now subscribers (who turned out to vastly outnumber Logos Cloud subscribers) began seeing the product's entire value as the regular release of new features. (Which was not the original intention.)
WOW! Entire value?
I don’t have access to your market data but at least this one user has to strongly disagree.
Paying for some early release features (it was called Logos Now) was a bonus, but subscribing to the feature sets, getting discounts, a monthly voucher and also helping create a subscription base which would help fuel the next version was a win/win. Logos Now was a bit of a membership club and we were loyal.
As long standing user of Logos I’ll figure out how to make this new reality work, but I think you have seriously misread the buy in of some users and have failed to identify what we liked about Logos Now, it’s price point and why Faithlife Connect Starter appears to be a big downgrade.
Often your posts win me over, but it sounds like us users (the tail) abused the program by wagging the dog and were just looking for the next features.
Logos Now was a bit of a membership club and we were loyal.
I appreciate that. I just didn't get enough of the users as members, and the hybrid model was confusing new customers.
it sounds like us users (the tail) abused the program by wagging the dog and were just looking for the next features.
Sorry if I wasn't clear... I wasn't calling you the tail, I was calling 'new features sooner' the tail wagging the Logos Now dog.
At the start we had lots of feature ideas and data sets to add, but over time we realized we needed to pour resources into bigger things like re-writes of core technology, stability and speed and other platform improvements, porting to the web, etc. While some users may have appreciated those things as part of the Logos Now deliverables, many users were counting features / deciding on 'what's new' and deciding it wasn't enough to justify it... and those new emphases would hurt that new subscriber recruiting even more...
"But I passed up purchasing the feature set, and now I'll lose it if I don't double my monthly subscription cost!"
We have tried to address every case of this through credits to help you purchase the feature set, and thus lock in the new features even if you cease subscribing. It was our intention that every Logos Now user who'd chosen to 'upgrade via Logos Now instead of purchase' have the option to re-make that decision, choosing purchase-for-ownership, with the help of a credit.
This is why I’m not upset about the new announcement. You are crediting back what I’ve paid to try LN over the last two years and I can use the credit to now “own” the full feature set. Not many other companies out there would do that.
I hope Faithlife is successful in your new strategy; however, I strongly suspect that with the announced changes, your subscription revenue is going to decline rather than increase like you are hoping. If that is the case, there will be of course new changes later down the road.
Not many other companies out there would do that.
Thank you for this acknowledgement.
your subscription revenue is going to decline
As I mentioned in another reply, Logos Now generated around 1.8% of revenue.... so while that's real money, and I'd hate to see it go, if it all went, and as a result we ended up with a new subscription product for new customers that was understandable and financially viable, even if starting from zero subscribers, and existing users went back to purchasing upgrades / books as they wished, it would probably work out better.
[quote]
This is why I’m not upset about the new announcement. You are crediting back what I’ve paid to try LN over the last two years and I can use the credit to now “own” the full feature set. Not many other companies out there would do that.
I hope Faithlife is successful in your new strategy; however, I strongly suspect that with the announced changes, your subscription revenue is going to decline rather than increase like you are hoping. If that is the case, there will be of course new changes later down the road.
The cost to purchase the full feature set empowering logos 7 is $429.21. NOT $200 or $100. You are getting less than half of the cost to get the stuff you are losing.
Combine this with the FACT that the commission sales men (and one woman I never spoke with) offered Logos Now as the key to having the cool tools like lemma in passage (which have helped me get much closer to God) at the least cost;....therefore, I was able to put more of my wad toward buying the library I wanted. I did and rented the feature set by getting Logos Now.
NOW, I get the privilege of renting not only the books I already own (literally, almost every one at each level) but renting the feature set for 2.4 times the cost of the feature set Logos Now was providing me. I work in a rainforest and only have internet now and then. Faithlife TV and the cloud are useless to me.....
In the old days I was a professor at USC business school. We called this a "Cram Down"... .a situation where the "cramee" has no choice but to write off his investment or take the medicine. With the investments all of us have made we can't leave .... and who would want to, no other company has anything like these great tools.
BUT... Bob, one of the key principals we had at our secular business school was to treat your customers like gold. I feel like a brick to you. But, I can promise that "All things work together for good to those that love God, the called according to His purpose." I also know that Christians reap what they sow.
In my mind, this is a horrible way to treat the folks who bought your stuff and deferred vacations and other stuff to have tools to serve God....and felt proud and privileged to give you their hard earned money.
If I were a young man and didn't own a library full of books I would jump at the ability to rent what I needed and the Faithlife Connect would be just fine.
I do wonder how you would feel Bob if you were one of your customers who strained every financial muscle in their body to buy your books and software....then got this proposal which is really and truly little more than a traditional Cram Down.
I do remain your faithful "Cramdownee" and will stick with Logos because there is nothing even close to as good. I know I will never trust any of your staff as their good intentions were not same intentions as the management. I will continue to buy your books, pay for Faithlife Connect Essentials...but I won't forget that i got bitten.... and if bitten again it is my fault.
Also, I would gladly pay more if you just said you needed money and were raising your prices.... you didn't do that.... Instead you offer me things i don't want and can't use and then say take it or walk away. This is not going over well with your key invested customers.
Unfortunately, this doesn't bode well for those of us who thought our purchased libraries would have strong residual value....
Rob
Rob, you say "The cost to purchase the full feature set empowering logos 7 is $429.21." I take it that you're referring to a present customer and not a new one, correct? Can you clarify that a bit? Is it a Logos 4, 5 or 6 user who you have in mind or something else.
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
Rob, you say "The cost to purchase the full feature set empowering logos 7 is $429.21." I take it that you're referring to a present customer and not a new one, correct? Can you clarify that a bit? Is it a Logos 4, 5 or 6 user who you have in mind or something else.
Mr. Bootjack,
I own a lot of books (still paying for them) and rent the feature set through Logos Now. I got a quote to buy the feature set for Logos 7 and its related data sets for the price of $429.21. I took a screenshot but can't upload it.
Bottom line, full feature set of Logos 7 (not including Lemma in Passage search or any of the interlinear bibles included with Logos Now....Just Logos 7 feature set....
Hope this helps.
Rob
Thank you for taking the time to explain the situation. I purchased Logos Now a few months ago to have access to the feature set, not all the other components. I was not aware that "new features" were due every few weeks. While I appreciated the other components like a free "classic" each month, which helped me learn the value of Logos for more than just Bible study. I considered everything else a perk to the primary value of having the feature set. As a student who just started his MDiv, this new model hurts.
I do not have a problem with the new subscription model for new customers. As I read through the tiers, I realized that there were a few people I know on the fence about Logos and this price point may help convince them. I think Faithlife has provided a lot of value in these tiers (Faithlife TV being the exception.) However, I am holding off on recommending this to friends and family, because I want to see how this transition is handled.
My biggest concern is the lack of dynamic pricing for the hybrid approach. I see two main pieces to Faithlife Connect (FC): subscribing to content and subscribing to software. I have no problem subscribing to software, I have done this elsewhere as others have mentioned; Microsoft Office being the prime example. After all, for probably most Logos Now subscribers, we subscribed for software not content. What matters for software is the quality of the product, not the quantity of new features it contains. As to content, if I already purchased content that is now offered in a tier, but am going to be charged the same as if I had not purchased that content, I feel cheated.
This raise a couple scenarios:
1) I own a library now. If I subscribe to FC with content that overlaps what I bought, will the price be adjusted?
2) I own nothing. I subscribe to FC. I purchase a library. Will the library be dynamically priced? I would imagine no, because the content through FC is a temporary license. Will my FC subscription be adjusted due to the licenses which have switched to permanent?
Looking back at my purchasing decision a few months ago, I have a couple observations. When I was trying to determine what to buy, Logos Cloud was never on my radar. I did not know it existed, I wish I did. When I contacted Faithlife with questions about Logos Now, I was not suggested Cloud as an alternative library. Instead I was given the hybrid option, which is fine. I subscribed for software and bought the content. Even finding Logos Now was a bit of an accident, however. It was not featured in a prominent way as an alternative to purchasing the feature sets. For me, the problem with Logos Now and Logos Cloud was the lack of marketing. Even a side banner on the product page of base packages for other purchase options would have helped me navigate my options.
1) I own a library now. If I subscribe to FC with content that overlaps what I bought, will the price be adjusted?
Not presently. There is no dynamic pricing for Faithlife Connect.
2) I own nothing. I subscribe to FC. I purchase a library. Will the library be dynamically priced?
No. You would be buying a permanent license (which means you own but are also still paying to rent).
I would imagine no, because the content through FC is a temporary license.
Correct. Otherwise someone could subscribe, get dynamic pricing on a library based on what they rented, then cancel the subscription, and FL would be out money for what you no longer rent but own yet didn't pay for.
Will my FC subscription be adjusted due to the licenses which have switched to permanent?
No, since there is no dynamic pricing for FC.
If FL could address this, lowering our cost, more of us might subscribe.
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
No, since there is no dynamic pricing for FC.
If FL could address this, lowering our cost, more of us might subscribe.
Thanks. Hopefully, this "penalty" of paying every month for books that are already owned will be addressed soon. Without this adjustment, I can't in good conscience recommend FC to anyone.
My biggest concern is the lack of dynamic pricing for the hybrid approach.
This is a problem for us too. It's a hard one to solve, because the business models are so different, and there can be significant implications in how revenue is calculated, royalties shared, etc.
Purchases are easy: Collect one price, sale is done, pay royalties. Subscriptions involve (for now) multiple business models; some are gambles (we buy a copy and hope you subscribe long enough to cover the royalty cost before canceling) and some are different models (we pay a percentage on the revenue collected, so less than we'd pay for a sold copy when the subscription is short, but much more when it is long).
It's just too complicated for dynamic pricing. Even if you could program the formulas into a computer, the explanation to each user would be unique, complicated, and would change based on the month. And there are lots of philosophical questions with financial implications.
Which is why Spotify doesn't give me credit for all the CDs I bought years ago... and Netflix doesn't credit me the movie tickets I bought when the films were new releases... and my Microsoft Office 365 subscription isn't cheaper because I've bought 5 copies of the whole Office suite with or for various computers over the years...
And yet, if I did buy a one-time video-on-demand digital purchase of a single movie via Amazon's video service, it gets added into my video library even if it isn't part of Prime Video. (Though, if it is or becomes part of Prime Video, I don't get any credit or discount.)
We're watching what other companies do, and experimenting, and trying to find the optimal solution. Ultimately it seems like all these transitions work when the subscription becomes 'worth it' no matter what I paid in the past... which is why I caved and subscribed to Spotify, despite having spent so much on (some of) that music already on CD... and cassettes before that...
Which is why Spotify doesn't give me credit for all the CDs I bought years ago... and Netflix doesn't credit me the movie tickets I bought when the films were new releases... and my Microsoft Office 365 subscription isn't cheaper because I've bought 5 copies of the whole Office suite with or for various computers over the years...
I'm sorry, but those are completely different scenarios. It is unfortunate that you view them the same way.
Spotify doesn't sell CDs. Netflix doesn't sell movie tickets. Office 365 is a comparison between software to software, not content to content. FL is an a position where they are selling content and renting the same content. The closest comparison is Amazon Video.
And yet, if I did buy a one-time video-on-demand digital purchase of a single movie via Amazon's video service, it gets added into my video library even if it isn't part of Prime Video. (Though, if it is or becomes part of Prime Video, I don't get any credit or discount.)
This argument makes sense, save two details. Prime Video rotates an increasing library of content and my purchases do not equate to a significant portion of the Prime Video library. I would risk saying that many of us do not see the size of FC library (starter or essentials) as worth it, because we own a significant portion of the content already.
I did a brief comparison of FC Starter and Logos Starter and it looks to be nearly the same content. The fact that the number of books in the FC and Standard libraries match means that they probably are the same content. If they are indeed the same content, then any FC subscriber should never purchase a Standard library! Your subscription model discourages big purchases. Suddenly, the comparison between Prime Video and FC becomes a contrast. At this point, what makes dynamic pricing so difficult, since it appears to be no different than upgrading between libraries?
I truly appreciate the candor that has been expressed on this forum. It gives me a lot of faith in FL as a company. If I am wrong and the libraries are different, would it be possible to get an easy way to see the difference?
I did a brief comparison of FC Starter and Logos Starter and it looks to be nearly the same content. The fact that the number of books in the FC and Standard libraries match means that they probably are the same content. If they are indeed the same content, then any FC subscriber should never purchase a Standard library! Your subscription model discourages big purchases. Suddenly, the comparison between Prime Video and FC becomes a contrast. At this point, what makes dynamic pricing so difficult, since it appears to be no different than upgrading between libraries?
I truly appreciate the candor that has been expressed on this forum. It gives me a lot of faith in FL as a company. If I am wrong and the libraries are different, would it be possible to get an easy way to see the difference?
You're correct. There's currently a one-to-one relationship between the following:
That will likely change when Logos 8 comes out. They won't necessarily stay in lockstep. It was the easiest way of improving the quality of Logos Cloud libraries when we did the Cloud relaunch last year.
But presently, for example, a Logos 7 Bronze or higher owner would gain no new Logos base package library resources by getting Faithlife Connect Essentials.
Which is why Spotify doesn't give me credit for all the CDs I bought years ago... and Netflix doesn't credit me the movie tickets I bought when the films were new releases... and my Microsoft Office 365 subscription isn't cheaper because I've bought 5 copies of the whole Office suite with or for various computers over the years...
Bad analogy - No one would subscribe to Spotify if they only had 10% more songs than I had my CD library - and crummy songs too. This is why your large library holders see significant value loss in a subscription plan that does not consider their own library.
Office 365 subscription cost is at or even a little lower than waiting to buy the next CD. This is comparable to the value people saw in Logos Now. You notice over the years Microsoft has pared away unwanted/unprofitable features in Office that no one wanted, and that just increased the cost. I wonder why FL doesn't consider this in its subscription model (which by the way most do not have an issue with as this post shows, the issue is the value for the cost).
I’m sorry when that frustrates you, and promise that we will continue to try and do right by every user, even if we have to address each user’s situation specifically. We will also continue to listen to your feedback; it is the most important thing in helping us make decisions.
Thanks for letting us know what you think, even if you're unhappy.
One last thing: Bob, I appreciate your openness to feedback, whether positive or negative, and your willingness to dialog with your customers.
I wish to highlight this section of Bob's post to some of the forumites who regularly jump in and start calling people bad Christians whenever they raise complaints about something FaithLife has done. Here you have it from Bob himself--they can handle the criticism.
Thanks for taking the time to explain. I have spent around 15k over the years, and have been blessed with access to top resources, and powerful software tools that have helped be dive deeper into the word of God. I plan to continue to add resources to my library because I love the platform. Logos now did not make much sense to me, so I think that your decision to change to better defined product offerings is wise. I can understand why some people are upset. As is the case with government, after a "program" is rolled out, it is very hard to take it away from people who are benefiting form it, no matter how unsustainable it is to continue to offer (i.e. Obamacare...)
Its hard for me to get too worked up about this since the goal of all these "books" and "features is to dig deeper into the bible and apply it to my life, and teach it to others, for the glory of God!
I am truly grateful for the hard work that you and your employees put into making Logos so great. I am not a Preacher, I am a CPA, so if it were not for Logos I would not have the time, the training or the resources to go as deep as I do! You have been fair and I trust that you will continue to be fair.
God Bless
Mark
Here's my "street cred" for Logos: Since 2004, spent $23K on resources and upgrades.
Here's my take on things: I hate all software subscription models, and prefer owning the software. Aside from not seeing the value in Logos Now, and being highly confused about the benefits, I never subscribed. I have no intention of subscribing to anything new in the future, and since my purchases have ebbed off lately, probably never will.
With that said, Bob, why don't you just sell the software? Its worked for thousands of companies for a very long time. I happily purchase new versions of software if there are compelling reasons to do so. If not, I usually buy every other upgrade.
Is it a change in your 25 year old business model? Yeah, but hey, it beats all these little and annoying disruptive reversals every few years when things don't pan out.
Will people be annoyed? Sure, but so what? One reason why I never jumped onto Logos Now is I had no need for the latest up-to-date feature set.
And I think most people don't ::need:: it either. They want it, sure, but don't need it, and can wait a year or two between releases. We've got a freakin' digital library of quality resources at our finger-tips! That's amazing enough! And after 25 years of innovating, while I'm sure there's still a lot of cool things you can do with the manipulation of book data, isn't it getting to the point where you've already achieved a lot of the "low-hanging fruit" and are having to work harder and harder to develop new and innovative features, most of which are interesting to a smaller and smaller group of people?
What I'm saying is, people can wait 1-2 years for a new feature set, AND pay for it too.
Just my thought on things. I don't know the financial of something like this, of course, just putting to text the sort of system I like and would be happy to purchase if it were to go that way in the future.
With that said, Bob, why don't you just sell the software? Its worked for thousands of companies for a very long time. I happily purchase new versions of software if there are compelling reasons to do so. If not, I usually buy every other upgrade.
They can’t do that b cause they spent 15 years saying (or at least strongly implying) that the software was free, you just pay for the books. Many people who’ve invested hundreds or thousands of dollars would be horrified if they had to pay for software upgrades to keep using Logos when the ‘old‘ version becomes incompatible with their new computer, or because they want to buy one book which only works with the latest version.
This is my personal Faithlife account. On 1 March 2022, I started working for Faithlife, and have a new 'official' user account. Posts on this account shouldn't be taken as official Faithlife views!
They can’t do that b cause they spent 15 years saying (or at least strongly implying) that the software was free, you just pay for the books. Many people who’ve invested hundreds or thousands of dollars would be horrified if they had to pay for software upgrades to keep using Logos when the ‘old‘ version becomes incompatible with their new computer, or because they want to buy one book which only works with the latest version.
Yeah, there would be a period of adjustment, but so what? Business models don't stay the same forever. If this can help fund development in a more reliable way than these other schemes do, why not do it? Plus, it would actually be less confusing because most people are used to paying for the latest software release. That's been the norm for decades for the entire industry.
Maintaining current hardware and software is the cost of doing business in the digital age. We all know this. Logos has dealt with funding the software portion by growing their marketshare for books, but obviously that's not paying the bills anymore.
If we could just pay for the software updates and buy books like we've always been doing, and do away with this stupid subscription stuff, I think everyone would be a lot happier.
The whole thing would certainly be a lot simpler.
I hate all software subscription models, and prefer owning the software.
Greg, I think what you're proposing is (half of) what we're doing: we're going back to just selling the software, which should meet your needs and those of many others. And then, for people starting from scratch or who prefer subscription, we're creating a subscription offering.
Or am I misunderstanding?
EDIT: I was misunderstanding... I now see you meant charging for the updates to the software... but I think that would break more expectations from even more users than discontinuing offering Logos Now, though you're right it might be an alternate solution.
We also need to support the pure transactional model for people who want to 'buy it, own it, and not have to pay again.' That's what we've always offered, and what we plan to continue to offer.That is a very worrisome statement. It is far less assuring than statements you have made in the past.
I'm sorry -- I didn't mean it to be any different than past statements on the subject. We have no plans to discontinue the transactional model.
We also need to support the pure transactional model for people who want to 'buy it, own it, and not have to pay again.' That's what we've always offered, and what we plan to continue to offer.That is a very worrisome statement. It is far less assuring than statements you have made in the past.
I'm sorry -- I didn't mean it to be any different than past statements on the subject. We have no plans to discontinue the transactional model.
Don't forget that you're on a forum of exegetes. Every word you say will get dissected for meaning, context and inference. Ironically, your software helped train us for that in part. Anyway, I'm going to fire up a couple of Logos Guides on this thread so that fully understand what everyone here is saying...
Bob -
Thank you for your explanation of the economics of the problem. I cheerfully admit to being one of those who "over-valued" the 6 week cycle of updates. I will also admit to seriously considering Logos Connect for my Luthern pastor daughter-in-law. I'll be evaluating the library for its useful to a Lutheran.
I have, however, been slightly disappointed with the 6-week cycle of updates but not for the reasons you suspect. With an IT background, I was aware that there would be only so much "low-hanging fruit" projects for Logos to both push out visible improvements and make the infrastructure changes necessary to keep the product on the forefront of the industry. Therefore, I was anticipating a number of visible data and small projects to be rolled out. Examples:
Yes, the ones that come to my mind are ones that reflect my interests, but I am certain that a number of your users could provide lists of small projects that would enhance the usefulness of Logos for them. As the 6 week development cycle seemed to greatly improve your quality control and as there are many small projects still fitting into the 6 week cycle model, I'm not thrilled that Logos Connect does not retain the new feature aspect of Logos Now.
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
I've been thinking about what other model would work for both FL and the customers, and I understand the need and desire to go towards a subscription model. I think you can successfully do this with just tweaking and reprioritising what you already have.
Logos is in a bit of a unique situation where you have both advanced software and resources. It's sort of like Amazon Kindle and Microsoft Office combined, where you buy resources but also get very powerful tools to work with your resources.
You mention that your subscription model, Logos Now, failed because of lack of uptake. I think that main reason this happened was because it wasn't implemented as the default purchase method for new customers and version upgrades. If you change your website so that the default purchase method was a subscription service, you could steer new customers to this, and promote it to new customers.
May I suggest going with a subscription model for your software, plus outright purchase for books?
I would suggest the following model: (I've just put some prices in to flesh out the idea - I don't know if they are realistic for FL's profitability)
Users first choose the software & feature package. Include the option of outright purchase for those who want it, but make that the secondary purchase option, not the first. Also allow for dynamic pricing so that a percentage of the subscription fee would go towards the full purchase price - this would allow people to lock in features at some future point - e.g at retirement. This step would be a slight modification of your Feature Set purchase option.
Users choose a base library package to purchase outright. Possibly give one year free subscription to one of the above levels, based on the size of the purchased library. Splitting the library package from the software features may allow you to be able to decrease the cost of the base packages - making Logos more attractive.
Choose add-on subscriptions. This would include things like:
Another thing that I noticed was a couple of mentions about people buying less. This is to be expected as your larger customers run out of stuff they need/want to buy. This is also why (as others have said) you need a strong focus on getting new customers - particularly those with no library, who will likely be future big buyers. I'm thinking particularly of seminary students. I'm not familiar with what you do in order to promote Logos to seminary students, so forgive me if I'm suggesting thing you already do. My thoughts were:
I think my first suggestion could help transition Logos to subscription service, while not upsetting current users by including dynamic pricing and still allowing outright purchase, while the second suggestion would help FL to gain future big-spending customers before they have committed to competitor products, supporting the long term viability of Logos.
Hopefully my suggestions are useful to FL. I really want to see FL continue to do well in the future.
I've been thinking about what other model would work for both FL and the customers, and I understand the need and desire to go towards a subscription model. I think you can successfully do this with just tweaking and reprioritising what you already have.
The problem with all this, and this goes for Logos' implementation of it too, is everything's too confusing.
KISS is key, so here's my suggestion:
Subscription can be for people who only need Logos on a limited basis, or just want to get their feet wet, or something like that. The native program would be for anyone who wants to have downloaded resources on their computer. Subscribers would have to purchase it to get that functionality. Base packages would be for the professional user or highly motivated layman.
These are just quickly written ideas. I have no idea how Logos works internally and what the financials look like. But after watching things develop over the years into a more and more complex system, I think a big reset needs to happen. Income from book sales isn't cutting it, obviously, and somethings gotta give. My suggestion is to make the whole set-up similar to what works in the computer industry, to make it easy for the customer to understand and get sucked into, and to provide a consistent source of revenue so Logos can continue developing great software.
Logos engine needs to purchased with each upgrade??? And I thought I was going to have a nice quiet seizure before. Unless I am misunderstanding this, maybe someone should delete this right off the forum. The rest needs not any comment.
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
Logos engine needs to purchased with each upgrade??? And I thought I was going to have a nice quiet seizure before. Unless I am misunderstanding this, maybe someone should delete this right off the forum. The rest needs not any comment.
Hi Boot,
No, you heard me right. Just like almost every other piece of software out there, every major release needs to be purchased. I'm thinking point releases, like Logos 8 or Logos 9. Obviously if you buy a base package or upgrade, the Logos program is included with the price. But for those who don't need more books, but want to take advantage of new features and keep access to their books current on the latest operating systems and hardware, purchase the program. You purchase new hardware, right? Purchase new software too.
This isn't an odd idea. The software industry has been operating successfully like this for decades.
Logos cannot be compared to Adobe or Microsoft because of fundamental differences. Logos puts out both the tool and the resource, while those companies only put out the tools. Their subscription model is for the tools, not the resources. Making a subscription model based on the tool AND the resource only leads to massively huge subscription prices that nobody wants to pay.
Nix that idea and just sell the software like everyone else. Put all the non-royalty based resources on a flat-rate subscription plan thats limited to web access, and sell base packages and upgrades like normal for those who want Logos natively on their system long term. Keep the mobile programs free with a limited number of entry-level resources for entry-level people, but then just tie in a person's subscription and/or base packages into it. Subsidize it's development with some subscription revenue and desktop program revenue.
As I said earlier, in the digital age, where there are multiple mediums between the user and the content, its expected that the user will have to invest in new hardware and software to continue to have access to the content. With physical books you don't have that problem, which is why physical books are awesome. But you do with digital books, and we justify that by saying the benefits of digital outweigh these small constraints.
Logos is a digital book company. Its fully invested in digital books. While trying to embrace the benefits of digital books and the perpetual access of physical books has worked in the past when the industry was new and growing, its not working anymore when the industry is more established.
Embrace digital or go home. Accept that the medium between the user and content need funds to be maintained.
My suggestion is to make the whole set-up similar to what works in the computer industry, to make it easy for the customer to understand and get sucked into, and to provide a consistent source of revenue so Logos can continue developing great software.
What works in the computer industry is selling support to enterprises. One of the most successful software companies is GitLab. They don't charge for their basic product, they charge for professional features and fast support. If FL is having trouble keeping the cost of the engine down, then maybe it is time to consider open-source. There is a reason that major companies have started to open their source code. I'm not saying it will be a fix all, but software engineers/coders work on opensource projects a lot. This could be a way to tap a relatively unengaged set of Christian skill. Would Christian software designers be willing to throw some extra hours at Logos? I don't know, but I would venture to say yes. As long as the features they develop remain free, then gathering the coders should not be impossible. It would require some new marketing and engagement, though. FL could still charge for anything they develop in-house, which is the same way GitLab does it. If FL bundled things for a church (enterprise) and sold seats to the church for access to various FL products, then FL could sell/bundle subscription support for the product as well.
I'm not saying that FL needs to go opensource, but if you want to talk about what the computer industry is doing, especially cutting-edge, then you have to talk about opensource. I'm just throwing things at a wall to see what sticks.
No not pay for each upgrade that’s not something anyone will buy into
Keith Pang, PhD Check out my blog @ https://keithkpang.wixsite.com/magnifyingjesus
I finally got my email. After visiting my Subscription page, I called Customer Service to change my renewal from FLC to Verbum Now. The representative informed me that Verbum Now will be transitioned to FLC so he could not honor my request, but I was welcome to cancel the renwal of FLC. This contradicts the statements posted in this thread.
https://community.logos.com/forums/p/160523/957990.aspx#957990
Meanwhile, Jesus kept on growing wiser and more mature, and in favor with God and his fellow man.
International Standard Version. (2011). (Lk 2:52). Yorba Linda, CA: ISV Foundation.
MacBook Pro MacOS Sequoia 15.4 1TB SSD
HI Bob,
Thank you so much for taking the time to explain your companies decision to introduce this. My concern is the way that everything is lumped together which I know your e-mail touches upon with an analogy. It sounds like the reason for the product introduction is to keep revenue flowing in order for you to develop the product, run the business and make a profit. This makes sense total sense from your side of the fence and I can understand why as a business you want this. From my perspective as a customer I want this too, if only to see the product develop and be available in 20 years time so we are on the same page there. I would also like to thank you for the "break in" period and I have to say I feel you have looked after me personally over the next year so thank you for this. My criticism is the bundling of features which we may or may not want seems unfair. For example I have a lot of the books in the bundle you are including but I have to effectively pay for these again (month after month). How about doing something smart and including books we don't already own, or giving us a discount for stuff we already own. Also I love Mobile Ed but I want to own the courses for future reference so renting them for 6 months is for me pointless - how about letting us buy the courses as a very much reduced rate or even giving us them as part of the subscription. What you have suggested may be workable but I think you need to be customer driven and not revenue driven - aim for customer satisfaction and you will hit your revenue targets - aim for revenue targets and you are likely to miss both.
Please consider applying this product in a better way :-)
Thanks
Bob,
Thanks for the post. I am like several others who chose LN as a way to support development efforts and use new features before they were offered in a package. When I renewed this year, I wasn't thinking about a 6 week release cycle but about the features that I would likely use this year.
If the lowest offering had the Sermon Editor and a few other features that I use in LN, I'd maintain a subscription. Since FL has sent a discount code towards the purchase of a package that would get me those features, there's no reason for me to be upset. You've been more than fair and we've seen a better web product and feature sets along the way.
Wylie, TX
Bob,
Thank you very much for the extended, detailed explanation behind the new direction. You don't owe us that, but I definitely appreciate it.
Despite all of the data that you have gathered, I think there's an incorrect premise in your explanation. It's not that we wanted new features every 6 weeks - it's that we wanted to have the easiest possible way to make sure we always had all available features (including datasets). If you had rolled out significant new features annually, that would have been fine - I know that I'd have them.
What I (and many others, based on all the threads) wanted was a known, fixed cost that ensured I'd have all the features. There are two reasons this is important: 1) I don't need any more large package book purchases; 2) FL's long-standing policy of not releasing feature-only upgrades on the day of major upgrades. As I said in another thread, if I knew for sure that I could upgrade on the day of release for the equivalent of $99/year, I'd be content. But we don't know what the day-of-release offerings are going to be, let alone the price. LN gave me predictability at an easy to swallow price point. That's disappeared.
Further, if LN users only make up 1.8% of revenue - you admitted it wasn't as widely adopted as you'd hoped - what makes you think that Connect will have any better adoption rate? As I look at the price points, a new customer could buy packages that he/she would own for the annual cost of a subscription, which would disappear if the subscription is not renewed. It's not clear to me how Connect provides more incentive to adopt than LN.
One last point: You made it clear that you're trying to ensure that you can have an appropriately profitable company - completely understandable. But the extra "benefits" in Connect Essentials surely cost something. So the price point for Essentials has to cover the costs for all Logos features plus 2 courses plus TV plus other resources plus whatever other "benefits" are included. What's the objection to offering a Logos-only subscription which doesn't have to cover those costs. As I read all the threads, the majority of respondents state that those benefits have been lightly used at best in LN and aren't actually of interest.
I suspect your response will be: "That's all understandable, Donnie. That's why you can still buy the feature sets." That would be a perfectly fair response, but it would still miss my main point: The purchase price point for feature sets when major releases come out is unknown and unpredictable. $99/yr solves that problem for me (and I think many others).
Thanks again for responding and answering so many questions. It's generous of you.
Donnie
What I (and many others, based on all the threads) wanted was a known, fixed cost that ensured I'd have all the features. There are two reasons this is important: 1) I don't need any more large package book purchases;
Well, if you do subscribe to Faithlife Connect, you can still have that predictability, just at a higher cost. Because you're kind of making my point... we were pricing Logos Now in a way that still anticipated we'd get revenue subsidy from book purchases. But you have (understandably) become an "I don't need any more large package book purchases" customer, which means we're getting less revenue than was expected/needed to support the feature development you expect.
Further, if LN users only make up 1.8% of revenue - you admitted it wasn't as widely adopted as you'd hoped - what makes you think that Connect will have any better adoption rate?
Because Logos Now was (by definition) something we sold to people with a base package, and those base package customers turned out to (mostly) not care about it.... and it confused the messaging to new customers. Faithlife Connect is a clearer story (and a good value) for a new subscriber who isn't tacking it on top of a base package sale, and who may not be a 20-year user. And there may be many, many more people in the church who are willing to subscribe at a lower up front cost because their need is different. (Someone who signed up to be a small group leader this year... and who might not want to make a permanent, multi-hundred-dollar library purchase, or a student who wants to have extra tools to get through this semester...)
We still offer full purchase, and even payment plans, to make the permanent licensing accessible too, but we're realizing there are different customer profiles.
We may be wrong, in which case we'll adjust things again... but we're pretty certain there are people out there who aren't 'base + Now' customers, who want something simpler.
The purchase price point for feature sets when major releases come out is unknown and unpredictable. $99/yr solves that problem for me (and I think many others).
I know, and I'm sorry that particular option is going away... but it wasn't solving the problem for the costs to support it.
you have (understandably) become an "I don't need any more large package book purchases" customer, which means we're getting less revenue than was expected/needed to support the feature development you expect.
Which is why it seems plain as day that FL must end up in a Subscription model for it's features. Companies like Adobe, Microsoft, Intuit and Salsforce all do it.
I was in the Adobe ecosytem when they made the change and the outcry was very loud, and yet look where they are now.
BUT, what they all offer is a subscription to tools, not content! IMHO, that is FL's biggest issue. You started off operating in reverse of the current trend: Get free tools (functionality) if you buy content (really secondary products) that work with the tools.
Now somehow you need to reverse that or at least rebalance it. Of course, the problem is, many of the people who bought into the first scheme and got you to this point are feeling betrayed. Not good:(
Of course, the flip side is: how many new tools and features does anyone really need? Brother, we are just reading books!
At the root of this problem is that our component prices aren't lined up with our component costs.
So why not just trim the fat, cut the nonsense, and take the plunge into a full tools subscription and properly convince (basically bribe) your current owners into becoming subscribers. They helped you get here, Make them feel like they are important and in two years everyone will have forgotten about it and FL will have a sustainable model with happy advocates for their product.
But, if you think that expanding the business requires all these "adjacent markets" then you better be right about what people want and be able to provide it. Sadly, I don't see as much evidence of that as I do FL trying to do things that they "hope" or "guess" will work. Thus, instead of offering people the tools for subscription, you are offering the tools with a lot of bloatware that no one wants to pay for.
Honestly, how many people interested in parsing syntax, searching lemmas or reading 700 page commentaries are tuning into Faithlife TV? And the free books? The list is quite sparse and poor.
I do actually think that the Ecourses are a great incentive, but sadly, the list of available choices is again not too exciting.
Why not just sell the books and rent the tools, straightup? Give folks a fair chance to stick with a certain tool set at the end of their subscription or pay to upgrade and all is fine. A la carte will let you know what people want and what is a waste of everyone's time and money.
Yes sir M Wilson. That would be just super for those of us who do not want to go the Subscription route but presently have the product.
Personally, I want to own the product, whether it be Logos 7 or to earn Air miles, jump into Logos 8 which I'll probably do. It seems from what you're saying, the owning option would eventually be ruled out. Or am I misreading something you're attempting to say?
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
But, if you think that expanding the business requires all these "adjacent markets" then you better be right about what people want and be able to provide it. Sadly, I don't see as much evidence of that as I do FL trying to do things that they "hope" or "guess" will work. Thus, instead of offering people the tools for subscription, you are offering the tools with a lot of bloatware that no one wants to pay for.
I think it is the "adjacent markets" that has the most impact here. There seems to be a shift in general from printed media to visual media
As someone about to graduate from seminary, I was thinking that Now would have been an affordable way to stay up to date on the software without adding to my library. I didn't think I'd be able to afford the feature only packages going forward, and I've pretty much gotten my library to where I want it with the exception of some "nice-to-haves" that I probably won't end up buying.
I don't think the primary value of Now was new features "every six weeks" so much as just up-to-date software without massive financial outlay. You could have been on an annual or semi-annual update schedule and it still would have been valuable.
But if some people thought that "cool new features every six weeks" was the most important aspect of Logos Now, they had a lot of help coming to that conclusion...because that's how you marketed the product. You aggressively marketed this product, and one of the main talking points was new features every six weeks without having to wait for the next major update. I mean, you did name the offering Logos NOW, as in I can have new features NOW instead of waiting two years. You marketed Logos Now in every way imaginable. Many of your Logos Pro training videos are basically extended length advertisements for Logos Now, since you always made sure to include menu options that people didn't have unless they had Logos Now. That added to people's confusion because they would try to perform the actions in the training videos to discover they didn't have the feature that was being demonstrated, and it wasn't always explicitly called out that it was a Logos Now-only feature. My very detailed oriented mind (I was an accountant/financial analyst in my former life) means I automatically look for those little details, but not everybody thinks that way. They assume that if you show them something on a training video, they will be able to do it in their software.
My point is that Faithlife creates a lot of their own problems through their own aggressive marketing/communication tactics. I see it over and over again every time you have a new product/service release or promotion. Every time, there is some level of confusion (usually mass-confusion) that can be directly traced back to vague/misleading communication or even out-and-out overselling of products offerings or promotions (meaning pretty much overstating or playing up offerings to the point that customers consistently think they're getting more than they actually are). You pretty much do have to have an accountant's or lawyer's eye for detail and precision to see what is really being said and what's not being said, and I see why the average person may get confused. You need to focus on clear communication in advertising going forward, or you will continue to have these problems.
As many have said, the greatest value you offer is the actual software itself with all of the wonderfully helpful features. It has been indispensable during my seminary education. I love the software and the powerful tools it offers, and I hope to have a reasonably affordable way to keep my software up to date going forward. I know you need to make money, and I want your to business to be sustainable. One major reason I chose Logos over Accordance is that I thought you were more up to date on the latest technology trends in software, and thus would be more sustainable going forward since I was making a big investment in the future of any bible software program I chose. Keep up the good work and remember to continue to focus on what you're good at. Sorry for the long post, but I've wanted to say this for a long time but never felt like typing this much before and thought it would be overkill. [:)]
Live long a prosper, Faithlife...seriously, live long and prosper.
If you didn't get an email, ... contact us. We'll make it right.
I hadn't received the email so I contacted customer service yesterday specifically asking about an email containing a coupon which I had read about on the forums, and 30 minutes later I received a generic customer service reply:
Dear James,
Thank you for contacting us! The information about Faithlife connect as you can see we have a lot of forums https://community.logos.com/forums/p/160514/956980.aspx and information comes here https://connect.faithlife.com/ https://connect.faithlife.com/logos If you are a Logos now member, don’t worry you’re not losing anything actually you’re winning a lot more
Here https://www.logos.com/compare/feature-sets shows you what are you winning
Sincerely,
Andrea Cruz
Faithlife Support Department
800-875-6467 | 360-527-1700 | UK Callers: 0(871)218-1700
www.Logos.com/Support - Logos Support
www.Logos.com/Videos - Training Videos
You study with Logos, now present with Proclaim.
There was no coupon or anything about credits or sales or special offers specific to me (and I would think I fall in the "handful of customers" who have spent over $20,000 on this investment over the last 7 or 8 years). And I will say I have been very impressed with Logos and Faithlife, but I would like to receive this email/coupon you've referred to. I just don't know who else to contact.
Logos 10 | Dell Inspiron 7373 | Windows 11 Pro 64, i7, 16GB, SSD | iPhone 13 Pro Max
If you didn't get an email, ... contact us. We'll make it right.I hadn't received the email so I contacted customer service yesterday specifically asking about an email containing a coupon which I had read about on the forums, and 30 minutes later I received a generic customer service reply:
...
There was no coupon or anything about credits or sales or special offers specific to me (and I would think I fall in the "handful of customers" who have spent over $20,000 on this investment over the last 7 or 8 years). And I will say I have been very impressed with Logos and Faithlife, but I would like to receive this email/coupon you've referred to. I just don't know who else to contact.
James, no one has responded to you so let me just ask if you were a Logos Now subscriber. My understanding is that the emails and coupons only went out to Logos Now subscribers and the amount was based on how long they had subscribed.
Pastor, North Park Baptist Church
Bridgeport, CT USA
Bob, thanks for explaining the situation so clearly. Obviously, no software company, Logos included, can continue to develop next year's product on last year's sales. The $18k I've spent was for the product that I downloaded and have used since, NOT for indefinite future releases. Paying a comparatively small amount for the feature set upgrade every couple of years (about $150 for Logos 7) is a really inexpensive way to make sure that my Macbook Pro and Logos continue to get along. I don't have to purchase the same books over again, so I don't see the problem.
Logos Now cost more to develop than it ever earned in subscriptions, and was adopted by so few that keeping it going made no sense. Purchase sales have flattened to the point where some kind of subscription model is necessary if Logos is to continue to function in the future.
Got it.
Thanks again for explaining it!
Greg Lawhorn
Bob, thank you for your very lengthy, very clear, very level-headed post. This is excellent customer service, as is giving nine whole months of notice before making the switch. Nine months should be more than enough time for people with strong emotional reactions to calm down and get used to the idea. It also gives you more time to tinker with/improve Faithlife Connect, which is also good.
(NB: I have not read all of the responses to your post, just the first page.)
For my part, I think that what you are doing largely makes sense, and I myself am glad that Verbum Now is sticking around because it meets my present needs better than the present Faithlife Connect offerings do. Perhaps some of the people who want to keep 'old Logos Now' should subscribe to Verbum Now!
“The trouble is that everyone talks about reforming others and no one thinks about reforming himself.” St. Peter of Alcántara
No. This is not like a magazine. You all said yourselves this is your "online service". It's not understood by the users to have an expiration date in the same way paper magazines do. That's not how any other online service works. At all. Anywhere.
Think instead if Amazon Prime renamed, dropped half their services, and told every subscriber they could have it back for twice the price. Or if Netflix did the same. That's the proper analogy.
This is shady. And giving a 9 month head-start doesn't change that.
Adding tremendous new features to justify a new tier at a higher price or choosing a more modest price bump would have been standard practice (for companies without a moral compass).
I am just so very, very disappointed. As someone who has been a loyal user for years, invested thousands of dollars, I did not expect so little from Logos. I have had my view of your business significantly altered through this.
There's an answer. Walk it back. This is does hurt you. And it violates a trust we put in you.
I appreciate Bob's explanation. The one thing that disturbed me about it was the suggestion that FaithLife would prefer to be on a pure subscription model. Personally, I prefer an ownership model. I understand Bob's point about users wanting new features. But...that's not where I am. While I do want the software to be maintained and kept reasonably up-to-date with evolving platforms, it already has way more features than I'm ever likely to use.
For me personally, it really is about the books. Instead of renting access to a generalized library, I like building my own. Right now I'm working full-time in a corporate job, and can afford to do that. It won't be too many years before I retire from that corporate job, and when I do I'd like to be able to continue using the library I'm building now.
I appreciate Bob's explanation. The one thing that disturbed me about it was the suggestion that FaithLife would prefer to be on a pure subscription model. Personally, I prefer an ownership model. I understand Bob's point about users wanting new features. But...that's not where I am. While I do want the software to be maintained and kept reasonably up-to-date with evolving platforms, it already has way more features than I'm ever likely to use.
For me personally, it really is about the books. Instead of renting access to a generalized library, I like building my own. Right now I'm working full-time in a corporate job, and can afford to do that. It won't be too many years before I retire from that corporate job, and when I do I'd like to be able to continue using the library I'm building now.
I appreciate his honesty about how, were he founding Faithlife now, he'd probably go subscription only. I'm also glad that he's keeping the buy-and-own model that customers of his like you and me prefer.
“The trouble is that everyone talks about reforming others and no one thinks about reforming himself.” St. Peter of Alcántara
I appreciate his honesty about how, were he founding Faithlife now, he'd probably go subscription only. I'm also glad that he's keeping the buy-and-own model that customers of his like you and me prefer.
I agree - I appreciate both. I just find it a bit disconcerting that he no longer sees the model we like as a preferred way to do business. I'd hate to see the ownership model gradually de-emphasized and neglected over time. I'm not saying that Faithlife intends to do that, or ever will. I just find it a bit unsettling.
For me personally, it really is about the books. Instead of renting access to a generalized library, I like building my own. Right now I'm working full-time in a corporate job, and can afford to do that. It won't be too many years before I retire from that corporate job, and when I do I'd like to be able to continue using the library I'm building now.
As I watched Now's feature path at $10/mo, my impression was a yawn. I wondered how many pastors sit around counting theophanies .... if you're decently familiar with the text, an exactness I suppose is worth what? On the other hand, so many forum queries on speed, usability, maps (!), and so on. And DAL going gaga over pictures at Another Co.
Then there's now the dog-wagging tail problem, and the solution as free movies and some books at twice the price.
I suspect many will take a harder look at exactly what the software improvements are good for, in their day to day spiritual life.
"If myth is ideology in narrative form, then scholarship is myth with footnotes." B. Lincolm 1999.
I wondered how many pastors sit around counting theophanies
Don't know about others, but as a child I was fascinated by the tables and lists in Dad's Unger's :-)
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
I love Logos and have invested into its software because it gives me indispensable tools.
I just hope that Logos does not get so caught up in looking at market trends that they forget to pay attention to why their business exists in the first place, which is to give people powerful tools for studying the Bible.
My feeling as a Logos customer is that a subscription service will most likely price me out, or under deliver. But, you said that you are keeping the buy-to-own service, which I am already very happy with, so I will have no problem.
I hope you are able to make the business work and keep it flexible
I have looked at the comparison chart. The Logos Now features I regularly use will not be available through Faithlife Connect Starter. I am being forced to pay double for Essentials. Other new features available still does not bring back the current features I now use. $200 off Logos 8 is nice, but does not solve the issue of still having to pay double for what I now use. You can say all you want that Faithlife will give you this or that, but the fact remains that I will still have to pay double for what I currently use. This does seem like punishment to me.
You can say all you want that Faithlife will give you this or that, but the fact remains that I will still have to pay double for what I currently use. This does seem like punishment to me.
Danny, for you it's probably worth checking out Verbum Now, which offers almost exactly the same features as Logos Now at the same price (and Verbum staff have confirmed that Verbum Now isn't going anywhere anytime soon). There's a pretty decent chance that everything you use in Logos Now is available in Verbum Now.
“The trouble is that everyone talks about reforming others and no one thinks about reforming himself.” St. Peter of Alcántara
I have looked at the comparison chart. The Logos Now features I regularly use will not be available through Faithlife Connect Starter. I am being forced to pay double for Essentials. Other new features available still does not bring back the current features I now use. $200 off Logos 8 is nice, but does not solve the issue of still having to pay double for what I now use. You can say all you want that Faithlife will give you this or that, but the fact remains that I will still have to pay double for what I currently use. This does seem like punishment to me.
It is punishment if a cram down is punishment (creditors are given take it or leave it offers... take 15 cents on the dollar or you will get nothing)....... Bob implies that he can't stay in business with the Logos Now model. I wonder if getting rid of the things we don't want might change that equation. Again, going back to Business School...., if your overhead is too much for your income you are toast (Harvard even agrees)... maybe cut income from things like the TV and keep those of us who just want to study the bible happy.
Problem is, Bob, your salesmen sold us the idea of getting cutting edge tools (logos now) and a huge library to serve God.... and now you are instructing your same salesmen to urge their customers to rent this huge library their customers already own (don't worry about it as we don't have an ability to credit you for what you own.... but, don't worry) and also rent the tools you were renting.
They didn't know better when they touted and pushed logos now... they honestly thought they were doing the right thing for their customers and you... and also could take the commission home to the wife... it felt good to them and the customer.... now management makes their words untrue.
Sir, this will backfire. It may be a big desert; but, the tents are close together. Logos is driven by hungry commission driven sales people selling to people who want nothing more than to understand the Bible and serve God...Pretty easy sale....so, the pitch your salesmen use has been, at least to me, let's load up on Books (you own them after all) and, at least now, rent the tools (logos now) so you can have the books you need to serve God. More the merrier. Stretch and buy the books.... you will do a better job for God.
Simple solution: Cut out the stuff we don't want and all of the overhead associated with it (including employees), sell those of us who have a bunch of books the software and charge for updates. Folks who haven't gone nearly broke buying (repeat BUYING) books to better serve God can live with this. Folks who don't have a big library can just rent what they need and buy any add ons. That way, lots of very cash starved seminariarians can rent the books they need to start their ministry and do their studies.
Does that work???
Simple solution: Cut out the stuff we don't want and all of the overhead associated with it (including employees), sell those of us who have a bunch of books the software and charge for updates. Folks who haven't gone nearly broke buying (repeat BUYING) books to better serve God can live with this. Folks who don't have a big library can just rent what they need and buy any add ons. That way, lots of very cash starved seminariarians can rent the books they need to start their ministry and do their studies.
Does that work???
Rob, not arguing with you. I thought Now had no future the day it was intro'd.
But from the looks of the Now wreckage:
- They're crediting Now'ers for much of their investment. And, ignoring Now'ers benefitted as promised. Pretty much 'made whole'?
- They're intro'ing Connect. It looks like L7 deja vu. I don't see how people will see the value. Especially if Now acceptance was so low. Who knows.
Maybe just reset the calendar to 2016 and call it a day .... new L8 soon. Buy, or not.
"If myth is ideology in narrative form, then scholarship is myth with footnotes." B. Lincolm 1999.
In marketing they make a lot of the question "is this (product) for people like me". Now was. Connect is not. The feeling that kind of change in direction gives is unpleasant. Especially with talk of "if we started today we would be subscription only".Rob, not arguing with you. I thought Now had no future the day it was intro'd.
But from the looks of the Now wreckage:
- They're crediting Now'ers for much of their investment. And, ignoring Now'ers benefitted as promised. Pretty much 'made whole'?
- They're intro'ing Connect. It looks like L7 deja vu. I don't see how people will see the value. Especially if Now acceptance was so low. Who knows.
Maybe just reset the calendar to 2016 and call it a day .... new L8 soon. Buy, or not.
All of us who bought heavily into logos are too heavy a burden I guess. *sigh*
I'm getting out of here for a while again. Till the next time I get an unsettling email from them

L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
Logos is driven by hungry commission driven sales people selling to people who want nothing more than to understand the Bible and serve God.
Several years ago (ca 2010) we learned that the Logos sales structure was switched so that salesmen didn't earn commissions anymore. Unless it was quietly changed back in the intervening years, commission is not sales' primary motivation.
Logos is driven by hungry commission driven sales people selling to people who want nothing more than to understand the Bible and serve God.
Several years ago (ca 2010) we learned that the Logos sales structure was switched so that salesmen didn't earn commissions anymore. Unless it was quietly changed back in the intervening years, commission is not sales' primary motivation.
The sales men and woman have a wonderful godly attitude and a desire to sell their products. I wish I could get that type of person without incentivising them based on sales.
Sorry....
Bob implies that he can't stay in business with the Logos Now model.
I'm sorry if I wasn't clear enough... we're not in danger of going out of business. The Logos Now model wasn't working on its own, but one of the reasons it wasn't working was that so few base package users chose to use that model. (For all the sound and fury on the topic, less than 4% of active base package users subscribed to Logos Now.) So it wasn't sustainable, but it wasn't killing us: even a healthy business doesn't want to carry a small 'bad-business product' inside the overall healthy, bigger business.
Simple solution: Cut out the stuff we don't want and all of the overhead associated with it (including employees), sell those of us who have a bunch of books the software and charge for updates.
Well, as you can imagine, laying off staff and cutting back isn't a popular plan inside the company, and it doesn't bode well for the future. Salary increase pressure, morale, career planning, etc. are all pressures that get worse when you choose to shrink instead of grow -- and it's easy to start 'circling the drain' once you solve problems by shrinking instead of growing.
Moreover, as mentioned earlier, we made some firm commitments about making engine updates free, and engine maintenance is getting more and more expensive, along with baseline expectations for what 'minimal' upgrades mean.
but the fact remains that I will still have to pay double for what I currently use. This does seem like punishment to me.
I think that one things that keeps getting lost in this conversation is that we aren't forcing anyone to pay double to keep what they have; we're changing the product configuration. People are all getting what we agreed -- and more. We're just planning to not offer a particular configuration in the future (the configuration of just fresh features on a regular basis). And we issued credits to let you 'lock in' through purchase the features you were presently getting via the Logos Now subscription. So if you just left the subscription model, you wouldn't lose anything, you'd have no monthly expense, and you could still buy the new features when they shipped in upgrades. So while it's a different model (a more pure purchase model), it's not really a 'cram down' or 'punishment' forced on anyone; it's just removing the hybrid model (chosen by less than 4% of active users!) and using credits to put you back in the model you used to have, and which 96% (!) of other users were preferring already (as evidenced by their choice to stay with it, instead of going with Logos Now).
With that said, we're still re-evaluating and thinking it over... but I think the criticism as punishment/greed/etc. is a bit too far.
... but I think the criticism as punishment/greed/etc. is a bit too far.
I do too.
To Bob and the others who have worked so hard so that I can figure out Gen 1:1 (my current project) almost as well as IF I spoke Hebrew:
I have overreacted and behaved badly. It feels good to complain and pile on. You have done your best and I have piled on like many of my clients do when they don't get their way or the result they want. I am sorry.
And guys, it doesn't matter that you have spent the price of a car for the capacity to figure out what God really met when he caused the Bible to be written. Yes, it feels good to vent; but, enough is enough. You still have your car!!!!
I maintain that IF Bob can keep Faithlife healthy and chugging along (albeit with intermittent troubles) your investment will still be here a decade from now. He just assured us we will have Faithlife for the foreseeable future.
That is what we all want.
And, honestly, the Holy Spirit combined with the tools in Logos makes my Bible speak. That is priceless.
So, I am sorry. Please accept this apology. You are NOT my pastor and owe me nothing but what I have paid for.... and you have not taken anything away that I owned. In short, run Faithlife, keep it healthy and do your best. I can't and shouldn't bitch about that. If fact, I wouldn't want that job for all of the tea in China.
I am more interested in Gen 1:1 than this anyway. AND, I just used my free new (rented for 6 month) course to watch Dr. Heiser talk about Gen 1:1 in his 12 hour course on studying Hebrew with Logos tools. This course alone costs nearly $500 if you buy it and I get to use it as part of Bob's peace offering of Faithlife Connect. I think I will put that into my pipe and smoke it....cause, its a pretty good deal.
No more complaining from me.
Rob
Now: Stop Complaining, Pray for Bob and go do something with God in the 10 minutes you are tempted to devote to saying something mean on this forum. I for one am going out to swim in the Caribbean.
Good day to you Mr. Pritchett,
I hope this reply finds you well. May I make a suggestion. All the people that have been Logos Now members could be grandfathered into Logos Connect Essentials at the price they have been paying for Logos Now until such time as they no longer subscribe. It is hard to take away products at a certain price to customers and charge more than double for the same. Then all new subscribers can pay the new price.
Good day to you Mr. Pritchett,
I hope this reply finds you well. May I make a suggestion. All the people that have been Logos Now members could be grandfathered into Logos Connect Essentials at the price they have been paying for Logos Now until such time as they no longer subscribe. It is hard to take away products at a certain price to customers and charge more than double for the same. Then all new subscribers can pay the new price.
This likely won't work because Bob said in the first post...
Logos Bible Software has historically been priced in such a way that our bills are paid by book purchases; we've never charged enough for 'software' or 'features' to actually cover our costs.
We wouldn't do it that way if we were starting from scratch today, but that's where we are based on history and user expectations.
Many (but thankfully not all) of our "best customers" have built 'large enough for now' libraries, and are purchasing fewer ebooks, yet continue to want new features, and (as everyone adapts to the continual upgrade model of apps, subscription software, etc.,) they _expect_ new features more often, and at lower and lower (or no!) cost.
Dr. Kevin Purcell, Director of Missions
Brushy Mountain Baptist Association
Okay so went to subscriptions and noticed that it says that I have both Connect and Now. Now will expire Nov 2018, Connect will renew at the starter level in June 2018 at 89.99. I am so confused as that seems like double billing to me as there is less than Now in the Connect starter level that billing starts for even as have Now for another 7 months. Even if billing for Essentials started in June I would not get anything that I did not have in NOW until November when Now would be discontinued? Am missing something ? I read BOB's post where He says "So yes, since everything in Logos Now is now in Faithlife Connect (and more, of course), and since Logos Now is no longer sold separately, you could argue that we raised the price of Logos Now." There is no more in the comparison chart.???
Okay so went to subscriptions and noticed that it says that I have both Connect and Now. Now will expire Nov 2018, Connect will renew at the starter level in June 2018 at 89.99. I am so confused as that seems like double billing to me as there is less than Now in the Connect starter level that billing starts for even as have Now for another 7 months. Even if billing for Essentials started in June I would not get anything that I did not have in NOW until November when Now would be discontinued? Am missing something ? I read BOB's post where He says "So yes, since everything in Logos Now is now in Faithlife Connect (and more, of course), and since Logos Now is no longer sold separately, you could argue that we raised the price of Logos Now." There is no more in the comparison chart.???
Claude,
I'm going to parse this out a little to help you make sense of this.
1) Your original Logos Now Annual subscription would have renewed on June 8 of this year. We turned off the renewal for Logos Now completely, and then...
2) We extended your Logos Now benefits PAST June 8, so you will keep getting everything you had in Logos Now until 11/12/18 at no extra cost to you.
3) We also migrated you into Faithlife Connect Starter, effective immediately, again at no cost to you right now, so you can start getting the benefits of Faithlife Connect Starter immediately (such as Faithlife Courses, Faithlife TV, BSM Logos Editions). You will start your billing cycle for Faithlife Connect Starter on June 8 (which was when your original Logos Now subscription was up for renewal). You are being billed $89.99 for Faithlife Connect Starter, which is $10 less than you were being billed for Logos Now.
The net out is that you have access to BOTH Connect Starter and Logos Now benefits until 11/12/18. On 11/13/18, you'll only have access to Faithlife Connect Starter benefits.
Thanks followed that.
Okay so if i want essentials instead of starter I need to call in to have that change made before the renewal date.
You got it. You can do that by calling Customer Service at (888) 308-7621 or emailing customerservice@faithlife.com.
I have nothing but the highest regard and affection for Mr. Bob, and the entire Logos company. I have been with Logos practically from the get - go. Best decision that I ever made was to build my library in Logos.
I am one of those who has already bought most of the big packages of books that I really need. And I have little interest in new "features" and tools. So, I am becoming of less interest to the company.
To get me to make a major purchase, it would take new sets of books that I truly want. Those books may not be popular enough to justify Faithlife publishing them. (For example, I would make a major purchase to acquire the scholarly set of Wesley's Works that Abingdon has been publishing for about 20 years now. But, despite my pleas for years, Logos has not seriously tried to publish the set.)
But I am not an unhappy Logos customer. Quite the opposite. I am a very thankful Logos customer. I use my Logos library daily. I would make the same choice again, and I recommend Logos to young seminary students frequently. When Logos 8 comes along, I will no doubt upgrade - make that "little doubt". If Faithlife's future business model doesn't fit me, I am still a happy customer.
"In all cases, the Church is to be judged by the Scripture, not the Scripture by the Church," John Wesley
Good night, I have just receive another coupon for the same amount as last time. Best get this spent before I get another email telling me if I use it, I'll be arrested. :-)
I realize this is but a mistake from the mainframes at Logos! [:)]
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
Good night, I have just receive another coupon for the same amount as last time.
I think you'll find that the code can only be used once. Unless they sent out a different voucher code, the system won't let you use the original code a second time.
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
How Logos Now Failed
Access to new features early, as they were released, was just a little part of what we imagined Logos Now would be, which we hoped would make it more attractive to transaction users, helping them transition to a subscription world.
It worked too well, and the tail began to wag the dog. Logos Cloud didn't mature quickly enough (because it needed a stronger web app, which wasn't yet there) and Logos Now's 'new features every six weeks started to feel like its primary benefit.
New customers, who should have only needed to choose between "Buy" or "Subscribe" were regularly being sent into a very confusing, and frustrating, pitch to both buy AND subscribe. Pure subscription wasn't attractive enough (without larger libraries and a pure-web solution), but just buying and owning felt 'left out' because Logos Now offered 'new stuff without the wait.'
Worse, as the tail wagged the dog, Logos Now subscribers (who turned out to vastly outnumber Logos Cloud subscribers) began seeing the product's entire value as the regular release of new features. (Which was not the original intention.)
And trying to make a new feature every six weeks leads to smaller, less significant features just to 'check the box'. It hurts our ability to dedicate team energy to bigger features and changes that might take months to develop, but which deliver more value.
This argument fails to convince because expectation was created by the six week release cycle and the feature releases throughout the Logos 6 life cycle. "New features sooner" was promoted by Faithlife and NOW users became disappointed by the sparse features of Logos 7 releases. It now appears that FL will revert to the previous model by hitting users with features in Logos 8 whilst introducing a 'pure' subscription model with some extra, but unwanted, features. If NOW users apparently didn't appreciate the off-cycle dataset releases perhaps the dog should have packaged them more appropriately (and it appears that it is now called CONNECT). That NOW succeeded beyond CLOUD should indicate why CLOUD's successor hasn't been warmly greeted. It also appears that VERBUM NOW suits the new marketing model, but this hasn't been justified...
Users have been given 9-12 months + Logos 8 to consider their options because the marketing strategy needed that much time ("Let's scrap Logos NOW, keep Verbum NOW and hike the subscriptions"[:P]). That seems fair!
Dave
===
Windows 11 & Android 13
Worse, as the tail wagged the dog, Logos Now subscribers (who turned out to vastly outnumber Logos Cloud subscribers) began seeing the product's entire value as the regular release of new features. (Which was not the original intention.)
This is what irks me, the bolded part above - so you know darn well what customers want, but instead of finding a way to give that to them in Phase 2 of Logos Now, profitably, you hide what customers want embedded in a lot of unwanted stuff - betting customers will grumble and subscribe to what they don't want to get what they want. That is NOT customer focused and I won't be subscribing or purchasing until there is some sensitivity to what I want to buy/subscribe to.
Users have been given 9-12 months + Logos 8 to consider their options because the marketing strategy needed that much time ("Let's scrap Logos NOW, keep Verbum NOW and hike the subscriptions"). That seems fair!
I must admit, as a Verbum Now subscriber, that it works for me! [:P]
“The trouble is that everyone talks about reforming others and no one thinks about reforming himself.” St. Peter of Alcántara
A few thoughts:
1. I have never thought of getting the software for free. I thought the base package price included at least some cost for software (even if it did not cover the full development cost). When one has the option of buying different levels of datasets instead of a base package, that is surely about purchasing software.
2. It is bothersome that the standard and consistent line has been that Logos books cost more because of "value added" tagging and not that it is cover the software development cost. I am not opposed to it covering the software development cost, but why does it take this outcry of FLC to tell the truth about this?
3. I am in agreement with those that think that FL has diversified too much and should focus on its core. None of my Bible/theology/ministry professors or professors that I know use Logos. It seems to that it would be well worth FL's time to have meetings with these type of professors and find out how to make Logos appealing to them. For instance, I had one OT scholar speaking at an event and I was driving him to the event from the airport I asked him about the Bible software he uses and specifically about Logos. He does not use Logos and said that his scholar do not use because it cannot do the kind advanced search functions that they need. He has been to Logos trainings and asked about doing these searches and no one can tell him how to do it on Logos. If FL got more professors on board with its product, that would expand out to there students for years to come. (Please not that I am not claiming that no scholars us Logos).
He does not use Logos and said that his scholar do not use because it cannot do the kind advanced search functions that they need.
Exactly, there are other systems that do a far better/faster job and are far greater value if you want to just work deeply with Original languages/Scripture. What Logos excels at, and the reason I'm in it, is for the vast, well tagged and integrated, content library. That is their niche.
Thanks for the explanation. I was happy to receive an email yesterday with a generous coupon code that can be used for either Faithlife Connect or Logos 8 when it is released.
Unless I'm wrong, as a customer of Logos since version 4 who has spent more money than I care to admit ( :-) ), I will be able to continue using my desktop software as always. I can use my apps (even the online app). I can choose whether to upgrade to Logos 8 or not. I can choose to continue my Faithlife Connect subscription when my annual subscription (rolled over from Logos Now) ends in November. You are not taking away my books. You are not taking away datasets and features that I own. You are giving me a coupon to purchase more datasets or upgrades or subscriptions. Nothing that I have purchased is going away. And I choose whether to jump into the new product or not.
All I can say is, I find value in the Logos product. I will continue to choose to pay for things in which I find value, understanding that valuable things cost money to produce and the company producing them has to earn a profit in order to stay in business - even a Christian company.
Thanks for interacting here and answering questions. That's classy.
I like the idea of rental libraries that are like for like the base packages and would think it a good idea for someone else...
For the likes of me... surely all that is missing from this proposition is dynamic pricing...
Can't you just make our licenses unlock a rental price which puts us on the linked level at only $9.99 a month or $99 a year?
גַּם־חֹשֶׁךְ֮ לֹֽא־יַחְשִׁ֪יךְ מִ֫מֶּ֥ךָ וְ֭לַיְלָה כַּיּ֣וֹם יָאִ֑יר כַּ֝חֲשֵׁיכָ֗ה כָּאוֹרָֽה
We need a true 'no purchase necessary, pure subscription' product. That's Faithlife Connect, and it's a great value that offers Logos Bible Software via the web (and mobile, and even download if you want), as well as Faithlife TV, Courses, and more.
Bob, what 'industry' is this now? It seems a confusion. Bible Software is what you are good at. Do Bible Software. FL-TV -- Not only do I not want it or care about it... have you seen it? What in the heck is the software company leading the industry in Bible Software doing trying to enter the market of Amazon, Netflix, Hulu.... with a "Christian alternative"...
Logos - do what your good at. You are Very Good at Bible Software!
You are not good at TV - you won't be - you don't have enough money to be good at that.
You are not good at Presentation software - Proclaim is a mess - a terrible mess. I'll say it if nobody else will.
Your Mobile ED is fine... there are lots of free/less expensive options out there that are EQUALLY as good in scholarship and content - Bill Mounce is doing it... he is not the only one. Sure, your production level is higher quality - but not worth the money you charge for it.
I fear you are abandoning the industry you created... where is the Faithlife Podcast? Turns out... podcast is something people actually listen to... You social media presence is not creative - it is sales... boring and irrelevant.
Your Forum Page looks like a flea market with the 29 categories nobody cares about... seriously - nobody cares.
Your Beta program has become nothing but incremental bug fixes for the past 6months... For what? To work on Faithlife TV... please tell us you will abandon this. -- No one cares.
And here is the deal - if you do get good at TV... then the Bible Study Software is what will pay the price ... to the degree you succeed at TV - I predict the quality, innovation and excellence of the Bible Study Software will suffer.
How about this... SELL Your Bible Study Software to another company - if you need some cash to fund this other stuff... just sell it - let someone who cares about Bible Study Software buy it from you and then you can go compete with Amazon and Netflix and Online Universities and Microsoft Powerpoint... every other industry you are trying to dabble in.
This feels like trying to raise money for the other endeavors you are hoping will grow this business... but on the backs of people that came to you in the first place for what you do well - better than anyone.
I'm not interested in funding these other endeavors. I don't care about them.
I don't know... maybe Logos 8 is the key that unlocks all of this confusion - and it is the greatest leap forward in Bible Software since... well, you did it the last time about 10yrs ago... However, I fear it is one more iteration of dilution of why people buy and use Logos in the first place. I guess a little time will tell.
BTW - I love Logos Bible Software. I've used it for almost 20yrs now and it has been a place I've invested much of my extra money over the years. But, personally - I'm not interested in buying any of the other products you are selling... there are other and better options for those.
MacBook Pro 15' Retina • 2.7 GHz Intel Core i7 • 16 GB 1600 MHz DDR3 • Version 10.10
Bob,
I really appreciate the time that you have taken to outline FL's position and to dialog with the customer base.
As someone who subscribed to LN and must say that I am disappointed with the move to FLC. I have read through (at the time of writing) all 13 pages on this thread and I think I have to agree that the communication of this move could have been much better and also that you may have misunderstood why many of us actually subscribed to LN.
I am a pastor with a little activity in academics. As such, I am not really interested in all the ancillary programs that FL has developed. FLTV has very little interest to me, and I am fairly competent with Power Point and have no interest in Proclaim (I have actually tested it out).
Consequently, I would echo what many others have said that I am strictly interested in Bible study and research around theology and biblical studies. Because biblical studies and theology is always progressing, I will always have an interest in more books. Therefore, I wish that FL would focus on the Bible software end of things.
If I understood your points, the concern on your end is maintaining something viable as a company, and I know that you have to make your own decisions as to what that means. And maybe those of us on this thread (and the other threads discussing this move) really only represent a small percentage of your actual customer base. However, I just want to chime in that I am concerned about the direction things are heading.
I am going to try out the new FL Essentials until my LN expires and then make a final decision, but at the moment I am pretty sure that I will be deciding not to continue with it. The cost is too steep for my interests. I do appreciate the coupon and also the nine months to make a decision.
Every blessing for the future.
Not a happy camper!
I believe the initial announcement for LN was the brilliant additional features “now”.
I was a long time Adobe customer. I owned Photoshop, Illustrator, and InDesign - all very expensive programs. Then, they went subscription model and I slowly extracted myself from Adobe after being loyal and upgrading along the way to keep my software current. But I couldn’t do it every year. Some years it was not worth it.
But, now a competitor, Serif, came out with an image editor and drawing app that are much less expensive but have the features or nearly as Photoshop and Illustrator. The market dictated or allowed for such an opening.
Your new pricing model is leaving us behind. I can’t justify $240/yr to keep up. The market will now allow a competitor to occupy the spot you are vacating. I really like the Logos software. It is the best I think available. But, I feel like I am being punished for not paying enoug somehow.
If I went to my boss and said I could not afford to live on what he pays me and said I would now require to be paid 140% more, he would show me the door.
Perhaps you could offer an increase in price more incrementally. This is frankly outrageons!
I called Customer Service to set up my Auto-Renew with Verbum Now and they referred me to the Products Team at this time the Products Team is uncertain as to how to proceed with setting up accounts that do not start today. The representative said he would have to consult with his manager as to who should be handling this. It is his opinion that Customer Service should be handling this. He told me he would have to get back with me on Tues. So, the process is still uncertain at this time.
Meanwhile, Jesus kept on growing wiser and more mature, and in favor with God and his fellow man.
International Standard Version. (2011). (Lk 2:52). Yorba Linda, CA: ISV Foundation.
MacBook Pro MacOS Sequoia 15.4 1TB SSD
You are not good at TV - you won't be - you don't have enough money to be good at that.
The point of Faithlife TV isn't to beat Netflix or Amazon... it is to serve our customers in a unique way. Faithlife TV isn't yet what it will be. For one thing, the Christian content library is just beginning, and as it grows it will have content you won't find on Netflix or Amazon. Many Christian film makers can't easily get distribution on these larger platforms, and need a platform for sale or rental (or even just distribution). We're building this as a way they can get their content out.
Faithlife TV has special support for Logos Mobile Ed. It maintains your 'last read' position between Logos Bible Software and Faithlife TV, allowing people to choose the best platform for viewing while staying organized.
Faithlife TV is designed to support churches in ways you'll see rolling out this year. Churches can use it as a host for their live streaming, so invalid / traveling / sick congregants can watch the live stream on their smart TV in their living room, instead of just in a browser window on a laptop. Already you can record a service with Proclaim, and the audio will be turned into a video with your syncronized slides, and made available for viewing through Faithlife TV.
Churches will also be able to upload their own video content, allowing members and people who follow them to view their unique, in-house content on a smart TV streaming platform. (You can't do that with Netflix or Amazon.) Churches will also be able to purchase video content (small group curriculum with videos for use at home) and make it easily and automatically available to small group leaders for in-home use. No more getting DVDs to people, or having to project laptops to large screens.
(For what it's worth, we've talked with many churches that have tried big, secular solutions -- streaming video via YouTube, hosting sermon videos on YouTube or other services, etc. There are lots of problems working with organizations that don't specialize in churches: hostile people flag videos for objectionable content (when it's just the gospel they find objectionable), automatic copyright monitoring bots flag worship services as having unauthorized music because there's no way for churches to tell YouTube they have a streaming license for broadcasting services, etc.)
You are not good at Presentation software - Proclaim is a mess - a terrible mess. I'll say it if nobody else will.
I'm sorry to hear you feel that way, and would welcome your suggestions on improvement.
I also want to know if you're looking at Proclaim as it is now, or if it's been a while, because as a subscription product Proclaim is updated frequently, and it's gotten very powerful while also getting easier to use. Thousands of churches use Proclaim each weekend, and new churches adopt it daily. It's okay if you don't like it, but I hope you're looking at the latest version.
where is the Faithlife Podcast?
Just to be clear -- this is something new you do want us to get into? <smile> We do already have https://today.faithlife.com/ and https://faithlifetv.com/items/369488 with Michael Heiser... we're looking at others.
I fear you are abandoning the industry you created...
I'm sorry you feel that way. It's not our intention, and Bible software is still the heart of our business (and the biggest part of it). We're just looking for other ways to serve the Church so that we can keep growing, provide opportunities for our staff to grow and advance without having to leave the company, and to cover the increasing costs of supporting an increasingly large 'technology platform surface.' It was a lot easier when Microsoft Windows was the only game in town. :-)
Bob, You're a strong and courageous leader and I think you have demonstrated you have learned from your most recent mistake. I would like to see you reduce the time it takes to add new books and get the books and resources that have been widely requested e.g. Fire Bible, Baylor Handbooks, NET Bible 2nd Ed, Carta, etc.
Meanwhile, Jesus kept on growing wiser and more mature, and in favor with God and his fellow man.
International Standard Version. (2011). (Lk 2:52). Yorba Linda, CA: ISV Foundation.
MacBook Pro MacOS Sequoia 15.4 1TB SSD
[quote]Faithlife TV is designed to support churches in ways you'll see rolling out this year. Churches can use it as a host for their live streaming, so invalid / traveling / sick congregants can watch the live stream on their smart TV in their living room, instead of just in a browser window on a laptop. Already you can record a service with Proclaim, and the audio will be turned into a video with your syncronized slides, and made available for viewing through Faithlife TV.
That I like. My small church is mostly the elderly. Would love to have a way to reach them when they can't make it in.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
(For what it's worth, we've talked with many churches that have tried big, secular solutions -- streaming video via YouTube, hosting sermon videos on YouTube or other services, etc. There are lots of problems working with organizations that don't specialize in churches: hostile people flag videos for objectionable content (when it's just the gospel they find objectionable), automatic copyright monitoring bots flag worship services as having unauthorized music because there's no way for churches to tell YouTube they have a streaming license for broadcasting services, etc.)
I have a love/hate relationship with YouTube. Mostly hate. For example: I hate when I go to show an appropriate clip to teens and have inappropriate content either 1) shown as a link on the side OR 2) autoplayed afterwards. FLTV sounds like it has some potential!
It was a lot easier when Microsoft Windows was the only game in town. :-)
Ahem. Spoken like a true, former MSFT employee. That was NEVER the case Bob. [:P]
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
I really do not know what to think.
The above post explains why there are doing what they are doing.
We have Faithlife selling a product that is better than , in my personal opinion, the competition.
So many people complaining and some even saying we, us, or even all. I for one am glad Faithlife is there and giving us such a product.
They are a business. As a business they have contracts with other companies. The last time I checked the prices on everything is going up. Fuel was a bit cheaper for awhile. My groceries were not. Rent was not, etc. So I am going to have to assume that the prices of their contracts are going up. As with any other company the price the customer pays reflects in what the company has to pay.
They not only have contracts but all of those people to code the software. If they just offered what McDonalds pays I doubt we would have the software we have today. Those people deserve to be paid more than minimum wage.
Straight up if you cannot or don't want to be able to afford their software, stop complaining and/or threatening to go elsewhere. Just go elsewhere. Faithlife charges what they see fit. There are other options out there.
I have been following the posts and I have to say that I have been staying away from posting. All the negative comments just is not right. All the threats just are not right. I really feel sorry for those that have a question because frankly we are not Christians in the sense that we are supposed to be peacemakers. There is very little peace here in the message boards. I will never post a question on these boards, because there is a real good chance that the information will either be not complete, or it will be answered in a negative fashion.
I am like everyone else. I would like to get whatever product as cheap as possible. I am on disability, so I have to, many times, buy a product that is less expensive. I have to cut costs where I can. I will never be able to afford even what I would like to have, let alone all of it. I will purchase what I am able to afford. I thank God that he saw fit that a company like Faithlife should exist.
Thank you Mr. Pritchett for all that you have done for us.
Thank you to all the employees of Faithlife as you all have made Studying the Bible not only much easier but much faster.
You cannot assume people's tones over reading text on a forum.
Many people are concerned and this whole announcement is abrupt. People have invested a lot of money into Logos so that they even exist today. Yes, they make great bible software but Logos Now was advertised as a way for people to have features by renting and now the increase to keep features is going up a $140 a year which is an extreme increase in pricing. Not only that what is offered in the $240 a year is a lot of what people don't want and will have to pay for to continue on something similar. Yes, they have tried to compensate but it is a very dramatic increase in price.
Keith Pang, PhD Check out my blog @ https://keithkpang.wixsite.com/magnifyingjesus
I will never post a question on these boards, because there is a real good chance that the information will either be not complete, or it will be answered in a negative fashion.
Please do not hesitate to post, say, a how-do-I-do-this question. U will get polite, helpful responses. Reasking will promote the same helpful reply......I ask some silly questions + do get great responses.
Wait a week. Go back to the forums. Look at the how-to questions.
with the help of a credit.
have emailed credit (or even free Faithlife Connect subscriptions) to ensure we're taking care of people
If you didn't get an email, or think we somehow let you down, contact us. We'll make it right.
As stated here... I still haven't received the email with the coupon.
Logos 10 | Dell Inspiron 7373 | Windows 11 Pro 64, i7, 16GB, SSD | iPhone 13 Pro Max
Hi Bob,
Thank you for your full disclosure and forthrightness. That is much further and honest than most businesses would care to go with their customer base. I'm sure you're in a difficult place and this stings just as much for you as it does for your customers. Change is difficult.
I would have to say that it's quite unfortunate that not enough customers were able to signup for LN. Both for the customer base and FL.
In my opinion FL is going down the road they need to go. I have not used and do not care to use the web based app at this point. However, I can see that in order to remain relevant and affordable to a (potentially) larger user base (revenue stream) FL has to provide a more attractive pricing model to a newer generation of believers and students of the word. That is your future and if you fail to execute the transition the business will not survive. While I may not like it personally I applaud you and FL for not shying away from attempting to make it happen.
I'm in the group who have made a significant investment in resources but have not added significantly to that investment in the past 2 years. I, like others, appreciated the LN subscription as it made sense. A couple of reasons for not purchasing more resources. 1) I don't need a significant number of new resources at this time, and 2) My primary device is an 8 inch Windows tablet and with a large library I cannot realistically add many more resources and have everything still run on the tablet due to space constraints.
I can understand those who are upset and unable to afford keeping up with feature set upgrades in new releases. I'm not in the financially struggling category although many of the Logos users in my circle of friends are in that category so I really understand their frustrations over what appears to be unnecessary features and services.
I think what I hear you saying Bob is that the FL Connect pricing point of ~$20/mo is what would work for customers like myself and FL to be in a win/win situation with feature set upgrades paying for software development costs. I just checked on my price to do a feature set upgrade on my Ultimate Collection and it would be around $2,500. Even if major releases of the software occurred every 3 years, my math shows that $720 is less than $2,500. Even though I don't like paying an extra $11/mo it is still a bargain in comparison to purchasing the feature set upgrade. And, for myself, I can actually afford to pay it.
There are two things that, in my opinion, would benefit everyone going forward. (I'm speaking of the core bible study product, not the extras such as FL TV. I have never used the extras so I don't have an opinion of them)
1) For those who can afford it, and are in a situation similar to mine, let's get behind this change and signup for it. If FL can succeed in getting the software into the hands of a new generation, using whatever (subscription, rental...) model, we all benefit. The more we use and support it the more can be invested in it. For those of us who are already LN users we are paid for already on FL Connect for the next 14 months, I believe, plus Bob sent us all credits to help in purchasing feature upgrades.
2) I would love to see some kind of special pricing for those users who have been around for a while (nice way of saying older like me) and have made a significant investment in resources over the years. That way they can keep up with new features in an affordable way. Some of these believers are those who could benefit the most and provide the most benefit and blessing to those they minister to.
I know the second item would be the most difficult to implement. There would need to be a way of determining who qualifies and not everyone would be happy in the end but the other side is that those who know the software best and could use new features and upgrades the most are stuck on the outside looking in because they can no longer afford it.
If there is a way to do it I will return the credit sent to me so someone more in need could use it to purchase a feature upgrade. Others probably have some better thoughts about how to help FL help all of us make it through this transition so that we all benefit. I do believe it would be very helpful, for those of us who are able, to signup for FL Connect and fully support FL as they work through this with us. The transition is definitely painful for many but in my opinion absolutely necessary for all of us to come out on the right side of things.
Thank you for listening,
William
I think what I hear you saying Bob is that the FL Connect pricing point of ~$20/mo is what would work for customers like myself and FL to be in a win/win situation with feature set upgrades paying for software development costs. I just checked on my price to do a feature set upgrade on my Ultimate Collection and it would be around $2,500. Even if major releases of the software occurred every 3 years, my math shows that $720 is less than $2,500. Even though I don't like paying an extra $11/mo it is still a bargain in comparison to purchasing the feature set upgrade. And, for myself, I can actually afford to pay it.
I am wondering how you came up with a Feature set upgrade price of $2500. It looks like the List Price for the Starter Feature Set is $199, the Full Feature set is $599, and the Extended Feature Set is $799 when I look it up after logging off my userid to avoid it showing my dynamic pricing which is substantially less.
I was using this page https://www.logos.com/compare/feature-sets to look up the feature sets.
I thought that the feature set list prices were independent of the collection that you have. I could be wrong... Paul
Hi Paul,
I guess I was confused and used the price for upgrading the Collectors Edition base package to v7. The $2,500 is the dynamic price for that upgrade. My bad. Thanks for pointing that out.
As far as the Extended Feature Set I'm seeing $879 instead and on sale for $679. I don't see the $799. Now we are closer to $740 for 3 years.
Maybe someone from FL can comment on and clarify on pricing for the extended feature set.
Seems closer to a wash depending on how one values the extras and on the actual cadence of new releases. It could still be a bargain without the extras if the release cadence is closer to 2 years.
Although we don't know the actual launch date for Logos 8 it's been less than 2 years since Logos 7 launched. The cadence between Logos 6 and 7 was slightly less than 2 years.
Based on release cadence of closer to 2 years I would still hold my position that FL Connect is a bargain for those who can afford to update their feature sets and want to pay less than purchasing to own. Although you could also argue that since the difference is less maybe it's better to purchase to own. I believe though we would be helping FL more by subscribing since they would have a somewhat more predictable revenue stream vs. not knowing for sure what percentage of installed base will purchase the upgrade with each new release until it comes out.
Thanks again,
William
It's important for everyone to realise that once you have a full feature set, upgrading to the next one will probably cost less than a Logos Now subscription. I had the Logos 6 Feature Set (or whatever it was called then), and buying the Logos 7 Extended Feature Set only cost me $70.21 on a 50% off Black Friday deal.
As Logos upgrades tend to happen every two years, that's a lot cheaper than the $200 I'd have paid for Logos Now over that same time.
I obviously have no idea how much I'll have to pay for the Logos 8 feature set, but I'd be surprised if I have to pay more than $200.
This is my personal Faithlife account. On 1 March 2022, I started working for Faithlife, and have a new 'official' user account. Posts on this account shouldn't be taken as official Faithlife views!
I have a question that I looked to see if someone else has posted yet but I couldn't find anything. I am a current Logos Now subscriber that was automatically mapped to the Connect Starter subscription. After looking the Starter subscription over I have no real interest in it, however I might I have an interest in the Connect Essentials subscription. My question has to do with how Faithlife addresses the overlapping of a Logos Now subscription with an Essentials subscription. My current Logos Now subscription doesn't expire until May and in the interim if I subscribe to Essentials it feels like I would be paying twice for the same benefits since Logos Now is essentially a subset of Essentials. Has Faithlife addressed this scenario?
Hi Bob,
Here is a thought for FL to consider for those who signup for FL Connect at any subscription level.
Give a dollar for dollar credit for each month they are signed up for FL Connect to be used towards purchases to own such as new resources or feature set upgrades. It would basically be like paying in advance for purchases and building a credit to be used anytime desired. It couldn't be used towards subscriptions or anything considered rental in nature.
This would give incentive for purchasing to own while at the same time helping those not inclined to subscribe to get on board since this would in effect help in keeping up with feature set upgrades for each successive release. This would offer value to those who currently see no value in FL Connect vs. purchasing feature set upgrades only.
Doing something like this might put subscriptions over the threshold where FL would be sitting on a nice revenue stream while incentivizing purchases at the same time. Anything purchased above and beyond the credits would be a win for FL in my opinion.
Just another thought to help us all.
Thanks again for listening,
William
Doing something like this might put subscriptions over the threshold where FL would be sitting on a nice revenue stream while incentivizing purchases at the same time. Anything purchased above and beyond the credits would be a win for FL in my opinion.
I hope they hear you on this. My biggest concern is that the current subscription plan discourages purchases of the Standard library and discourages those with the Standard library from joining FC. They should to be finding ways to encourage all purchases. I'm holding out that when Logos 8 launches the new libraries will include something unique for the subscription.
After reading pretty much every post in every thread on this issue, and after further reflection, here are my current thoughts:
1) Connect is not a replacement for LN and never should have been implicitly positioned as such by automatically migrating people to one level or another in Connect. Bob's explanation clarifies that from FL's perspective, LN failed; and they went back to the drawing board for a new subscription model. The automatic migration contradicts Bob's explanation re. LN. If FL had simply given people a credit for the amount they had spent on LN and explained up front that Connect's target market is brand new Logos users, I suspect a lot of this drama and churn would have been avoided.
2) Mostly as a matter of curiosity, but partially as a matter of understanding Bob's comments, I'd love to know what portion of the $240/yr for Essentials is for benefits other than the core Logos application. Clearly they cost something, so after subtracting them out, whatever's left has to be in some way related to the "cost of doing business" to keep the core Logos application moving forward. FL / Bob don't owe me that, for sure, so I'm not expecting that level of detail. Just stating my interest in that detail...
3) Related to whatever that number would be, I have to wonder how FL's competitors can remain viable and profitable at < $100 / year upgrade prices when Bob says FL can't. As I said before, I'd pay ~$100/yr to know that I always had the latest features (including datasets), irrespective at what pace those features happened to be released. What I'd like to avoid is a new major release dropping and having to spend hundreds of dollars in one shot to get the latest features. But I think that's what I'm facing (albeit with a $200 credit the next time it happens).
My (most recent) $.02 ...
Donnie
Okay Have been making my way through the wilderness and just when I thought I made it out I fell into a hole. FLC says that have access to T&T Clark Johannine Studies (10 vols.), but having tried the online app to no avail. How do access the collection without outright purchase? Any clues ? By the way only two days left...
Okay Have been making my way through the wilderness and just when I thought I made it out I fell into a hole. FLC says that have access to T&T Clark Johannine Studies (10 vols.), but having tried the online app to no avail. How do access the collection without outright purchase? Any clues ? By the way only two days left...
I answered in the other thread as it seems more appropriate over there. But you should be able to see those books.
Have joy in the Lord!
3) Related to whatever that number would be, I have to wonder how FL's competitors can remain viable and profitable at < $100 / year upgrade prices when Bob says FL can't.
FL has over 400 employees. I believe Accordance is around 50 (according to glassdoor), and OliveTree was around 20 when they were acquired by HarperCollins. They don't have to sell as much software to support their respective organizations. It's also possible that they're willing to "stay in their lane" while it looks like FL has more ... ambition.
I suspect what happened is that Logos went through a period of exponential growth when they offered deals that were too good to be true (e.g. the Christmas sale of 2011). That's what got me on board. That growth has probably slowed, but the growth of business expenses rarely slows, so now they probably have to fight for every penny that used to roll in easily.
Bob, Ok I get it. Subscription services are the new thing. I am seeing it everywhere and it is a good way to keep all the content updated and keeps down IT costs dealing with people that have issues because they didn't upgrade 5 upgrades ago. I wasn't happy with the change. I subscribed to LOGOS now to get the new features in advance and, I did like the free book every month as well. I did not use it for the Web app or any of that because the web app was no where near robust enough for what I do with the software on a regular basis. I am dealing with this change in model with another software I use all the time where the owners are not updating the legacy software because they are trying to cater to all they customers with a web app that isn't there yet. I also hate shelling out the large yearly subscription fee on this stuff every year. First it was office, then my recipe software, now faithlife and Logos. But, I do understand. I have not been buying nearly as many books as I have in the past simply because I do not currently have large funds to further invest in my library, and a lot of the resources available do not fit, my conservative, theology.
So, I just have one more question. It is unlikely that if LOGOS 8 comes out before the middle of next year, that I will be able to upgrade, at least right away. So, I used the coupon to get the feature set and lock those in, but here is the question, since I will lose my LOGOS NOW subscription and may not be able to upgrade to LOGOS 8 right away, will I lose access to those features until if / or when I either choose to upgrade to LOGOS 8 or pay the higher subscription price?
Just wondering.... will there be a discounted way to obtain those features when LOGOS 8 comes out without having to spend over $200 to upgrade my base package?
Thanks, Carla
On the positive side I can appreciate the feedback and "justification" for switching from one product line to another...related to profitability. I can also appreciate ownership expressing their editorial view on how the product will change for the better in the future. Yet I recall numerous times that FL and its products is a business and is in the market for profit. What strikes me is how in the lengthy sharing by ownership is how any of this is either my problem or my concern...it's the free market at work. Another way of saying it is when a business screws up it's their problem...grow to fast...offer meaningless product lines...lose money...forcing endless software gimmicks on customers who may not enjoy them...just the way it rolls in business. In the end, FL live or die, it just doesn't matter to me since I use other true bible software for my needs. The only thing I would miss if FL disappears due to business mistakes will be the minor monetary investment ($1800.00 or so over 20 years) in Logos. It's just business.
Just wondering.... will there be a discounted way to obtain those features when LOGOS 8 comes out without having to spend over $200 to upgrade my base package?
Carla,
What I would do is wait to buy the features until Logos 8 is released. (You can call Customer Service and ask to return them). You will have your credit to use when Logos' pricing will be their best - at the release of the new software. Many of us think this will be in October or November of this year.
You are a Logos Now subscriber. You will have access to all the features until November regardless of when your renewal date is. There is therefore no need to buy the feature set now.
You never have to pay to upgrade the software. So you should be able to buy the feature set when Logos 8 comes out using your credit. Should you want to buy an upgraded library, that will cost extra.
Pastor, North Park Baptist Church
Bridgeport, CT USA
Good explanation! The new Faithlife Connect cloud service will work well for those who need the software for a short period of time, those who want a cheap up-front software, or those who will be long life costumers and are used to having cloud subscriptions.
With this next generation that loves changes and getting new software updates, it makes perfect sense! Subscription based payments are the best way to pay for changing software. I am still a little old school (millennial) , so I like to own my stuff, but I do think it meets the needs of another audience.
Thanks for the explanation! Keep up the good work.
Sorry for disappearing after a flurry of responses... I feel like I gave the best explanation I could, though...
We are still listening, and we're considering ways to change this plan to address the feedback you are giving us. Despite our (many!) mistakes and mishandled communication, we are always listening to and considering your input, because you are incredibly important to us and the reason we are here: to serve you.
Please give us a few more days to work out some alternate plans before you lose our number / abandon ship. We want to retain (or regain) your trust.
-- Bob
With respect this is one of the most convoluated emails I have ever read (especially from a company). I was trying to buy or subscribe to LOGOS for to give to a friend (and I by change found these comments).
Having spent over $2,000 dollars on books - I am afraid they will be gone someday. I hope when 'whatever changes comes along (or Faithlife goes out of business or gets merged - there is a procedure to download all our books to our computers (and have a desktop program) to do searches, etc.
I'll wait and see what happens - so today I bought $50.00 of real books for my pastor, and $200.00 of real books for me. I might not be able to search them - but I sure own them.
I hope things work out. I would suggest a 'strategic planning session (1 or 2 weeks) - make some decisions - and then announce them. Included will be a 'download option' and a reader that will stay with us forever'. Maybe we have that now - but I'm not sure.
Maybe Jeff at Amazon will solve the problem and buy Faithlife. I'm sure it is less expensive than Whole Foods, and will fit in with Kendell.
Welcome to the forums Jerry! [:)]
Included will be a 'download option' and a reader that will stay with us forever'. Maybe we have that now - but I'm not sure.
I am not sure what your question or statement is... but this already exists. The Logos engine is free (and will always be so) and you can "download" your books. If I am missing something in your question, please create a new thread and we will be glad to help.
Another problem is too many options. When I start to buy something - I call or chat with a rep - and end up more confused then when I started
One of the big reasons for this change is indeed to "simplify."
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
Having spent over $2,000 dollars on books - I am afraid they will be gone someday. I hope when 'whatever changes comes along (or Faithlife goes out of business or gets merged - there is a procedure to download all our books to our computers (and have a desktop program) to do searches, etc.
Welcome [:D]
Thankful for many friendly forum discussions: have learned a lot plus have a lot to learn. Thankful for Faithlife restructuring Logos Now for future users while taking care of existing customers (as technology transitions).
Thankful Faithlife applications for Windows and Mac do download all library resources, which needs internet connection for sign-in and download. After library is downloaded, indexing is done locally on computer, which is useful for searching. Also program settings can be changed to disable internet connection, which is useful when internet is unstable or not accessible. Logos wiki has => Online Only features that require internet access. For offline application search, larger library allows more relevant articles to be found.
Thankful visual filter highlighting that can combine hundreds of searches for simultaneous display works when offline: e.g. thread => more inductive symbols
Keep Smiling [:D]
After several days of reflection, I too think that I over reacted to the initial news regarding Logos Now.
I get it that Logos Now is no longer a viable option. I understand that Faithlife connect is an entirely new offering. I appreciate the coupon code so that I don't lose any features.
My only real beef is with how this was communicated. After all, the very first email I received about this said, "LOGOS NOW IS NOW FAITHLIFE CONNECT". This is a long way from clearly communicating what was really happening - that one program was going away, and something entirely new was being offered.
I apologize for the tone of some of the emails which I sent Faithlife. I do believe, however, that given the way this was communicated there was a lot of fertile ground for misunderstanding, and many could be forgiven for thinking that they were going to be charged more than double to keep the features they already had.
Logos Now clearly IS NOT Faithlife connect, even though that's what the email subject line read.
I purchased L7 Lutheran Portfolio, L7 Gold, L7 Platinum, L7 Anglican Bronze, L7 Full Feature set, and the V7 Full Feature set. Along with a bunch of Misc. items. Bought all that at 4 different times. So looking at my order history L7 Full Feature set cost me $133.87 before the LN discount. The V7 Full Feature set was $1.18 before LN.Afterwards realizing I bought quite a bit, I looked into the LN discount. I Realized it would be cheaper if I called in and had my Purchase Recalculated. So I bought LN. Then Logos recalculated everything. So the price of the full feature set with LN of $105.25. Not sure what happened but they decided it would be best for me if they refunded everything and do it over. After the refund I got the list of new to me, since I had L6 and V6 with all crossgrades, the list only showed things that are whats new to L7. Since Both L7 and V7 were both refunded and repurchased together, I didnt have an easy way to figure out What was new to V7 full Feature after purchasing L7 Full Feature. But if I remember correctly it was only 2 or 3 additional things which cost me 84 cents. In Dec last year, after my LN was expired, I purchased the "Logos 7 Essential Upgrade, Large" for $102.31. In doing so I have the complete L7 feature set, not LN, along with a few books and journals. So even taking the LN discount away, and after having the full L6 and V6 with all crossgrades, the grand total was $237.36 to have all the features (and a few books and journals). And since I have Logos version 7.13 they are updating feature set.
So even though the prices are different depending on how much you have to catch up in the first place, it may be cheaper to just upgrade the feature set if you already have a large library, and are not interested the the features of Faithlife Connect.
Yes they can also change the price of the feature set upgrade, but still it could be cheaper than the overlap with Faithlife Connect. Since they are even giving you credits for LN and 9 month notice, I am totaly confused with all the anger and resentment.
I hope that maybe this will help some in making a choice on which way to go.
God bless.
I received the news about Logos Now and Faithlife Connect at the end of last week, and I wanted to wait and prepare a response concerning it after I had a chance to read through other customer’s responses and Bob’s response, as well as spend more time researching and reflecting on Faithlife Connect in order to offer as objective of a response as possible. I didn’t want to issue off a short, heated response after only initially receiving the “shock” concerning the announcement.
A few words of note before I wade into this. I’ve been using Logos for years (I started on LLS 2.x and went through Libronix and “Series X”, version 3, version 4, 5, 6, and 7). I endured the painful “Logos Mac” transition of the past, as well as I upgraded to Scholar’s Silver, then Gold on Logos 3, then Platinum on Logos 4. My L4 Platinum upgrade was $400+, Platinum 5 $500+, Platinum 6 $600+, and Platinum 7 $700+ (even as Logos Now member and only buying the Platinum library, in which I had some of the high-end books in there). Each time I upgraded to a new version of Logos in a decent time frame, even with the increasing upgrade costs. I currently have 9,213 resources in Logos, and since Logos 4 (where all my purchases were registered to my Logos.com account), I’ve spent $14,110.64 in sales. I spent a ton of money with Logos pre-Logos 4 (I have enough Logos CD’s to be used as coasters for a good size church gathering if I wanted to). I signed up for Logos Now when it was first offered and kept it, and I even signed up for Logos Cloud when it was first offered (which I only canceled after Logos phased out the plan I was on). I’ve heavily promoted Logos throughout Bible college and seminary and pretty much ran on it for years. I’ve always been eager to invest in Logos even if it put me at major odds with my family. I’ve purchased and read through Bob’s books and have been willing to continue to invest heavily in the Faithlife/Logos ecosystem over the years and be as much of an ultimate Logos fan as I could. I’ve spent more money in Logos than I ever have on a car.
Additionally, one critical note I’ll make up front is with regard to the new product icons Faithlife is using (I was going to mention this in another thread). The new multiple shades of green behind the app icons is hideous, and with my vision problems, actually makes me dizzy. I wish Faithlife would have sticked with a solid shade of green for the app icon backgrounds moving forward.
In terms of Faithlife Connect and Logos Now, here’s my thoughts on the situation:
With that said…
I read over the Faithlife Connect announcement email, as well as spent quality time on the Faithlife Connect website comparing the tiers and reading up on Faithlife Connect in general. After looking over the various tiers and reading over the Faithlife Connect announcement email, as a longtime, loyal customer, essentially I felt as though Bob and the Faithlife marketing team included a picture of themselves “waiving” at us in an unsightly manner. Learning that in November, I would be automatically moved to a plan that didn’t include all the features of Logos I had under Logos Now unless I wanted to upgrade to an annual price increase of about 140% that also included subscription access to books I already shelled out over $700 for (which the collection included additional resources as well) literally had me double over in stomach pains. I’m not sure if I’ve even physically recovered from it. The way the email was announced and marketed and communicated did not seem as though Logos Now was being “retired” and that Faithlife was rolling out Logos Connect as a new subscription service. It was marketed and communicated in a way where Faithlife seemed to transition customers onto a subscription service more than double the price and with overall not as good of value as Logos Now. Simply put, the way Faithlife handled the marketing and communication, no matter the coupon or the extension, it felt from a customer point-of-view as a classic “bait and switch”. The way Faithlife handled the communication of the Logos Connect email was received by us as a “We’re not pleased with the amount of money we’ve been getting out of you each year for your Logos Now membership. We’d rather move you to a new service that already includes the resources you’ve spent hundreds of dollars with us and chase you 140% more if you want to retain all of your existing Logos features, plus with overall fewer perks than Logos Now”.
In terms of Logos Now itself, I read Bob’s response, and if Logos Now was never intended to primarily be a membership for customers to gain access to the latest Logos features on a regular basis, then someone has slipped something into the marketing teams food during the marketing stages of Logos Now and for the past couple of years. That’s exactly how Logos Now was marketing and communicated to customers: the ability for customers to receive access to the latest Logos features on a regular basis without having to wait for a major Logos upgrade and shell out a hefty upgrade cost in a Logos feature set. Even the branding “Logos Now” reflects this. Logos Now also included an additional discount toward the purchase of a Logos 7 library and allowed for Logos Now members to purchase a Logos 7 library only without the features. These discounts helped offset the fact that there couldn’t be true “dynamic pricing” for Logos Now members in terms of features (although my upgrade cost to a Logos 7 Platinum library itself was $700+ with my Logos Now discount and only buying the books, more than I ever paid for previous Logos upgrades before Logos Now). The free books and free preview resources, coupon codes, Faithlife TV access, etc., were nice perks but not essential. I didn’t use Faithlife TV as much as I thought I would, and I generally forgot to look at each month’s preview resources. The coupons were nice, but only enticed me to spend more money with Logos than I likely would have.
In terms of the six-week feature release schedule, I was never a fan of it. While it’s fine for Faithlife to offer general updates to Logos every six weeks, especially bug fixes, the six-week feature release schedule was a headache for me, one I even complained about on the forums. I felt that Faithlife was rushing features out the door too quickly, some of them half-baked, and some of them degrading the quality in my Bible study experience since they weren’t ready yet (I noticed Logos actually getting buggier at times). Even as a Logos Now member, I would have gladly continued my membership for a major release of new features on an annual, semi-annual, or quarterly schedule (even an annual schedule would have satisfied me, although I know large organizations who ship high end software and subscription services that run $100,000 for the up-front cost and $2,000+/month for the subscription afterwards, and they generally released new features on a quarterly schedule).
In terms of Logos Cloud, it wasn’t marketed or communicated well. Instead of being marketed as a “web based version of Logos”, it should have likely been marketed as the Logos version of “Office 365 Desktop” with beta access to the web based version of Logos (in case the web based version didn’t quickly get up-to-speed with enough features). While the original Logos Cloud plans were confusing for base package owners, I found enough content in them I didn’t have to justify the $20/month price, as attempting to purchase the resources I didn’t have on there on a monthly payment plan would have ran much higher than $20/month). Under the new plans, they align with Logos 7 libraries which makes logical sense, although since I have a Logos 7 library already, essentially I’d be paying for the identical resources I’ve already invested in hundreds of dollars in along with overall not as great of perks as was on Logos Now.
I read carefully through Bob’s explanation of Faithlife Connect versus Logos Now and the logistics of it. I compared it to reading through some chapters in Bob’s business book, as well as my past upgrade history with Logos and how Logos has marketed and communicated each of its product and service offerings in the past. I’ve even had communications with former Faithlife employees in the past over some of Faithlife’s communications issues. Needless to say, Bob’s answer doesn’t feel fully transparent, and I’m not fully sold on it. I don’t know if I’d call it “greed” as some customers have. “Desperation” somewhat comes to mind the more I sit back and ponder watching Faithlife and Logos over the years. I feel like I’ve been on a sinking Titanic in which the captain keeps asking me to plug up the holes in the ship with money. There’s a few core issues I see with Faithlife and Logos, and I’ve tried to mentally bury these over the years in my dealings with Faithlife and Logos, but the incident with Faithlife Connect crossed the line where I can no longer suppress them:
In terms of my standing as a Faithlife/Logos customer, after thoroughly pondering the way Faithlife handled the marketing and communication of the Logos Connect transition, here’s my response moving forward:
A few months ago, I had a feeling that the Logos 8 marketing and communications rollout would be as complicated and confusing as it was in Logos 7, if not more confusing. I actually put together a marketing and communication plan for Logos 8 that is so clear for the customer’s standpoint and that would have made the upgrade process go so smoothly, that Faithlife would have had the upgrade go off without a hitch and make a ton of money out of it. I waited to send it over to Faithlife to review, but since it is so clear and understandable and so simple, I’m not sure if Faithlife could mentally grasp it. It’s not confusing, complex, and complicated enough for Faithlife’s marketing and communications teams. Bob and Faithlife’s marketing teams have my customer information on file, so they know where to reach me if they want it.
This isn’t a total “goodbye” of myself and Faithlife and Logos, but I’ll admit my faith and confidence is shattered enough in Faithlife and Logos where the only way Faithlife and Logos is going to wake up, streamline, simplify, focus on core markets, cut the fluff, improve marketing and communications, and improve customer service is when there’s a major impact to its bottom line.
Dr. Nathan Parker
Nathan, I wish you could have gone into a little more detail.
Thanks for tuning in this week to "The Parker Factor". Catch more analysis each week! Check your Faithlife forum listings. ;-)
(With all the disgruntling and upsettedness going around, I thought I'd throw in a little humor tonight).
Dr. Nathan Parker
Perhaps what can be done is a system where users can purchase individual features on an alacarte basis. This is so that users do not have to wait for the next major release for new features. Faithlife can continue their ongoing development work and users can pay for the features that they really want, this allows faithlife to get some revenue for the features that they create. The prices for those features can be slightly more expensive if bought individually as compared to when the major releases come out.
OK, when I first got the email from Faithlife, I shot off a couple of "Hey I'm confused" emails to customer service and kept telling them they were not answering my questions about having to pay double for the same features. Eventually, one of them sent me the link to Bob's response. After a few days of reading the other posts and mulling it over, I have decided that it wasn't that big a deal after all. Yes, the communication was poor and could have been much more deftly handled, but I am not a born communicator and if God held me accountable for all my communication gaffs, I would have no chance at salvation. Here are my conclusions, take them for what they are worth or thumb your nose at them...
1. If, back in 2013, when I first invested in LOGOS, Faithlife Connect Essentials for $20 a month was offered, I would have probably jumped at it rather than investing what I thought was an exorbitant sum in Logos. I have Music Unlimited from Amazon and don't buy CD's any more, I have reduced my print library from 8 floor-to-ceiling bookcases to two, mostly books that I have trouble finding electronically. So, I think it is a good option for those that want it.
2. I love Logos Bible software, and while I have only been with it since version 5, it does keep getting better. I have spent at least a new car's worth of money on it over the years. I hope Bob maintains the option to own and upgrade our libraries every few years. While I may not want to keep upgrading from say Gold where I am now to Platinum, I have a great interest in feature enhancement collections and sermon archives still. I am also addicted to study Bibles. So, as long as they keep the purchase and own model going, I'll probably keep investing in it, although maybe not as much each year as in previous years. I will use my coupon when Logos 8 comes out for the new feature set, and, if my Logos Now subscription ends before 8 comes out, I will probably take Faithlife Connect Essentials for the few months in between and then drop it.
3.I own Accordance, Bible Works, Quick Verse, Word Search, Sword Searcher and Bible Analyzer. I still do most of my work in Logos, although, I like the maps and timelines in Accordance better, and WordSearch has Instant Verse Study feature which I absolutely drool over, SwordSearcher has great Word Cloud feature that allows me to create a Word Cloud on any portion of scripture and instantly see what words and themes are emphasized based on the size of the word in the cloud. They all have features and unique resources not available in other libraries and platforms, but the one I would be most loathe to give up would be Logos and this kafluffle hasn't changed that.
4. I tried using the cloud last night, and it is still not there in my opinion, though a lot better than the last time I investigated it. It doesn't let me use my custom layouts, the parallel resource sets don't work the same way, and aren't defined the way I have them defined in the software. When the cloud first came out I was excited because sometimes I wanted to study on my lunch break at work and it just wasn't there. Now, I possibly could if I wanted to do so.
Bottom Line, nothing has changed and Logos has been good to me over the years when I have wanted to make returns or had issues, so I think, all in all, I will upgrade every couple of years to at lest the new features and maybe sometimes, to new books and libraries, and hope against hope that I die before Logos does. LOL
Take it for what it is worth, which isn't much.
Bob, I am apologize for my initial reaction. I trust you will learn from this and do a better job of communicating the next big change that comes down the pike.
Carla
here’s my response moving forward
Bob said, "Please give us a few more days to work out some alternate plans before you lose our number / abandon ship. We want to retain (or regain) your trust."
We might want to wait to hear what FL will announce before making any decision(s).
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
I wonder if Bob ever feels like moses trying to lead the nation of israel?Bob said, "Please give us a few more days to work out some alternate plans before you lose our number / abandon ship. We want to retain (or regain) your trust."
We might want to wait to hear what FL will announce before making any decision(s).
I'm glad my church members aren't as whiny as I've been.
L2 lvl4 (...) WORDsearch, all the way through L10,
Instead of the marketing email that was released, it would have been better Bob would have drafted up an email that had been released to customers telling us up front that Logos Now was becoming an issue for Faithlife to maintain (especially on its current feature release schedule), that it would be completely retired, offering us the $100 coupon as a means to “give us back the cost of our Logos Now membership” that could be put toward a Logos feature set to “permanently buy the features we had in Logos” (as well as mention it could be used for either Logos 7 or Logos 8, and for those with a Logos feature set, it could be used for any Logos.com purchase), as well as mention that Logos Now would go through early November. In the same email, Bob could have mentioned that Logos Cloud has also been an issue for Faithlife to continue marketing in parallel with Logos Now, and that Logos Cloud would be morphing into a new offering called Faithlife Connect. It would have been made clear in the email that Faithlife Connect as a re-brand of Logos Cloud (not Logos Now) is a subscription version of Logos that costs more for the complete Logos feature set and includes resources customers may already have in a Logos 7 library. Therefore, while Logos Now members would be invited to take a risk-free trial of Faithlife Connect in case it would be a good value for some, since Faithlife Connect costs more than Logos Now for features that include Logos 7 library content, it may not be the best option for many current Logos users, and if it isn’t, customers can transition back to the traditional purchase method, while being encouraged to share Faithlife Connect with new Logos customers. Had that been the case, I’d already be promoting Faithlife Connect to friends of mine who aren’t Logos users yet.
The last few days, I've been thinking along very similar lines. Doing something like this would have gone over a lot better and avoided this most recent trainwreck. Bob, I assume, has paid marketing staff to come up with roll-out plans for him. No sympathy for them is forthcoming if customers in their spare time can figure out better ways of doing it. They shouldn't need a week-later "Oops, let's try this again" do-over after every major change.
Brother, I fear you may have forgotten (or simply glossed over) the "why" behind the initial implementation of Logos. You hinted at it in your long response but quickly moved on to other things. I have been with Logos since its Libronix days (and physical backup CDs of our entire libraries), making my first purchase from you roughly around 2003 (11 years after you created it - yes, I know).
The point that I'm trying to make is this. The reason that I got on board back then and continued to invest was because I believed that there was a future to digital tech, and lo! and behold! I was right (one of the few things I have ever gotten right). Back then, you weren't trying to get perpetual customers forever; you were trying to convince people like me and others that we should build digital libraries and not physical libraries - or at least consider supplementing our physical libraries. Now let's stop and think about that model - which, by the way, worked just fine: If I am investing in a physical library am I always going to be adding to it at the same rate? Answer: no. Not at all! You wouldn't expect that. If one is a student for life, the library will keep growing bit by bit for life. The beauty of the physical library is that once you retire are facing death, you can will your library on to your family, or to a church. I know that you have worked a little bit toward that (though it is far from satisfactory, seeing that it stops after one gifting). I don't want to digress too much, but the point is that there are many of us (I don't really know how big your customer base is, but I know quite a few people in a similar boat to me) who have literally spent, not thousands of dollars, but tens of thousands on Logos - I know that I have. And all of that has been without a subscription that I don't need or want.
Do you know what I want? I want my library. The amount of money that I've spent, I would think that you would be happy that it has funded you to this point. But let us reason together on this, you can't expect me to continue to spend at rates that I once did when I was initially building my library, can you?! If a new volume is added to a set that I like, I buy the single volume. These days I'm very picky about what I buy - mostly monographs anymore. But I was just the intended demographic of your initial startup. Don't throw me and everybody like me under the bus because you don't have the revenue stream that you think you need. We want our libraries and we will continue to invest in them. What you need to do is not to dream up new ways to get us to pay you more when we have invested thousands, if not more; no, you need to ask yourself if that is still your model - attracting library builders - and figure out how to get more.
Maybe the building that houses your office and staff doesn't need continual upgrades; to be bigger and better every couple of years. Maybe it's time to recall that this initial project was borne out of a desire to help those in the ministry, not necessarily to make you wealthy. Listen, I don't begrudge you the profits that you have made from my purchases or anyone else's. You have a good product and I thought it was worth the money, so I bought it - that's how the system is supposed to work. But now, you're changing all the terms on the old guard.
People aren't buying books like they used to? No - your client base is getting older and we all have most of what we would like, just like I do with my physical library - yes, I still have one and am growing increasingly glad of that fact every day with the depressing changes that Logos rolls out every few months. But, we're still buying. What you need to focus on is getting new people to invest in these libraries just like we did. It isn't going to come from having a subscription plan the costs hundreds of dollars every year.
Marketing 501
I teach a graduate level - "Strategic Marketing Management' course that begins next Monday. I'm going to use this thread and example as a case study. I'll approach it from a neutral position and let the students do their own analysis.
I'll just post notes - without names - for them to view.
Wow - is all I can say.
as a side note. My confusion has always been - and I also go 'way back' with several thousand dollars invested - is there are too many names, and options. Make it one name - one website - with different product offerings.
I have a nice library - and it will take me 10 lifetimes to read what I have. I enjoy LOGOS, and add books from time to time, but don't want to subscribe to 'anything'. Who can keep up with the subscriptions? I found a charge on a credit card of something that I thought I quit a longtime ago. SO i've been paying $9.99 a month for almost two years.
Netflix, Microsoft, Hula, Grammarly, Screen Castify (there the best - they have a reasonable price). I'm going to get one credit card that expires every year and put all my subscriptions on that card. Then I will be reminded every year - 'what's going on.
Brother, I fear you may have forgotten (or simply glossed over) the "why" behind the initial implementation of Logos. You hinted at it in your long response but quickly moved on to other things. I have been with Logos since its Libronix days (and physical backup CDs of our entire libraries), making my first purchase from you roughly around 2003 (11 years after you created it - yes, I know).
The point that I'm trying to make is this. The reason that I got on board back then and continued to invest was because I believed that there was a future to digital tech, and lo! and behold! I was right (one of the few things I have ever gotten right). Back then, you weren't trying to get perpetual customers forever; you were trying to convince people like me and others that we should build digital libraries and not physical libraries - or at least consider supplementing our physical libraries. Now let's stop and think about that model - which, by the way, worked just fine: If I am investing in a physical library am I always going to be adding to it at the same rate? Answer: no. Not at all! You wouldn't expect that. If one is a student for life, the library will keep growing bit by bit for life. The beauty of the physical library is that once you retire are facing death, you can will your library on to your family, or to a church. I know that you have worked a little bit toward that (though it is far from satisfactory, seeing that it stops after one gifting). I don't want to digress too much, but the point is that there are many of us (I don't really know how big your customer base is, but I know quite a few people in a similar boat to me) who have literally spent, not thousands of dollars, but tens of thousands on Logos - I know that I have. And all of that has been without a subscription that I don't need or want.
Do you know what I want? I want my library. The amount of money that I've spent, I would think that you would be happy that it has funded you to this point. But let us reason together on this, you can't expect me to continue to spend at rates that I once did when I was initially building my library, can you?! If a new volume is added to a set that I like, I buy the single volume. These days I'm very picky about what I buy - mostly monographs anymore. But I was just the intended demographic of your initial startup. Don't throw me and everybody like me under the bus because you don't have the revenue stream that you think you need. We want our libraries and we will continue to invest in them. What you need to do is not to dream up new ways to get us to pay you more when we have invested thousands, if not more; no, you need to ask yourself if that is still your model - attracting library builders - and figure out how to get more.
Maybe the building that houses your office and staff doesn't need continual upgrades; to be bigger and better every couple of years. Maybe it's time to recall that this initial project was borne out of a desire to help those in the ministry, not necessarily to make you wealthy. Listen, I don't begrudge you the profits that you have made from my purchases or anyone else's. You have a good product and I thought it was worth the money, so I bought it - that's how the system is supposed to work. But now, you're changing all the terms on the old guard.
People aren't buying books like they used to? No - your client base is getting older and we all have most of what we would like, just like I do with my physical library - yes, I still have one and am growing increasingly glad of that fact every day with the depressing changes that Logos rolls out every few months. But, we're still buying. What you need to focus on is getting new people to invest in these libraries just like we did. It isn't going to come from having a subscription plan the costs hundreds of dollars every year.
Well said. Over the last 22+ years I have strategically grown my library along the lines of what interests me. I have taken advantage of the free book of the month and the old Christmas specials and even bought the Bronze then Silver base libraries. My library additions have slowed down as there are fewer books that interest me. I would love to upgrade to Gold or Platinum but I simply don't have the funds these days.
I'm just a lay person and now I am retired. Me needs have changed as have my means. Connect sounds like a good way to lure new users but time will tell. It just doesn't fit me. No hard feelings and no animosity. FL probably didn't convey the message as well as they should have. But the package that they provided us - coupon, keeping our Now subscriptions active until November+ and the Connect subscription roll over - were all first rate. For that I am thankful and will remain a loyal Logos user even if I don't purchase much going forward.
Nathan Parker said:
It was marketed and communicated in a way where Faithlife seemed to transition customers onto a subscription service more than double the price and with overall not as good of value as Logos Now. Simply put, the way Faithlife handled the marketing and communication, no matter the coupon or the extension, it felt from a customer point-of-view as a classic “bait and switch”. The way Faithlife handled the communication of the Logos Connect email was received by us as a “We’re not pleased with the amount of money we’ve been getting out of you each year for your Logos Now membership. We’d rather move you to a new service that already includes the resources you’ve spent hundreds of dollars with us and chase you 140% more if you want to retain all of your existing Logos features, plus with overall fewer perks than Logos Now”.
I completely agree.
However, what I said previously concerning my feedback concerning marketing future versions of Logos is still sitting in my brain. I'm willing to post it publicly right here on the forums for everyone (including Bob) to read so at least I as a longtime Logos customer can help become part of the solution.
Does anyone want to hear it?
Dr. Nathan Parker
Does anyone want to hear it?Nathan, the Minimalist. Of course I want to hear what you have to say!!!!!
I'll probably post it this weekend or next week. I've found a few ways to make it even simpler (but not any shorter in explanation). :-)
I'll be glad to post it though so that Faithlife can read it as they plan for Logos 8.
Dr. Nathan Parker
I'm wondering...
Back when this originally happened, Logos Now was discontinued. Verbum Now wasn't.
What if the REAL reason for this was the marketing teams had secret plans to bring non-Catholics back into the Catholic church by having us all switch to Verbum Now? Maybe a secret plan to bring everyone back into the mother church? ;-)
Dr. Nathan Parker
As a recent purchaser, who had considered the option of LN, I would have to argue that this not only undermines my willingness to "subscribe"; but also makes me question whether I did the right thing in ordering a base package at all. I would expect that, like me, most users of the Logos system are into a product that allows one to perform technical exegesis, better, faster, and more thoroughly.
I would also like to say, many of the extras (T.V., ebooks, ...), really make me wonder at whether or not there needs to be a streamlining of development. I would be willing (and consider) subscribing to something that gives the ability to do better, smarter, and faster technical work, and perhaps improved datasets or discounts. But, I am also a Logos user for the sake of Logos, not of T.V., groups, or web-apps.
The point of this is to say, I would wonder if many of the user base really has a need or even a desire for many of the things that Faithlife offers. (If I wanted church media, I could probably get a better, more professional, and more useful set of stuff from Sharefaith -- with more usefulness, particularly to the kind of church I attend and am most likely to attend and/or lead). I have always understood Logos to be a research system focused in Bible study and theological research (the "package expert" guys sure push it as that kind of a product!) . I would expect that the best way to add value -- and spend the man-hours involved in programming -- would be to focus the majority of the work on that aim and end.
Further, as far as the features are concerned, the 'great new features every six weeks is something I've never heard: I have most certainly missed that memo (and/or the hype). I studied programming as part of my undergraduate degree, so I have an idea what programming is like -- granted nothing as major as Logos. And, from this standpoint, things like Vyrso scare me -- because I would have to expect that (supposing Logos is programmed in something of an object-orientented, and some (probably more recent) version of an MVC paradigm (Of course it is!)) the Faithlife developers must either develop an entire new program around a very limited core library, so that a full-featured engine and user interface has to be written and updated from almost scratch (thereby sinking developer hours into, not only writing new apps, but also the libraries, interfaces, and bindings that work with them, which is expensive and time-consuming); or (which, given the integration, is what I suspect) there is a need for a basic API that re-focuses one or two MVC frameworks (like Logos and Proclaim), into any number of different applications -- which, if I remember my programming studies correctly, is one of the major benefits of developing software in a modular, object oriented way; but doing so could also be bad for performance, as optimizing the code for different features becomes more complicated, as code in the engine may have to be tested in different additional ways; and there are additional clients that must be handled, which must be dispatched at runtime (one of the ways of optimizing software is reducing the indirection involved in these kinds of calls -- especially if they occur frequently), and, possibly, the need to develop wrappers and adaptors and interfaces that allow for the function of libraries to be extended into new use cases for new features. (The benefit, as far as I can remember, of modular and polymorphic programming is not to have the same Logos app repackaged into 4 different forms; but so that controller code doesn't do unexpected things to the state of the model if the end user does something 'unexpected'; being able to handle unexpected and erroneous 'events' intelligently; and so that the logic behind particular features can be added, updated, and changed, with a bare minimum of change to other parts of the program, so that the program can be more easily maintained, enhanced, and updated.) This makes me wonder, whether or not there are either (1) features and optimization that are not the best they could be, because what should be concrete is abstract or polymorphic, or involving extraneous function calls, which does take away runtime; or what model and controller code could be improved by not having 4 different viewers; or (2) what features don't work as well as they could, or aren't built distinctly for a technical study and research platform, because they have to interface with 5 different (expensive to develop and/or maintain) software components, which also effects the available functionality and ability for new features to work natively within an app. In short, programming is a tough job, and I have to wonder if Faithlife is over-extended.
Yes, I can agree that 'great new features every six weeks' is amazing, and, having a very small taste of the effort and thought required to write quality programs, I would not be surprised if it were very difficult for developers to maintain that kind of release schedule for all but the most trivial of new features. Yes, it is difficult and expensive. And it requires updating techniques, libraries, and compilers quite often. And commercial compilers and IDE's, too, can be expensive. And decent development libraries are expensive, and sometimes can be licensed on a per-instance basis, which makes development of a commercial program more and more expensive. And developing a major commercial program across two different platforms requires investing in development tools, training, and commercial libraries for not just one, but two different platforms, which makes the development all the more costly. And developing free versions for mobile platforms may also require different programming skills, commercial licenses, and possibly paying for the app to be included in the store.
So, I am not surprised to see that different companies need to balance their cashflow with subscription pricing. I can understand the need for having new avenues of income. And I can probably expect that this cashflow becomes largely prejudicial to faithlife, when many of the business tools that you use every day may or may not have moved to the cloud and incur ongoing costs when they may have previously involved one-time costs. As I said, I would consider subscribing to something that truly enhances my ability to study better.
However, I can also argue from my experience as a person who has spent my entire adult life in the study of Christian theology and of the Bible, that I find many of the products offered unhelpful. I find that the "package expert" guys are some of the best experts of the hard sell, which I consider to be impertinent to a Christian company, and often overvaluing the product. I find that, while there is focus on training, much of the focus is not on showing me how what I have now can get the job done in better ways; but in convincing me that I need just that little bit more -- whether or not I actually need it (I have to confess, that I am one of your costumers with a 'good enough for now' library with few exceptions: I purchased a base package at my level with that particular intention) -- which I find to be neither virtuous nor helpful; and that these changes in branding are not pertinent to me, but are just plain distracting; and are not at all related to the reason I purchased Logos: to be able to study Scripture better, more thoroughly, and more easily. I have looked at Vyrso on several occasions, and I have found the available content lacking; The sermon editor seems to be more suited for a Proclaim power user and Bible study leader than someone who wants to have a tool integrated into *Logos* that helps with developing _sermons_. It seems almost unsuited to a person who will never want proclaim (and would likely find different options if he did) (the page describing it advertises a feature to develop sermons and Bible studies *quick and easy*; most pastors would recognize, however, that there is more value in outlining, drafting, and brainstorming tools (both for study and for the actual message) than in media production tools; propositional outlines (although, one would wonder if that is something that would be better provided as a diagramming/outlining module, than in pre-written outlines of bible books (especially for the textual or thematic preacher)) notwithstanding.
Logos Now was something I was considering subscribing to, especially if it would bring with it better access to support (I find Morris Proctor's work to be very lacking), and considerable discounts to allow me to add more to my library once I can and/or need to. I believe I understood the product right: additional features, unavailable to other Logos 7 users; access to the web-app without subscribing to cloud; and the ability to upgrade to the new version before others, with discounts on version 8 base packages.
Now, with *cloud* and the web-app, I can see where the confusion may arise. I am also confused, though, on why I have been prompted to buy a base package after I bought a base package. I find faithlife TV to be questionable (are you really trying to compete with Netflix-like streaming services, as a Bible study company!?); and often find most video productions from evangelical sources lacking in quality. I might consider a subscription that would allow me to download("own") an extra some-odd Logos resources per month, but I have to say, I am likely not going to find the new ebook service to be that much improved over the selection of Vyrso, which I also found to be one of the least capable eReader apps available. As an existing Logos costumer, I am also confused about whether or not FaithlifeConnect is offering me access to Logos, Logos cloud, or additional features/resources in Logos (or Bible study on the Web?)! On the one hand, this scheme reminds me of the online Christian bookstore, of which I am a preferred customer, wanting me to pay $5 per month, in order to receive discounts -- even though I prefer my books in e-edition -- and then sending me endless catalogues advertising mostly junk and trivia whenever I place an order. If I wanted to go broke buying endless books that look good, that is a good thing; If I want to build a library to help me study, then it is counterproductive and distracting. That is an unfortunate but irritating side of ordering from that company. (One would also have to wonder how many people pay that $5).
So, if there is a likelihood that (like, I will perhaps need to focus at some point on original language and/or Baptist resources) this subscription will give me tools to build a better research library, or to use it better, then I will consider it carefully. If it will give me the ability to invest more to get more tools, to make better use of my library, then I will consider it carefully. But, *Faithlife* products? and a "research library" consisting of (access to) mostly products that I either already own, or of which I have no need at this time? (I actually had considered Cloud Premium or Pro as an alternative to Logos, but decided my base package is more cost effective -- I found the resources available at the lower levels to be, well, trite). Well, the issue of buying v licensing web-based products is confusing, I'll admit (since, in reality, I probably do not actually "own" my library, but a perpetual license to it) -- but, this is why I say, that I would be interested if there were considerable discounts on future *Logos* _purchases_ (without the "package expert" people) to allow me to develop my library further when I can and need to. But, looking at the TV site, I come to suspect, that you are, again, not developing a tool for serious technical/pastoral Bible study, but engaging in a market of Church and Christian content consumption -- possibly trying to compete with the likes of Facebook and Netflix -- which is distracting to me, is often prejudicial to the ability to really focus on study and reading, and leaves me wondering how much value I am loosing from my significant investment in a base package because of these ventures which are largely superfluous to my needs; and perhaps how much it will distract from being able to invest further in my library on the Logos platform according to my needs, or whether the focus of the company has been moved from developing the kind of quality that is advertised and promised, to developing these devices and innovations, which are of no real or lasting value to the Logos platform, and require me to navigate through a stream of campaigns and advertising intended to sell me effective junk, while convincing me of the increased value thereof.
So, no, you killing Logos Now. But you are removing anything of interest, and focusing the subscription on what seems to me to be superfluous, which is irrelevant to the product I purchased from your company; you do not place a decision before me to either subscribe or own features and/or resources; you place something which, whether I choose to subscribe to it or not, already means that the value of my software is considerably diminished from what it could be; and you need me to subscribe to something I have very little need or want for, in order to help fund further development on a piece of software for which I am already heavily invested; and where much of my investment is not going to developing features, or helping to create more value for my Bible study platform, but to things for which I would expect that your more serious and loyal costumers have little need or use: just consumption.
I would, also, have to ask whether or not this 'tail wagging the dog' is a 'failure' of Logos Now; or whether a hard-sell, over-committed software company, while spreading itself too thin, is unable to actually guide its costumers (and, perhaps, even provide them with) the products that actually meet the needs of its costumers, but trains and pushes sales to the point that many costumers who ought to consider cloud essentials end up with both base packages and subscriptions. I would wonder if the absence of a promised cloud app is indicative of a lack of focus of development and support for the reason Logos exists, and the reason that most costumers will ever use Logos; and if many of the transaction people felt left out, because they felt pressured from an over-extending sales team to buy and subscribe to more than they need.
As a recent purchaser, who had considered the option of LN, I would have to argue that this not only undermines my willingness to "subscribe" ...
I didn't read your post beyond the first paragraph (I'm sorry) but in case you weren't aware of the new developments re: Logos Now and Faithlife Connect, here is an update thread: https://community.logos.com/forums/t/160830.aspx
If Logos Now is continuing in the form of Faithlife Connect (No Library), then why are there people on this thread deciding to transfer to Verbum Now? But thanks for making my point for me: navigating campaigns and hype for divergent products that are superfluous to anything I will ever need.
Do I need media packages? well, I would love the kind of media that helps me understand the Bible better; and, perhaps, lots of it: but not that projector stuff. And, even if I did, there's Graceway, and Sharefaith, and both those companies make better stuff than the Faithlife media stuff. Do I need ebooks? well, yes: but there's already a company out there that does that: lot's of them, in fact. Do I need to distribute my sermons to shut-ins? well, there's sermonaudio (and sermon central, ...). Do I need Christian documentaries? well, it could be useful. But I could also pester my church into subscribing to RightNow Media if I actually had a need for that.
It is also disturbing to me that one of the in-house Ph.D. scholars-in-residence who produces Lexham imprints for Logos (like the interactive media and Lexham books included in ALL base packages) produced a documentary on aliens and demons. And, that Faithlife has decided to feature it on the new Faithlife Connect TV site. This makes me wonder if many of the resources I depend on in my Reformed Portfolio base package is on the level of 'God and Jesus are aliens' type scholarship. Considering that this is from a company that advertises 'premier' Bible software, this is HORRIFYING! It also makes me wonder if FL is so unable to see and produce quality, that they will make a product that is on the level of the National Inquirer rather than the New York Times. Since there seems to be a tendency to replace standard scholarly works with Lexham imprints, this causes me to loose very much confidence, not only in my own software package, but possibly anyone who regarly uses these resources. Is the Dictionary of Bible Themes such a product with a National Inquirer level of accuracy? If so, that could have eternal consequences.
So, yea, it might be like being grandfathered into a LN++ type of product. But wouldn't a LN++ type product be focused on LOGOS users (not TV, VYRSO, PROCLAIM, CLOUD, GROUPS or the FSB, BUT LOGOS)? Woudln't the point be to invest in LOGOS?
But, my point isn't that I feel left behind. My point is not that I am confused. My point is that it is two different animanls. It is two different animals, where, every time one of these animals pop up, Faithlife has to develop a new vision, marketing campaing, training campaign, programming, and find the people who need it. But, those people are usually going to be Logos costumers who need Advanced (premier?) Bible study software.
My church uses facebook to connect with people: so, I can see a use for a social network (I probably won't use it, though) that isn't an advertising platform. Or, maybe, one where prayers and Bible study are able to be well integrated into the service (that could be great for a church prayer ministry!). But do I really want my BIBLE STUDY SOFTWARE company to spend money and time on investing in that kind of platform, and then spend more time and money advertising on how it can be employed as a general, but half-baked, tool for church management? Do I want to roll it out in my church, when doing so also means that my BIBLE STUDY SOFTWARE company is, perhaps, not advertising the answer to your prayer(tm) to anyone stupid enough to post [personal] prayer requests on social media; but, instead, is advertising half-baked, half-functioning Bible Study cloud software to my church because Bible study is Quick and Easy(tm) with that cloud app we still can't get just quite right, because we're spending too much money putting our own Facebook together? Where will this end. Will FL have its own, in house, market to buy comments, likes and views? Maybe I can one day post something on my Faithlife page (Again, I would probably use blogspot, ... if I needed a blog) and pay to have some number of people 'amen' or 'I'm Prayin'' it. But, all this ... from the producers of PREMIER BIBLE STUDY SOFTWARE!?
Marketing, and advertising, and business costs are real. And they mean that a company can only do so much. If that company wants to produce 12 different products, well, then, they often have to commit R&D, and programmer time, and marketing research, and training their sales people, and writing up informational stuffs, and other significant investments in time and money and other resources to EACH product. Faithlife can't decide that they will focus on Logos and then Proclaim is going to take care of itself. Nor will the campaign for the next Quick and Easy(tm), Awesome(R) feature for a faithlife product just materialize without effort. They have to have very significant investments to the development, research, and marketing of EACH. The Sermon Editor will neither write itself, debug itself, market itself, or even upgrade or improve itself!
A company can't wake up in the morning, decide it's going to be the leading Bible software producer in America, and then sell movies. If a company decided that they want to produce books about the Bible, movies, podcasts, (and a dating website? ... really? wow, that's dumb.) then that company has left the Bible software market almost entirely. It may be the leading Christian content distributor (for now), but there is a NECCESSARY adjustment to the commitment to produce software. So, it can produce the most content, and mediocre software; it can corner the market, so that you're not a Christian without it: but the best Bible software will always be somewhere else. In order to be the leading (premier?) Bible software producer, it is neccessary to have a commitment to developing, innovating, and improving content and tools to make that program more useful to both old and new users.
Someone said that Mr. Pritchett (forgive me if I mis-spelled his name) is a fan of Jeff Bezos. Well, Amazon has the monies in reserve of a small nation, and operates with a very thin profit margin. But they can do that, because they are also large enough to keep the Post Office going. I doubt that Faithlife has that kind of money, manpower, or even costumer base. And the fact is, however many books I buy from Amazon, they only care about the sell: they don't care about whether I get any benefit out of it or not. Even if I buy something I hate, it's no skin off their back whether I ever look at it again. Or even, if I think a physical kindle is one of those odd-looking ephone-ey thingies!
And programming is a difficult job. You don't just look at a computer and tell it to, "instantiate this data-structure template class for any number of instances of various types, that implement interface i." It requires coding, testing, debugging, alpha-testing, beta-testing,... writing Library code, controller code, model code, building a GUI, and making those pretty little pictures we call icons. It is very time-consuming. Faithlife is not Google. They are not Apple. They are not Microsoft. They don't have all the information in the world(tm) stored on their servers. They don't make their own hardware. They don't have endless developers lined up in giant departments to develop software that most people could never live without(R). They may be larger than I expect. But wouldn't it make sense, that in order to do something that will remain premier, they must focus on what they do? (I think someone complained about that, too).
Have you looked at the paper feature in Accordance 12? or the Dynamic Interlinear? Have you looked into the Instant Verse Study feature in Wordsearch? These are products that are developed by companies that focus on Bible Study, and they provide products that focus on Bible Study and Research, and making sure their products fit into the workflow of their costumers as seemlessly as possible. So all the features focus on Bible study and resarch, and doing it the way it is best. I don't have Accordance 12, But I wouldn't be surprised if the Paper feature is oodles more useful to my workflow and sermon writing than the Sermon editor ever will be: I don't have proclaim. If I did, it would suddenly become the absolute best tool for building quick and easy(tm) messages for proclaim. So the end-result is a product that is well-focused and consistent, without plugs for other products that company makes (Paper focuses very closely on the needs of what an Accordance user has in STUDYING the BIBLE, because there is no Accordance Proclaim. Proclaim may be a very good product (and perhaps it is); it may even be the best out there (it's not. . .), or the most affordable (again, . . .)), but (1) I am investing in a "premier" product that is supposed to make MY workflow easier, not Faithlife's, or that which Faithlife hopes I buy into (sorry:subscribe) to do quick and easy(tm) work on largely half-baked stuff; and (2) Even if I could get FC for free, it's not something that helps me use LOGOS Better, or STUDY MY BIBLE better. It is a range of products that one can easily find elsewhere, usually better.
The point is that Logos prides itself on being premier Bible study software. Not a decent, professional-grade Bible study software that can interact with its own, in-house, facebook; or its own, in-house Netflix; or its own, in-house, PowerPoint; or, even, its own, in-house iBooks: but a premiere Bible study program that MAKES THE PASTOR'S WORKFLOW EASIER. Will a premiere product come from an unfocused company, and where my investment in this product seems to very heavily imply that I must buy (I'm sorry: subscribe) into a largely superfluous FL World? How does that largely superfluous FL world help to develop PREMIER (not decent; not half-baked, but with lots of promise and potential) Bible study software?
Or, better, do I need to move to use competing products in order to have the kind of features, stability, and performance that would come from a company that DOES produce premiere software? I would expect that it is better to produce the software that anyone knows is the best, so that much of the marketing comes from the product's reputation. I would expect that a better corporate environment would be focused on handling costumer needs, rather than pushing sales and subscriptions. And, I would also expect that a company that wants to maintain good relations with its costumers would pay VERY close attention to communication. I may have purchased my base package recently, but I have followed many of these development since L4. And, well, Faithlife lacks focus. And clarity. And that lack costs me features, speed, polish, resources, and possibly even innovation, training, and developer time and resources in order to pursue that next BIG feature, to bring that next BIG hype; or the next faithlife product that hardly anyone knows about, or even cares.
If Logos Now is continuing in the form of Faithlife Connect (No Library), then why are there people on this thread deciding to transfer to Verbum Now?
They are not! You aren't reading the thread in context. Check the dates!
I see that you are new to the forum. Welcome! [:)] One suggestion: I would try to keep your posts short & concise, else your posts will fall to the TL;DR (Too Long; Didn't Read) syndrome.
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
It is also disturbing to me that one of the in-house Ph.D. scholars-in-residence who produces Lexham imprints for Logos (like the interactive media and Lexham books included in ALL base packages) produced a documentary on aliens and demons. And, that Faithlife has decided to feature it on the new Faithlife Connect TV site. This makes me wonder if many of the resources I depend on in my Reformed Portfolio base package is on the level of 'God and Jesus are aliens' type scholarship. Considering that this is from a company that advertises 'premier' Bible software, this is HORRIFYING! It also makes me wonder if FL is so unable to see and produce quality, that they will make a product that is on the level of the National Inquirer rather than the New York Times.
I can't see that anyone addressed this concern of yours in the forum, but I think that it is SO important, that I'm going respond and stand up for Mike Heiser (and by extension, FL's reputation). I haven't watched said documentary, but have seen the splash screen and can understand why, without knowing anything of its content, or of Mike Heiser's ministry of scholarship, you would think it is wacko fringe material. But having read Heiser's book The Unseen Realm, listened to several of his podcasts, looked at his websites, and watched some of his videos on Youtube, I can tell you he is a solid scholar who in fact considers it part of his ministry to reach people who believe the wacko 'God and Jesus are aliens' type stuff. (I have a close relative who is one!) So my advice, my brother, is to check it out before dismissing him and all of Faithlife with it. You do yourself a disservice, and border on slander of Heiser who is a defender or our faith. Here's a few links to help you see what he's about. You may find his research into this stuff helpful if you ever have to talk to someone who is terribly confused by it all. (They are a hard group to reach because they really want to believe it.)
Ancient Giant Skeletons - Are Giant Skulls and Cyclopes Real or Myth?: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1zaqu3srBwc
Ancient Astronauts Debunked: https://www.ancientaliensdebunked.com/
Since there seems to be a tendency to replace standard scholarly works with Lexham imprints, this causes me to loose very much confidence, not only in my own software package, but possibly anyone who regularly uses these resources. Is the Dictionary of Bible Themes such a product with a National Inquirer level of accuracy? If so, that could have eternal consequences.
I have found the Lexham Bible Dictionary, and Lexham Theological Wordbook to be solid resources that do an excellent job of condensing down large topics to the most important and crucial details. They've become my first stop when I need to get up to speed quickly on something. When I do further research in other standard resources and am able to compare, I do not find Lexham to be shoddy or inaccurate in any way. Just the opposite.
This change is welcome by me, personally. I am not opposed to a subscription model, but it seems unlikely the resources I am interested in will ever be available via one (at least for a long time). It's one thing for a company to move to a subscription model, it's another thing to convince publishers to make their products "subscription" products instead of buy-to-own.
I prefer to have a small library of resources I know well and use frequently than a large library of duds and overlaps; and, like many, I'm most interested in commentaries, which will always be the "premium" resource. As long as I can still buy these and use these (and am never in danger of losing them) I am happy. Since the one thing that could hurt me most is Faithlife going out of business, I am happy your are doing whatever you need to stay afloat.
Personally I hide all videos and interactives. They are completely useless to me. Datasets and interlinears are great. I also use collections and guides (my own custom passage guide). That's my product usage. So from my perspective, I would rather less money invested in flashy features and videos, but if that's what the new generation and new customers will pay for, then it still benefits me (indirectly). I just hope you've read the market correctly and the investment doesn't turn into a loss.
Josiah: This is interesting to me. I would think it would be easier to get publishers to accept a subscription model. If they could figure out a way to do it like Apple music. Whenever a resource is used a monthly report sent to the Faithlife will allow that publisher to get some money for each use. Also, they could negotiate with Faithlife to allow the newest resources to only be subscription.
I am upset because the Faithlife connect just doesn't seem like that good of a deal if you really only want to use Logos and build a great library of resources.
Josiah: This is interesting to me. I would think it would be easier to get publishers to accept a subscription model. If they could figure out a way to do it like Apple music. Whenever a resource is used a monthly report sent to the Faithlife will allow that publisher to get some money for each use. Also, they could negotiate with Faithlife to allow the newest resources to only be subscription.
I am upset because the Faithlife connect just doesn't seem like that good of a deal if you really only want to use Logos and build a great library of resources.
I thought the same thing when it came to publishers. The only drawback to subscription models is while the royalties are ongoing vs one time, generally the royalty payments are far lower than the cost of direct-purchase or especially bundle items (as one who has a music album and have watched the royalty payments come in over sales vs subscriptions, subscriptions are a fraction of the payment over direct sales. However, more overall customers listen to my music over streaming vs direct payment so they can "take a chance" on me, so I wouldn't reach as many audiences nor would I overall see as my royalties without the subscription model).
The FL Connect Essential (No Resources) solution that Bob offered to grandfather LN customers into for $99/year is a good option for those wanting all the Logos features without the books (even the price for new customers seems overall reasonable). I get all the features of Logos and LN, plus some additional perks. Some of the perks I haven't had time to heavily use yet (such as streaming much on FL TV), but it's nice to have them if I need them, plus periodically I can leverage these additional perks to benefit my studies.
Dr. Nathan Parker
Josiah: This is interesting to me. I would think it would be easier to get publishers to accept a subscription model. If they could figure out a way to do it like Apple music. Whenever a resource is used a monthly report sent to the Faithlife will allow that publisher to get some money for each use. Also, they could negotiate with Faithlife to allow the newest resources to only be subscription.
I guess we'll see. I'm sure the NICNT/NICOT will be available there any day now. And a bunch of Brill journals...
Honestly, I'm not an industry insider, but I don't think anyone in the music industry is rejoicing over this great era of Apple Music and Spotify, etc. I think they would gladly take the next time machine to the 80s. I don't really listen to music anymore, but I'm pretty sure most artists view such streaming avenues simply as advertising for their concerts.
I guess academic biblical studies writers could move in this direction, but I'd rather they get to stay with their families, and be able to spend time researching and writing instead of flying around the world just to read their journal articles out loud.
I am upset because the Faithlife connect just doesn't seem like that good of a deal if you really only want to use Logos and build a great library of resources.
Hmm, maybe I'm misunderstanding something. The way I read it I have no real reason to use Faithlife Connect, which is great, because now my monthly costs go down and I have more money for books. Whereas before there was incentive to use Logos Now to access new features (for example: the discourse analysis tools are great for reading original Greek and they might have been Logos Now only (I can't remember)). Since Faithlife Connect provides nothing I want, it seems an infinitely better system than Logos Now, which often seemed like a better option than purchasing a feature set to go with your library.
But here I might be confused. Sometimes I read quickly and miss the finer details.
I don't think anyone in the music industry is rejoicing over this great era of Apple Music and Spotify, etc.
Smaller labels might, especially if they end up being featured.
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
I may have missed an email about this as well as others. I used to pay $100 a year for Logos Cloud. Not it's double the price? What about a discount for those who had Logos cloud for 1 year so we can see the new features?
Hi Todd,
If you had been a subscriber to Logos Now, and then stopped, you may not be eligible for the deal that Mike links to. I think you'd need to check with customer services to ask them whether they're willing to let you in on that deal.
If your subscription hasn't lapsed, then you should have been automatically moved to that deal.
This is my personal Faithlife account. On 1 March 2022, I started working for Faithlife, and have a new 'official' user account. Posts on this account shouldn't be taken as official Faithlife views!
Chris,
I think I got pretty much what I was promised....
I know that I have sent two inquiries to customer service asking what software functionality (excluding stuff like free books and TV) I will lose if I return the recent Connect purchase and buy the full Logos 8 feature set.
I haven't gotten any response other than a confirmation that I can return the Connect purchase. It would be nice to know this answer. It the answer is nothing then they (Faithlife et al.) have for sure kept their promises.
Really not happy with what was promised and now has changed ... I feel you took advantage of my subscription commitment.
Chris, I assume you are a Connect Essentials subscriber. If so, are you aware that you can purchase an L8 base package without the feature set with a 30% discount as a Connect subscriber and continue your Connect subscription? If you are a Connect subscriber you should have received an email with a link to update you to L8 immediately at no cost.
Pastor, North Park Baptist Church
Bridgeport, CT USA
Wow Bob I cant believe this. I have been with Logos since the late 80s with cds. Then moved up to internet downloads and now 30,000 dollars later am here. This Christmas the updates came out no one said a word to me that the essentials was going. If I had known it would have helped me in my decision to up grade. One morning I will get out of bed and logos 9 will be out and I am stuck paying upgrades, that is what happen in the past. I am 30,000 dollars into this, all by myself floating. It would be nice to be updated when you do things like this. I think you have my email.
Welcome to the forums Don. Just checking that you know the thread you are responding in is an old thread. What are you actually responding to - email? purchase options?
Orthodox Bishop Alfeyev: "To be a theologian means to have experience of a personal encounter with God through prayer and worship."; Orthodox proverb: "We know where the Church is, we do not know where it is not."
hi MJ, Thanks for the headsup. I didn't know it was a old thread. I am always 5 or 6 steps about what is going on with logos. They never seem to tell what they are doing and iam mopping along trying to keep up. It really dosent matter, thanks again for letting me know. I think they are getting to big and little guys like me don't matter, even thou I have over 30000 dollars invested.
I think they are getting to big and little guys like me don't matter, even thou I have over 30000 dollars invested.
Who are the "big" guys? [:^)]
They never seem to tell what they are doing
Communication from FL can certainly be challenging at times, but most of us complain about too many emails from FL. Have you checked your settings? Do you have email going into a spam folder?
In any case, what is your primary concern? MJ tried to get you to explain, but you still haven't. You wrote:
This Christmas the updates came out no one said a word to me that the essentials was going. If I had known it would have helped me in my decision to up grade. One morning I will get out of bed and logos 9 will be out and I am stuck paying upgrades
Why do you think "essentials" is going away? Perhaps you subscribed to an annual subscription and it has run out? As for as I can tell, it is still available as a monthly or yearly subscription:
macOS, iOS & iPadOS |Logs| Install
Choose Truth Over Tribe | Become a Joyful Outsider!
1. Thank you for sharing. I understand the financial issues. I don't think this is motivated by greed.
2. $100 (or even slightly more) was/is okay. $240 is way too much. The inevitable comparison is going to be to Office 365. Logos Now/FaithLife Connect doesn't offer anywhere near comparable value for most people.
3. Logos is becoming bloatware. Many of us want powerful Bible software, which you have created. Many of the same people are not at all interested in all the other extras--courses, TV, etc. We want to be able to keep our software updated and nimble at a reasonable cost. $100 a year was reasonable for that. $240 is not. $90 is not reasonable for a greatly diminished alternative set of features.
4. Thank you for the coupon, which mitigates the sting a little bit. I'm going to use mine to buy a Logos 7 feature set to "freeze" my present configuration. I will not renew my Now/Connect subscription, nor will I buy any other subscriptions you offer in the future. When Logos 8 rolls out, I will think very long and hard about whether I really need it or if it is just the start of another lap on the treadmill. So, from me this year onwards, instead of $240 or $100 in subscription revenue, your going to get $0. I'm sure I'm the only one who is change purchasing habits like this. I don't see how this change benefits either customers like me or FaithLife.
3. Logos is becoming bloatware. Many of us want powerful Bible software, which you have created. Many of the same people are not at all interested in all the other extras--courses, TV, etc. We want to be able to keep our software updated and nimble at a reasonable cost. $100 a year was reasonable for that. $240 is not. $90 is not reasonable for a greatly diminished alternative set of features.
I completely agree. I think that this new business idea is about as good an idea as when you guys wanted to get into the online dating business.
The online dating business idea sounds more appealing now than this subscription based software service. LoL!
I've been thinking (since last year) about building my digital library with another company when Logos 8 rolls out.
PS: Apple had decided to offer new features less frequently so that they can focus more on software Quality. Why can't Faithlife do the same?
(Continued.)
5. I am very concerned about the well-being of FaithLife. I want you, and my library, to stick around basically forever. That this move is considered necessary is somewhat disturbing.
6. The rollout of this change was terrible. That's kind of the default for FaithLife. You really need to look into why that is the case.
We hear this criticism with almost every significant announcement. (I hear it internally when we make internal announcements.)
It could be you're right, and we're just incapable of communicating clearly... :-( It's a hard problem -- if you just put something out for discussion casually, you don't have the details and specifics that people immediately want to understand it. If you put out the details and specifics, people complain there was no warning.
This time we put all the information together, prepared specific "your individual situation" emails for everyone, and designed it to take nine months to actually change anything (other than giving you new stuff for free immediately).
Yes, I suppose we could have just put a "Here's what we're thinking...." label in front of it... but in many ways this IS the pre-announcement. (While we think the plan is done, it's also nine months from full implementation, which is plenty of time to gather feedback and make necessary tweaks...)
I will say to you Bob, that I seriously appreciate the coupon sent this way. You didn't have to do that but I'm still very happy you did AND you're not getting it back! :-)
Appreciate your responses!!!
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
Why not do a kind of ‘pre-pub’ or ‘community pricing’ concept to guage support for new ideas and features (as well as books) and what people would be willing to pay?
This is what I appreciate about FL, that you can be responsive and make adjustments.
Sincerely hoping you can find the sweet spot where FL is profitable and successful, and we continue to subscribe and support the company!
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
I appreciate your acknowledging that our intention is not greed. And you're right.
Unfortunately, the math wasn't paying the bills. Logos Now needed a significant percentage of the user base to adopt it in order to cover ongoing development costs. Unfortunately, only a small portion of the customer base subscribed, and in most cases, that subscription resulted in a lower annual spend from those users. (People who previously upgraded with a combination of resources (which, as I point out, are how we get paid) and feature sets decided that they didn't need more resources, and were happy to just get feature upgrades from Logos Now at $9/month, for less revenue.)
Yes, as many of you point out, it was a killer deal and those who took advantage of it loved it. But with decreasing book sales to long-time customers (possibly because we're being punished for bad behavior, as some of you hint in this thread, but more likely because "I have so many books I don't need any more", as many others users expressed), it was too good a deal -- unless lots and lots of people took the deal and made up for it in volume.
(Note also that as the company ages, an increasing percentage of the user base by definition becomes 'mature, long-time customers' with large libraries. At the start everyone needs more books... over time, everyone wants new code / new updates / continued support, but fewer and fewer people, as a percentage, are new customers just starting to build their libraries.)
Logos Now was an awesome deal, and we tried hard to get everyone to see that. But while you did, not enough did.
Logos Now maxed out somewhere near 1.8% of our annual revenue. That doesn't come close to making a dent in the cost of delivering it, let alone driving new product development and support.
That's great -- that's exactly what the coupon was for. And maybe the subscription isn't the best option for you. I hope an upgrade to Logos 8 will seem worthwhile; that's a determination you'll have to make once you see the value. We have to do the same kind of value analysis to see how much we can spend on improvements based on revenue... which is why we're in this conversation: sometimes we guess right, and sometimes we guess wrong and have to adjust.
Bob, do you expect Logos 8 to be released before our Logos Now subscription expires (November 2018)? Otherwise it would be hard to know whether we should use our credit to buy the Logos 7 Full Feature set or to wait for the features that will come with Logos 8.
I have a question about connect and resources. If I subscribe to essentials, I then gain access to 144 digital books (sadly most of which I already own). I will then have access to these books for as long as I am a subscriber.
However, what happens when Logos 9 comes out? Are these connect tiers like the base packages where the books are periodically switched out for new ones with new versions of Logos? That could create a bad situation if I become accustomed to an expensive resource I have been renting during current life cycle (2 years potentially or whenever 9 comes). Then I might be faced with both price increases as well as having to purchase a resource I came to rely on but will lose access to even though I am still a subscriber. This is one reason I wish that essentials more closely matched what the term 'essentials' typically brings to mind, which is just the program, features, datasets, and maybe the free book offers.
Andre, do you actually save by waiting till Logos 8, especially if you're back to Logos 5 or 6. Personally, I had Logos 6 before hurling myself into LN. I figured I might as well buy Logos 7 and it will lessen the cost of 8 a little bit at least. What say ye?
MSI Pulse GL76-12UGK Intel Core i7-12700H, RTX3070, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home
I haven't seen anything official about when L8 will be released, but Phil recommended that it would be better to wait for L8.
According to the Phil's post, it works out better to wait. L8 introductory pricing would be one reason for the savings. Not sure what other factors make it cheaper to hold off.
Thanks to FL for including Carta and a Hebrew audio bible in Logos 9!
Hi Bob
Thanks for sharing.
I don’t feel hard done by: I never did sign up for Logos Now, and I don’t plan to sign up for Faithlife Connect.
I don’t want a subscription model. I don’t want temporary books that disappear after I’ve done the work of reading them and marking them up. I don’t want TV or video. I just want to keep researching the 8000 books I’ve bought over 10 years, and others I'm still buying.
Perhaps I’m the odd one out. Or perhaps there there is strong resistance to being dragged into a subscription model. Perhaps that's why “only a small portion of the customer base subscribed” to Logos Now.
Thanks for listening.
Bob,
Your willingness to interact here is always greatly appreciated.
The order for a new product seems to be (1) Public sales pitch, (2) Personal email, (3) Business rationale on the forums. LN had a public sales pitch focused on features but your business rationale here on the forums focussed on the need for a subscription model. Upset seems to have been caused with the new offerings as (1) came before (2) and (3).
With LN, I read your rationale to exegete the sales pitch, expected LN’s initial excitement to decline, and opted to give you my money through upgrades like L7 not subscription. I’m ready to part with cash to keep the software updated so I can keep using my resources and the great features. I prefer to buy because it is clearer what I am getting.
But, I am concerned by the bundling of Faithlife TV and mobile ed etc. Despite being a big Logos fan, and daily user, I advised a friend not to buy Logos 7 before Christmas but to wait to compare Logos 8 with the competition. This was because the base packages had too much breadth (like mobile ed) and lacked as many quality commentary series (like NAC) in the more affordable packages as previously – for day-to-day sermon-prep Logos 5/6 seemed to have better bundles.
I’m happy to continue to upgrade, even to subscribe if absolutely necessary – especially if L8 improves speed (the main Logos weakness). But, should a more costly bundle with TV etc be necessary, I would be forced to consider whether a switch to a more focussed (and faster) Bible Software product was prudent in the long run. I hope this won’t be the case.
Bob, I think you have missed the point of what your customers are telling you:
1. The value of Logos Now was early access to features (you know that, well documented here)
2. Which means the "extras" that were added in, were perceived to be of lower interest - FL has invested tons in a lot of ancillary products, services, offerings that are not profitable on their own, and never have been. Will they ever?
3. As Logos Now morphs into Connect, more ancillary products, services, offerings have been bundled in - and by necessity the price is doubled. Yet still people just want full access to all features of Logos - why would this succeed if the same thing on a lower scale failed in Logos Now?
So what happens next - if history repeats itself, that people won't be forced to pay by subscription for a lot of stuff they don't really want (that message is ALL OVER the threads on here), doesn't this just force everyone back to a purchase model? Aren't all the original business problems then still unaddressed satisfactorily?
The crux of the issue is that FL has developed a lot of extra stuff that is not profitable. People will not be forced to pay for them on subscription. What indicates that Logos Connect will be SIGNIFICANTLY more successful that the 1.8% of revenue of Logos Now, as that is what FL needs? It seems that the prudent business measure being ignored is to kill the extras that are not profitable if people don't want them.
Your post is golden. I hope Bob listens to you. Logos is simply not listening to what the market has been saying.
Exactly. This is simply repeating what has worked, hoping it will work this time. Is Logos depicting someone's definition of insanity?
Don, this would be a great analysis, except that one thing is reversed: those 'extra things' aren't the unprofitable part... it's the 'free' Bible software that's unprofitable. Selling it in a bundle model (bundled with books, and now other stuff) is what made the whole thing profitable.
Saying we should drop the ancillary stuff so we can keep the cost lower is a bit like saying the car dealer should not offer the free weatherproof floor mats, and just drop the price of the car in half. The floor mats weren't what was taking the price up.... :-)
At the root of this problem is that our component prices aren't lined up with our component costs.
When we build a bundle, of 'software + books + other stuff', we can price that bundle to cover the costs. And (for old and historic reasons) we acted like the cost to you was 0% for software, 100% for books, and 0% for other stuff.
That was never true -- the software got subsidized by the books. Now our costs are changing (need to code for multiple tech platforms, increased cost of software development, and more) while we've gotten better at books (they cost us less to make).
And at the same time, the market is changing: long-time customers want more books, want more attention on software development that while important, attracts fewer new customers (new customers notice new features; experienced customers want more performance and polishing), and less other stuff.... and the market is changing where publishers want higher royalties on the books and competitors (with different structures and costs) are pushing the price of ebooks down... and in-app purchasing on mobile (growing platform) wants a 30% cut of revenue, not profit...
So now we've got a cost structure for software + books + other stuff that may look more like:
80% + 10% + 10%
and users are saying "hey, I just want those software updates...maybe even just the free ones...and I have enough books and don't need that other stuff... so I'm willing to pay you 10% of the old bundle price -- just don't give me more books and other stuff I don't want."
Which sounds very generous if you think our costs are 0% + 80% + 20%. But they aren't.
I suppose one solution, as suggested here, is to force everyone to start paying for the software upgrades at a level that will cover their costs. But this is difficult for technical reasons (Apple doesn't let you update some mobile users and not others, and some updates are hard to gate to just some users without massive complexity)...
And in light of the firestorm we see here for annoying the (tiny!) percentage of users who bought Logos Now, how much greater would the firestorm be if we changed the long-promised 'software updates are free' model? I think people would burn down our buildings....
And this change doesn't break promises -- it just disappoints expectations. (We're delivering what we promised -- we just aren't continuing to offer this package in the future.) Changing the whole model to paid updates or your software goes stale / doesn't work on new operating systems would be actually breaking a promise.
Sure, other companies 'bake in' these future costs, but they have smaller software, generally sell subscription-only, and don't have 25+ years of legacy (and size) to support... and I'll guess they'll have abandoned their product / shipped completely new things long before 25 years pass....